Jump to content

49ers going with Rattay instead of Smith to start season


faba

Recommended Posts

Niners promote Rattay over No. 1 pick Smith

NFL.com wire reports

SANTA CLARA, Calif. (Aug. 23, 2005) -- Tim Rattay will be the San Francisco 49ers' starting quarterback for the season opener, reclaiming his job from No. 1 draft pick Alex Smith after only two preseason games.

Coach Mike Nolan announced the decision at the conclusion of the 49ers' first full practice following the death of offensive lineman Thomas Herrion, who collapsed in the locker room in Denver on Aug. 20.

The players and coaches seemed grateful to focus on something other than their grief and mourning -- and Smith, Herrion's college teammate and friend for two years at Utah, was able to put his first pro disappointment in perspective.

"I know how this works," Smith said. "This is a team game. This isn't all about me. I think the team wants to win now. We expect to win now, and as of right now, this looks like the right decision. Hopefully, I keep getting better and keep pushing it. Who knows what happens in the future? But right now, I understand it."

Smith struggled as the 49ers' starter in their first two preseason games, while Rattay was outstanding as the backup. Rattay started nine games for San Francisco last season in his only season as a first-stringer, but struggled all season with three injuries.

Rattay took the news with his usual placid demeanor. He has worked closely with Smith in training camp, and the players have developed a friendship that transcends their competition.

"I've been working hard, (and) I'd like to say I was excited to hear it," Rattay said. "I just felt like if I kept practicing hard, something good will happen. You can't get too upset or too happy in the course of training camp."

The first-team offense floundered with Smith in charge in the first two preseason games. He failed to lead San Francisco to a first down on his first four series of the preseason opener against Oakland, and he went through similar struggles in Denver.

Smith went 5-for-16 for 43 yards without a touchdown pass in the first two games, while Rattay was 13-for-19 for 194 yards and three TDs.

Nolan said the competition is closed, with Rattay remaining the starter for the season, barring injury. The coach began camp hoping Smith would win the job and discounting the wisdom of keeping a top draft pick out of action, but he had nothing but praise for both quarterbacks.

"I was pleased with both of them, but naturally Tim has showed the upper hand when it came to experience," Nolan said. "The rookie did a very good job for a guy that's had to come out and try to learn as much as he can. He's done everything to prove that we're right in our (draft) selection. He'll just get better and better and get closer to having that job, but in the meantime, it is Tim's job right now, and I look for him to perform well."

Carson Palmer, the No. 1 pick in 2003, spent his entire rookie season on the Cincinnati bench behind Jon Kitna. Phillip Rivers, the No. 4 pick in 2004, sat out last season behind Drew Brees in San Diego.

the 49ers in their situation have nothing to lose - I would get Smith in the lineup sooner to get experience

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I knew Smith was going to get drafted high....But I was never in love the fact he'd go #1 overall.

Back in like 1999, QB guru Brian Billick said something like this: "We've gotta make sure these young QB's are worth #1 picks, because too many teams talk themseleves into falsely believing that some are".

I think that's the deal with Smith: Good athlete, solid arm, real smart, excellent height...But was he really ready to be drafted that high with so little experience and being only 20 years old?

The fact that he put up the numbers in that wacky spread-offense, in the high scoring WAC, using the shot-gun 100% of the time, makes his numbers a little decieving.

He could be a good QB in time, but he's no Elway or Aikman (a almost given star)....49ers better be patient...

Of course, it doesn't help the 49ers have no WR's or RB's to speak of.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...