Jump to content


  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Barmacral

  1. Did you ever consider going hard after Wombat and claim he was scum, knowing he was Loki?

    The town caught on that Loki-hunting was a scum tell. If you went hard after Wombat, claiming he was scum and he flipped Loki, you wouldve earned capital and looked more townish.

    But why was it a scum tell? Loki was a much bigger threat to town than he was to scum (we were more of a threat to ourselves than wombat ever was) and by not Loki hunting sooner you still managed to lose the game.

  2. Eh, I took a gamble on not voting Ape, knew if he went down I'd likely follow quickly after. My problem was that I ended up having a week of 12 hour shifts which I wasn't expecting (knew I'd have one day, but that was it). As a result even though I made it on and posted every day I wasn't around and didn't have the energy to spend on the game that I'd have liked.


    Once I was able to pay some real attention to the game I was the main lynch and managed to get a train run up on Nolder (and saw him self destruct which was hilarious) and Seph before you guys got your acts together and lynched me (I know, Lizzie and a couple others get a lot of the credit for those trains too). I also figured out that Pac was our roleblocker, and while Seph could have been Loki I liked Pac's wombat theory better but Seph was one of my best bets to get somebody other than me lynched and I was trying very hard to stay alive.


    So yeah, not a great game for me, my activity was too low and my Ape gamble cost me hard. However I did not "Forget how to bus" and did reasonably well when I was around so GFY.


    Also awesome game Kiv, I did thoroughly enjoy it.

  3. Oh btw here's thoughts on others:


    CTM - Most likely town

    Nae - possible scum

    SMC - possible Loki / Scum

    Pac - Townish

    Alanna - Neutral

    Wombat - possible Loki / scum

    JC - Prob town

    Nolder - Prob scum

    80 - Neutral

    JiF - prob town

    Seph - Prob loki

    Barm - Town


    I think I got everyone.

    • Thumb Down 1
  4. 1. Prior to voting Ape I actually stopped vote hopping. There was about an hour between when I asked Ape to address me and when I voted him. Not that any of that really matters imo. You can construe innocence or guilt from any of that depending on your preference or preconceived notions.


    2. We all agreed that Lily was playing up the AtE too much. Like I said after she flipped some things are better left unsaid even if they're true. Telling people you're an easy lynch isn't going to make them want to lynch you less it just makes them wonder if you're trying to manipulate them into not lynching them by saying that. I don't much regret the Lily lynch. It made sense at the time, although we could have stretched it out a bit longer. There was no need to rush it.


    1. Likely guilt since it goes so against what your playstyle is, it looks too much like you were protecting a teammate and realised there was no point in going down with the ship for me to just ignore.


    2. While valid points, these don't contradict anything I've said regarding your place on the lynch and how easy it was to hide on that train.

  5. Ok so mostly Nolder played a fairly neutral game, but there's two things that stand out to me.




    Alright I waited long enough.

    I think Ape is avoiding addressing me.


    Unvote Vote Ape


     This is the vote where he failed to policy lynch Ape for self-voting before finally bringing it up to L-1 when Wombat pointed it out. Before this he spent a lot of time vote-hopping. A teammate hoping to avoid the big train and eventually realising he couldn't?



    Barm (1) - CTM

    Lily (8) - 80, Jetscode, Nolder, Lizzie, SMC, JiF, Seph, Pac
    Lizzie (1) - Lily


    I don't know why this quote shows as Nolder, it was Doggin's post that I was quoting. Anyways according to this vote count he was the third person on Lily's speed lynch. This is an easy bandwagon spot on a person that was easy to lynch. An excellent place for him to hide in the train. By itself it wouldn't be notable but accompanied with his vote on the Ape and his attempt to shut down conversation now before going completely nuts it screams potential scum. He could also be Loki but I'd more likely expect him to be scum.

  6. VC is off. Here I'll fix it.


    Vote Barm


    Apparently some mother****ers don't want me to be hammer. Ok, sure, fine whatever. Let someone else do it I guess.

    Now it's out of my hands. Tie train. Make a decision.


    Nolder, does this not read as being melodramatic to you? This is why I thought you were being hard on the mod, your attitude towards his mistake.

  7. You're just repeating what others just said.  What did he do Days 1 and 2 that were scummy?  Build a case.  Convince me.


    Night two I targetted him because I had no real read on him yet. I'm looking, but it takes time because I am also needing to re-evaluate his past actions in light of his current ones.

  8. Dude, your last actual case is from like page 76.  You should be battling like hell to make a case for someone else right now.  I will have no remorse if you flip town.


    How about Nolder? Guy is saying I should give up, threatening to hammer when I'm L-2, blaming it on his mistakes and then giving the mod a hard time when the mod makes the same mistake. I'd say he's flailing.

  9. I'm really not arguing your point there. Makes sense to me. I am not voting you anymore. I think we just caught Nolder anyway.


    Fair enough.



    Well I'm not sure there's anything you could say at this point that would save you.

    I like most of the people voting you for town so I'm not too worried about it being a scum train, you said you didn't get any results on your night actions and told us your targets, you told us your suspects.


    Is there anything else you want to talk about that wasn't already discussed?


    Two people have unvoted me since I showed up, so while it is possible that it is too late to save myself, this idea that all possible discussion is done and I might as well shut up and go away is stupid and scummy as hell.

  10. Barm without more posts how are we supposed to figure out whether you're town or not?

    Eliminating someone with low t postcount removes an unknown from the game.

    It isn't our fault your postcount is low.


    My post count is low but I've voted and shared my suspicions and responded to people interacting with me. I've got plenty of content out there and it isn't my fault if people aren't smart enough to glean any useful information from it.

  11. By the way Wombat and SMC are sketchy. SMC for his hammer on Ape after two days of silence and his weird "JiF is Loki but I won't vote Loki" and Wombat becuase his "Barm is null and here is my vote immediately". Eventually he justified himself but still contradictory. JC is probably town despite his horrid play in day 1. I think his interactions with Ape were too legit to be scum team.

  • Create New...