I have been all in with Geno since we drafted him, mainly because his name is not Sanchez. I am not a big college football fan, so I have not seen him play much prior to the two pre-season games this year. I really hope I am wrong, but to me, Geno does not pass the eye test of an NFL QB. Forget about the interceptions, I could care less about them in a meaningless pre-season game against a top flight defense in his first start. I mean just watching him play the QB position, he does not look like a good NFL QB. His mechanics, his comfort level back there in the pocket, his presence as a QB, everything about him. He has a strong arm and throws a nice spiral, but that to me is where it ends.
I know a lot of guys pass the eye test, but suck as a QB, but I cannot think of one guy who is a really good NFL QB who fails the QB eye test. The closest who comes to my mind is Romo, but I think he sucks, others may disagree, and he looks comfortable, just has a really awkward throwing motion.
I hope I am wrong, but I don't like the looks of Geno as a QB.