Jump to content

Overall Grade  

88 members have voted

  1. 1. I give the Jets a grade of.....

    • A+
      3
    • A
      4
    • A-
      6
    • B+
      22
    • B
      16
    • B-
      7
    • C+
      4
    • C
      11
    • C-
      5
    • D+
      2
    • D
      1
    • D-
      1
    • F+
      0
    • F
      4
    • F-
      2


Recommended Posts

What overall grade do you give the Jets for their 2017 draft picks?

  1. Round 1 Jamal Adams    S    6'0"    214    LSU    
  2. Round 2    Marcus Maye    S    6'0"    210    Florida    
  3. Round 3    ArDarius Stewart WR    5'11"    204    Alabama        
  4. Round 4    Chad Hansen    WR    6'2"    202    California        
  5. Round 5 Jordan Leggett    TE    6'5"    258    Clemson    
  6. Round 5    Dylan Donahue    DL    6'3"    248    West Georgia    
  7. Round 6 Elijah McGuire    RB    5'10"    214    Louisiana-Lafayette       
  8. Round 6 Jeremy Clark    CB    6'3"    220    Michigan   
  9. Round 6 Derrick Jones    CB    6'2"    188    Mississippi
Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, Sarge4Tide said:

What overall grade do you give the Jets for their 2017 draft picks?

  1. Round 1 Jamal Adams    S    6'0"    214    LSU    
  2. Round 2    Marcus Maye    S    6'0"    210    Florida    
  3. Round 3    ArDarius Stewart WR    5'11"    204    Alabama        
  4. Round 4    Chad Hansen    WR    6'2"    202    California        
  5. Round 5 Jordan Leggett    TE    6'5"    258    Clemson    
  6. Round 5    Dylan Donahue    DL    6'3"    248    West Georgia    
  7. Round 6 Elijah McGuire    RB    5'10"    214    Louisiana-Lafayette       
  8. Round 6 Jeremy Clark    CB    6'3"    220    Michigan   
  9. Round 6 Derrick Jones    CB    6'2"    188    Mississippi

I'll let you know in 3 years 😉

  • Upvote 4
Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm happy with this draft. The Jets were not 2 picks away form winning the superbowl. It was all about getting pieces and positioning themselves. I think they did that. I'll give it a B+, maybe just a B because I'm disappointed at no extra OL, and we could have maybe used a better edge rusher/OLB. But overall it seems solid. 

  • Upvote 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

B overall

Love Adams, like the two WR's in three and four, Jeremy Clark is an interesting flier - the only really confusing thing to me is that we chose absolutely no offensive lineman or edge rushers and drafted a second safety over Dalvin Cook.  But I like Maye as a player and think he'll be good, I just can't give it an A.

  • Upvote 2
Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, OH THE PAIN said:

How do we grade a draft before anyone has played a game with their new team ?

 

Give a grade immediately after so we can look back at which one of us were the cool-aid drinking fools or sorry-old-plane haters that sh*t on everything.  But you're right, other than that, its meaningless.  

Link to post
Share on other sites

It felt like that time I bought an REM album and immediately found it that objectively sucked, but a few pretentious ****boys tried explaining to me that it was good only to find out that those same ****boys didn't like it either but just said they did in an attempt to appear learned.

Link to post
Share on other sites
20 minutes ago, Sarge4Tide said:

What overall grade do you give the Jets for their 2017 draft picks?

  1. Round 1 Jamal Adams    S    6'0"    214    LSU    
  2. Round 2    Marcus Maye    S    6'0"    210    Florida    
  3. Round 3    ArDarius Stewart WR    5'11"    204    Alabama        
  4. Round 4    Chad Hansen    WR    6'2"    202    California        
  5. Round 5 Jordan Leggett    TE    6'5"    258    Clemson    
  6. Round 5    Dylan Donahue    DL    6'3"    248    West Georgia    
  7. Round 6 Elijah McGuire    RB    5'10"    214    Louisiana-Lafayette       
  8. Round 6 Jeremy Clark    CB    6'3"    220    Michigan   
  9. Round 6 Derrick Jones    CB    6'2"    188    Mississippi

We waited too long to trade back. i love the tall long corners though. The RB seems like a stretch  - but that pick is totally a scouting based pick. They saw something in this kid. BUT  - we drafted good kids that want to smack people in the mouth. Hungry. 

  • Upvote 2
Link to post
Share on other sites
7 minutes ago, greenwave81 said:

Just have a hard time justifying 2 S picks in the top 39.  Maybe it works out, but swap out Mayes for Cook and I'd give this an A+.

But I ain't an NFL GM.

I think the off field stuff plus a medical scared them about taking Cook too early. Remember Terrell Davis  - 6th rounder!

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
9 minutes ago, T0mShane said:

It felt like that time I bought an REM album and immediately found it that objectively sucked, but a few pretentious ****boys tried explaining to me that it was good only to find out that those same ****boys didn't like it either but just said they did in an attempt to appear learned.

Was it the one when they didn't have a drummer? Or the other one? Or the one immediately before or after that one? Or was it...wait, what are we talking about?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Gave it an A-. Two real meh things were doubling down at safety and not getting an OL ( although this wasn't a good OL draft)

 On the other hand, he got a TE, 4 secondary players, 2 WRs, a pass rusher and a running back.

What makes me hopeful about his late picks is that in the first two years that he has been here, he has gotten some value from  late round picks.

(Deion Simon, Charone Peake, Brandon Shell etc.)

 

  • Upvote 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Tough draft to grade. I really like Adams, Hansen, and Leggett. Luke warm on Stewart, Donahue and Mcguire. Don't get Maye, Clark or Jones.

 

Maye is a good player, but he's almost TOO interchangeable with Adams. It could be a really good pairing, but it could very well be susceptible to the long game. Hopefully I'm wrong and they end up a stellar pair, but I would have preferred a rangier safety than Maye.

 

C+/B-?

Link to post
Share on other sites
8 minutes ago, T0mShane said:

Just gonna chill in here to see which dude is the first to load up the thread with gifs of Dylan Donahue wrecking shop vs a community college squad. 

I just like to watch guys that own cats pretend that they have seen more than a handful of any of these players,  and pretend know how that will translate to the pro game

  • Upvote 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

I think history will judge the Jets very unfavorably on the players they passed on in the third round. 

They were supposed to get lower round picks for Sheldon and Pryor rather than trading down,  They likely held out for too much.  

Link to post
Share on other sites
5 minutes ago, Scott Dierking said:

I just like to watch guys that own cats pretend that they have seen more than a handful of any of these players,  and pretend know how that will translate to the pro game

Why you gotta bring my cats into this, Scott? 

  • Upvote 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
54 minutes ago, Sarge4Tide said:

What overall grade do you give the Jets for their 2017 draft picks?

  1. Round 1 Jamal Adams    S    6'0"    214    LSU    
  2. Round 2    Marcus Maye    S    6'0"    210    Florida    
  3. Round 3    ArDarius Stewart WR    5'11"    204    Alabama        
  4. Round 4    Chad Hansen    WR    6'2"    202    California        
  5. Round 5 Jordan Leggett    TE    6'5"    258    Clemson    
  6. Round 5    Dylan Donahue    DL    6'3"    248    West Georgia    
  7. Round 6 Elijah McGuire    RB    5'10"    214    Louisiana-Lafayette       
  8. Round 6 Jeremy Clark    CB    6'3"    220    Michigan   
  9. Round 6 Derrick Jones    CB    6'2"    188    Mississippi

FWIW you should add the 2018 5th rounder to this list.

  • Upvote 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



×
×
  • Create New...