The resources that you speak of wouldn't be available if tanny was here. We wouldn't have 12 picks in the draft either. Our cap situation and our number of pics are the result of the things that Idzik has done since he has been here. Idzik>>>>>Tanny hands down.
It may not be our job to judge him, but the evil that is in a person and causes them to do such horrible things doesn't just go away. Sure he may act different now, hasn't been in trouble, most respected player etc. Doesn't mean that he is a better person. Our only hope is that Geno beats him hands down and that he never sees the field. It will be extremely hard to watch if he plays.
I think it's too early to give up on Hill. If he does nothing this year then dump him, but there have have been many WR that breakout in their third year. Roddy White was once labeled a bust, until his third season now look at him.