Of these 3 QBs, which is the biggest risk?

[jetstream23]

Which QB has the biggest risk associated with him in your opinion?  None of these guys, even Darnold, is perfect.  And, each of them seems to have a different kind of risk.  Josh Allen's accuracy and decision-making have some thinking he's the guy who still needs the most development.  Baker Mayfield is clearly one of the shortest top QB prospects in years, if not decades, and some are concerned about his attitude, arrogance, etc.  Josh Rosen looks the most pro-ready but his injury history, particularly concussions, and questions about his love of the game have some thinking he's a big risk.

The questions we'd have to consider are things like....Is Josh Allen a bigger, stronger Hackenberg?  Is Baker Mayfield more Brooks Bollinger than Russell Wilson?  Is Josh Rosen going to be the next NFL player to retire early after another concussion or two?

So, of those 3, who is the biggest risk?  The guy you're really gun-shy about taking?

And, let me be clear on this, you CAN think a guy is the most risky and still want to take him because of his upside.  THIS IS NOT the same question as Which QB do you want no part of at #3?

[Patriot Killa]

All I know is, Josh Allen has nothing to worry about. He played in the Grande Ronde conference where you are forced to play well or else owners of surrounding Indian casinos will put a price on your head for jeopardizing their earnings in illegal bets.

He’s built for teh pressure.

[jetstream23]

1 hour ago, Patriot Killa said:

All I know is, Josh Allen has nothing to worry about. He played in the Grande Ronde conference where you are forced to play well or else owners of surrounding Indian casinos will put a price on your head for jeopardizing their earnings in illegal bets.

He’s built for teh pressure.

I'm sold!

You should be his agent.

[Dcat]

There are diff't kinds of risks. 

Medically: Rosen

Inability to adjust to NFL: tough one...  Allen I'd say although there is merit to Mayfield's limitations.

[jack48]

14 hours ago, jetstream23 said:

Which QB has the biggest risk associated with him in your opinion?  None of these guys, even Darnold, is perfect.  And, each of them seems to have a different kind of risk.  Josh Allen's accuracy and decision-making have some thinking he's the guy who still needs the most development.  Baker Mayfield is clearly one of the shortest top QB prospects in years, if not decades, and some are concerned about his attitude, arrogance, etc.  Josh Rosen looks the most pro-ready but his injury history, particularly concussions, and questions about his love of the game have some thinking he's a big risk.

The questions we'd have to consider are things like....Is Josh Allen a bigger, stronger Hackenberg?  Is Baker Mayfield more Brooks Bollinger than Russell Wilson?  Is Josh Rosen going to be the next NFL player to retire early after another concussion or two?

So, of those 3, who is the biggest risk?  The guy you're really gun-shy about taking?

And, let me be clear on this, you think a guy is the most risky and still want to take him because of his upside.  THIS IS NOT the same question as Which QB do you want no part of at #3?

injury rusk