Smashmouth

My post seemed forced ? Now I'm the SK ? Let me tell you something about Nolder, he does come into many games as lazy town but if you read his posts this time was very different, he asked 2 people to fill him in on the game as if HE was forcing it. I've never seen him come into a thread and blatently ask people to look stuff up for him and fill him in on things he should have seen when doing his catch-up, Sorry but that's more than Lazy town to me. If you feel differently that's fine but don't say I forced it like you're trying to make some case based on what I said about Nolder because that's weak Crush.

you have to know explaining you're Meta as scum does not excuse you're actions in this game. I think that's a weak defense. Also, why would anyone feel the need to explain their Meta as scum ? It makes no sense to me Nolder

Ape is dead

I think what you're saying would be a bit too obvious on Nolder's part but he did come into the thread earlier asking others to fill him in on the status of the game. I'm not sure wtf hes doing but it certainly does not look town too me. Nolder has done this in other games and flipped town so could he just be staying consistent as a cover ?

think about what you said here and then think about what you forgot to do !! Traditions my friend traditions

I had the same feelings toward Brick, he pounced quickly with no real explanation at all as to why he would vote stark. Even after our explanations on why LK was full of crap he seemed to just ignore our posts and not even question why we did what we did which I would not expect from a new player about to hammer.

vote Nolder Did not like him coming into the thread asking others to fill him in on the current situation. Seemed like he was trying to play his usual lazy town routine and may very well be the SK lower chance of scum but I do not think hes town.

I'm not wasting anyone's time and for you to suggest that is pinging since others are still discussing this very topic and how you handled it and why you voted . I said what I had to say and I'm ready to move on so we can agree to disagree but you will have to address those issues at some point

Crush great post . Chan I would have played it exactly how you describe.

I dont have a problem with what stark did at all. I do have a problem with people thinking he should have done it on day 1 and possibly play right into scum's hands. I took the Counter claim for what it was and thought of my own reasons why someone would do that and no way in hell did I ever think scum was counter claiming and basically giving themselves up. I'ts ridiculous to think that was the case regardless of what Stark said I know for a fact that's why you held your vote

he didnt call out scum on day 1 because no way scum was going to hurt us at that point. It had the feel like scum wanted to out the cop but thats just my opinion and playing into scums hands is not a good town play . We can debate this all day but in a 17 player game why out the cop on day 1 ? Even if Stark got killed we would have had LK dead to rights anyway after the death scene its not like LK was an investigation result

sometimes you just need to look past what someone is saying and do what the game mechanics say you should do. Its real easy to go into a tirade and not make much sense when people don't believe you. I used to do that but I've calmed down the last few games and it helps me think clearer. In this case we had to step back and ask why would scum counter claim on day 2 ? Would have been dreadfully dumb play yet most thought thats what Stark did and hes by no means a dumb player.

You are a Buffoon there is no way in holy hell you are living tomorrow all those insults make sense now you were in total survival mode and had no freaking clue how to counter what I was saying. I guess in the end you outed our ******* cop so....

if Ape did protect him it would have been the right choice since at the time there was no counter ... missing on one protect would not have been the end of the world