If you could draft ONE of these QB’s in their prime..which would it be?

[Patriot Killa]

[Patriot Killa]

Peyton Manning 4 me... you will never catch me saying Tom Brady. Manning actually should of been a Jet in real life if it wasn’t for Parcells stubbornness.

[King P]

Marino definitely

[SayNoToDMC]

Manning. His team was so awful they got Luck when he went down. They would have won 11 games if he was healthy

[rex-n-effect]

Manning easily. Great player who could lead an offense on the field even when he was physically past his prime. 

I don't know how a team hasn't found the right amount of money (pro or college) to get him to come be an offensive coach or consultant. He doesn't need the money but disappointing to see his ability to read a defense and call plays on the fly lost to the game.

[Grandy]

Peyton Manning, it's not even close.

He's broken every single season record including rating, tds, and yards.

He's broken nearly every career record.

He's the best to ever do it.

[joewilly12]

Tom Brady the best QB I've seen play the game in my lifetime. 

[Patriot Killa]

Just now, joewilly12 said:

Tom Brady the best QB I've seen play the game in my lifetime. 

He’s a fuxking cheat!

[Untouchable]

Montana

[Patriot Killa]

19 minutes ago, rex-n-effect said:

Manning easily. Great player who could lead an offense on the field even when he was physically past his prime. 

I don't know how a team hasn't found the right amount of money (pro or college) to get him to come be an offensive coach or consultant. He doesn't need the money but disappointing to see his ability to read a defense and call plays on the fly lost to the game.

Well, he had a nice little thing with Papa Johns going before they decided to cut the NFL partnership...he still has NationWide insurance 

[MDL_JET]

Didn’t see Marino, Elway or Montana play. 

But Peyton. He was so much fun to watch him orchestrate the offense every snap, calling guys out. Was a true surgeon. 

[Kevin L]

12 minutes ago, Untouchable said:

Montana

Montana easily. One of the most clutch players I've seen in any sport.

[Jimmy 2 Times]

I followed the entire career of every player on this list.  Every one of them has merit to be considered and it's really hard to pick because the rules have changed over the years.  Manning and Brady didn't have to deal with the super defensive units of the 80's where pass interference wasn't called and you could kill the passer.

 

I do know one thing: Montana beat everyone he faced on the list and took a physical beating while doing it.

[Embrace the Suck]

Are the players playing when the defense could be physical or now?

[New York Mick]

Elway

[rex-n-effect]

20 minutes ago, Patriot Killa said:

Well, he had a nice little thing with Papa Johns going before they decided to cut the NFL partnership...he still has NationWide insurance 

And he has other business dealings. Definitely does not need the money and probably wants to enjoy some Sundays away from the game.

I just think any team that hasn't picked up the phone to see what might get him in the building is crazy, especially considering he's played recently enough that he has on-field knowledge of current teams and coaching staffs.

[Jetsfan80]

43 minutes ago, rex-n-effect said:

Manning easily. Great player who could lead an offense on the field even when he was physically past his prime. 

I don't know how a team hasn't found the right amount of money (pro or college) to get him to come be an offensive coach or consultant. He doesn't need the money but disappointing to see his ability to read a defense and call plays on the fly lost to the game.

Some guys are so good at what they do, it's useless for them to try to teach it to mere mortals.  They can't relate to the guys who need a lot of work.  

Much like Ted Williams when he was a manager.  A .350 hitter trying to teach .230 guys just didn't work.  His mind was on a whole other level.  

[56mehl56]

I believe Elway would dominate in today's NFL. 

[southparkcpa]

53 minutes ago, rex-n-effect said:

Manning easily. Great player who could lead an offense on the field even when he was physically past his prime. 

I don't know how a team hasn't found the right amount of money (pro or college) to get him to come be an offensive coach or consultant. He doesn't need the money but disappointing to see his ability to read a defense and call plays on the fly lost to the game.

If you want to play golf in January, Manning is your guy.   There is no better QB ever than Brady.  He has made GREAT receivers out of midget throwaways.  He gets rid of the ball as fast as Marino, can’t remember the last time he won less than 12 games . Oh and there’s that 5 SB wins , 8 appearances thing.  I stopped hating it a few years ago and just learn to appreciate it.  It’s like a Red Sox fan watching Jeter. 

[Charlie Brown]

38 minutes ago, MDL_JET said:

Didn’t see Marino, Elway or Montana play. 

But Peyton. He was so much fun to watch him orchestrate the offense every snap, calling guys out. Was a true surgeon. 

Wow !!

You are just such knowledgeable poster and I just assume we have all seen these guys but based on that you can not go wrong with Peyton Manning!! 

[Sonny Werblin]

51 minutes ago, Untouchable said:

Montana

Best big game QB ever. You could only beat him if you injured him.

[MDL_JET]

5 minutes ago, Charlie Brown said:

Wow !!

You are just such knowledgeable poster and I just assume we have all seen these guys but based on that you can not go wrong with Peyton Manning!! 

Ha I didn’t start watching football/Jets until about 2002 when Pennington was starting. Before then I was all about the 90s Knicks. 

[Patriot Killa]

9 minutes ago, Charlie Brown said:

Wow !!

You are just such knowledgeable poster and I just assume we have all seen these guys but based on that you can not go wrong with Peyton Manning!! 

I only seen Manning and Brady play, myself.

[Larz]

Joe

John

Brett 

 

[T0mShane]

Peyton Manning is the Carmelo Anthony of the NFL, except Carmelo won in college. 

[Patriot Killa]

2 minutes ago, T0mShane said:

Peyton Manning is the Carmelo Anthony of the NFL, except Carmelo won in college. 

Chill ouuuuutttttt! Where is Melo’s ring? Why did Melo get traded from the Nuggets and Peyton stayed the face of his franchise until he hurt his neck and was let go.

[Charlie Brown]

10 minutes ago, Patriot Killa said:

I only seen Manning and Brady play, myself.

You guys are killing me.........  

Time for this for me .......

[Patriot Killa]

1 minute ago, Charlie Brown said:

You guys are killing me.........  

Time for this for me .......

I was born in 96’ man what can I say??

[Charlie Brown]

2 minutes ago, Patriot Killa said:

I was born in 96’ man what can I say??

What!!!

I have tube socks older than you!!!

 

[Patriot Killa]

Just now, Charlie Brown said:

What!!!

I have tube socks older than you!!!

 

Lol yep. I’ll be at the ripe old age of 22 years old on March 29th. 

 

 

So i expect a F-n birthday thread for future reference.??

[RoadFan]

I feeel privileged to have seen Marino throw the football.  Like a masterpiece work of art. 

F*ck Brady.

[Patriot Killa]

Just now, RoadFan said:

I feeel privileged to have seen Marino throw the football.  Like a masterpiece work of art. 

F*ck Brady.

Is Rosen’s passes really similar to Marino’s like they say?

[Larz]

1 hour ago, Grandy said:

Peyton Manning, it's not even close.

He's broken every single season record including rating, tds, and yards.

He's broken nearly every career record.

He's the best to ever do it.

In the wussy Era 

Montana and Elway played when defense was allowed and you could hit the QB 

[Untouchable]

3 minutes ago, Patriot Killa said:

Is Rosen’s passes really similar to Marino’s like they say?

Allen is the guy being compared to Marino. 

 

[peebag]

Holy crapola...

It's John Elway and it's not even close.