THE BARON 174 #1 Posted November 13 Hello... I saw the previous post about assembling the Jets all time defense. Some nice picks and info... Anyone wanna take a crack at offense + special teams ??? LT- Birck (post Faneca arrival) * I would list Winston Hill, but I never saw him play LG: Faneca (his early tenure with the Jets) Center: Mangold TE: Mickey Shuler RG: Dan Alexander RT: Marvin Powell RB1: Freeman McNeil RB2 (pick a full back or scat back): Leon Washington WR1; Wesley Walker WR2: Al Toon Slot: Wayne Chrebet QB: Chad (before first injury) Punt/Kick Return: Bruce Harper K. Pat Layhey P. Dave Jennings 2 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
More Cowbell 1,510 #2 Posted November 13 I would just change FB Scat to Richie Anderson 3 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
THE BARON 174 #3 Posted November 13 5 minutes ago, More Cowbell said: I would just change FB Scat to Richie Anderson Nice pass catching back for sure. A must for the Tuna Jets... 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Green DNA 174,344 #4 Posted November 13 1980 is the beginning of time apparently. 2 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
pointman 2,519 #5 Posted November 13 No Stephen Hill?? 1 2 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Saul Goodman 2,789 #6 Posted November 13 Curtis Martin is arguably the best Jet player ever. Loved McNeil but have to give #28 the nod at RB. 5 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
pointman 2,519 #7 Posted November 13 32 minutes ago, THE BARON said: RB2 (pick a full back or scat back): Leon Washington Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Beerfish 19,262 #8 Posted November 13 Chad is the best Qb this team has ever had? ☹️ 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
The Crimson King 1,534 #9 Posted November 13 substitute: Winston Hill for Ferguson Dave German for Faneca Matt Snell for Leon (run. block. catch) Don Maynard and George Sauer for Toon and Chrebet but how you line up Sauer. Maynard and Walker, not so sure Namath at QB but after he learned to protect the ball and before his knees were just too bad to even hobble Joe McKnight on KO's Dick Cristy on PR (unless Titans don't count in which case, Santana Moss) P: Lac Edwards (Jennings averaged under 40 yds per here) Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
CurtMart 268 #10 Posted November 13 1 hour ago, THE BARON said: Hello... I saw the previous post about assembling the Jets all time defense. Some nice picks and info... Anyone wanna take a crack at offense + special teams ??? LT- Birck (post Faneca arrival) * I would list Winston Hill, but I never saw him play LG: Faneca (his early tenure with the Jets) Center: Mangold TE: Mickey Shuler RG: Dan Alexander RT: Marvin Powell RB1: Freeman McNeil RB2 (pick a full back or scat back): Leon Washington WR1; Wesley Walker WR2: Al Toon Slot: Wayne Chrebet QB: Chad (before first injury) Punt/Kick Return: Bruce Harper K. Pat Layhey P. Dave Jennings So McNeil over a HoF RB? Ok. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
rangerous 2,374 #11 Posted November 13 i think i'd consider lach edwards for jennings. maybe vinny for chad. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
rangerous 2,374 #12 Posted November 13 8 minutes ago, CurtMart said: So McNeil over a HoF RB? Ok. no doubt curtis martin was a really good back but imo mcneil was more talented. mcneil had injury problems. 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
THE BARON 174 #13 Posted November 13 17 minutes ago, CurtMart said: So McNeil over a HoF RB? Ok. It is questionable, but I think FM had more skills when he was at his best. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
TeddEY 255,538 #14 Posted November 13 1 hour ago, THE BARON said: QB: Chad (before first injury) I was going to put in Favre as my QB, just for the reactions, but it seems you've already outdone that. 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
TeddEY 255,538 #15 Posted November 13 Brett Favre and Ladanian Tomlinson/Leveon Bell 2 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Losmeister 2,889 #16 Posted November 13 1 hour ago, Saul Goodman said: Curtis Martin is arguably the best Jet player ever. Loved McNeil but have to give #28 the nod at RB. from my observations- only thing curtis was better at was durability. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
peebag 4,889 #17 Posted November 13 1 hour ago, Saul Goodman said: Curtis Martin is arguably the best Jet player ever. Loved McNeil but have to give #28 the nod at RB. <cough><cough>John Riggins<cough><cough> 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
THE BARON 174 #18 Posted November 13 10 minutes ago, TeddEY said: I was going to put in Favre as my QB, just for the reactions, but it seems you've already outdone that. Chad would be a smart pick. The important stat is the W's, not passing yards. Chad would give you the best TD to interception number and probably the best third down conversion percentage. Leadership is also off the charts. Though, with Chad, instead of my choice of Walker, Toon and Chrebet, I'd probably be better off with Key, Toon and Chrebet. Key over Walker for Chad who would need possession receivers over field stretchers. 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Beerfish 19,262 #19 Posted November 13 47 minutes ago, TeddEY said: Brett Favre and Ladanian Tomlinson/Leveon Bell To this day I think that if we retained Favre in rex's 1st year we win a super bowl. 1 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
chirorob 3,064 #20 Posted November 13 2 hours ago, THE BARON said: Hello... I saw the previous post about assembling the Jets all time defense. Some nice picks and info... Anyone wanna take a crack at offense + special teams ??? LT- Birck (post Faneca arrival) * I would list Winston Hill, but I never saw him play LG: Faneca (his early tenure with the Jets) Center: Mangold TE: Mickey Shuler RG: Dan Alexander RT: Marvin Powell RB1: Freeman McNeil RB2 (pick a full back or scat back): Leon Washington WR1; Wesley Walker WR2: Al Toon Slot: Wayne Chrebet QB: Chad (before first injury) Punt/Kick Return: Bruce Harper K. Pat Layhey P. Dave Jennings You took Leon Washington over Matt Snell? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
CSNY 64 #21 Posted November 13 Like most of the selection but an argument can be made for these guys Dan Alexander at LG Matt Snell at FB Don Maynard at WR Joe Namath Winston Hill Jerome Barkum Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
johnnysd 4,904 #22 Posted November 13 2 hours ago, Saul Goodman said: Curtis Martin is arguably the most overated Jet player ever. Loved McNeil and Martin couldn't hold his jock Fixed Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
THE BARON 174 #23 Posted November 13 20 minutes ago, chirorob said: You took Leon Washington over Matt Snell? never saw Matt Snell play. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
greenwichjetfan 2,955 #24 Posted November 13 LT: Brandon Shell LG: James Carpenter C : Spencer Long RG: Brian Winters RT: Brent Qvale TE: Doug Jolley WR1: David Clowney WR2: Curtis Conway SlotWR: Wallace Wright RB: Lamont Jordan QB: Chad Pennington 2 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Greenbloodblitz 636 #25 Posted November 13 15 minutes ago, greenwichjetfan said: LT: Brandon Shell LG: James Carpenter C : Spencer Long RG: Brian Winters RT: Brent Qvale TE: Doug Jolley WR1: David Clowney WR2: Curtis Conway SlotWR: Wallace Wright RB: Lamont Jordan QB: Chad Pennington Wallace Wright was an excellent football player Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
BklynJetsFan85 180 #26 Posted November 13 Agree with some of yours LT- DBrick LG: Faneca Center: Mangold TE: Mickey Shuler RG: Dan Alexander RT: Marvin Powell RB1: Curtis Martin RB2 Chris Ivory (bruising goal line type back) WR1; Don Maynard WR2: Al TooN Slot: Wayne Chrebet QB: Chad (before first injury) Punt/Kick Return: Leon Washington K. Pat Leahy P. Tom Tupa Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Copernicus 422 #27 Posted November 13 LT- Ferguson LG: Faneca Center: Mangold TE: Mickey Shuler RG: Brandon Moore RT: Damien Woody RB1: Freeman McNeil RB2: Curtis Martin WR1; Al Toon WR2: Wesley Walker Slot: Wayne Chrebet QB: Ken O'Brien Punt/Kick Return: Leon Washington K. John Hall P. Dave Jennings Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
GuitarJet 31 #28 Posted November 13 Fun post! Thanks for doing this Its a great start but as a 59 year old Jets fan I have some tweaks FWIW. LT- Winston Hill, I did see him play - he was a beast! LG: Faneca (his early tenure with the Jets) yup! Center: Mangold No question TE: Mickey Shuler, (2nd Tight End Rich Caster - was money in the clutch, made Richard Todd look like an NFL QB at times) RG: Dan Alexander (Yup) RT: Marvin Powell (Yup..... loved this guy's motor) RB1: Emerson Boozer (OK this one's an emotional pick, I met him when I was 8. Great man!) RB2 (pick a full back or scat back): LeVeon Bell. I would love to see him with the O-Line above WR1; Wesley Walker (No contest) WR2: Don Maynard (He was FUN to watch! He and Brett Favre would be electric!) Slot: Wayne Chrebet (Say no more) QB: Brett Favre... (Namath was a gunslinger, Farve was gunslinger with better knees!) Punt/Kick Return: Bruce Harper - yup K. Pat Layhey (was consistent for so long, might go with Jason Meyers with the new rules) P. Dave Jennings (yup!) Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
papz187 317 #29 Posted November 13 substitute: Winston Hill for Ferguson Dave German for Faneca Matt Snell for Leon (run. block. catch) Don Maynard and George Sauer for Toon and Chrebet but how you line up Sauer. Maynard and Walker, not so sure Namath at QB but after he learned to protect the ball and before his knees were just too bad to even hobble Joe McKnight on KO's Dick Cristy on PR (unless Titans don't count in which case, Santana Moss) P: Lac Edwards (Jennings averaged under 40 yds per here)McKnight on Kick return duties over Brad Smith, Leon Washington or Chad Morton? No way....I might even have Justin Miller over McKnight.Overall I'd take Brad Smith on KOs......guy was great despite not having the same speed as some of the others mentioned.Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
nyjunc 10,302 #30 Posted November 13 23 minutes ago, papz187 said: McKnight on Kick return duties over Brad Smith, Leon Washington or Chad Morton? No way....I might even have Justin Miller over McKnight. Overall I'd take Brad Smith on KOs......guy was great despite not having the same speed as some of the others mentioned. Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk McKnight probably wouldn't be top 10 as a KR because he fumbled so many times. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
The Crimson King 1,534 #31 Posted November 13 5 minutes ago, papz187 said: McKnight on Kick return duties over Brad Smith, Leon Washington or Chad Morton? No way....I might even have Justin Miller over McKnight. Overall I'd take Brad Smith on KOs......guy was great despite not having the same speed as some of the others mentioned. Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk McKnight: 29.0 yds per return, 76 returns, 2TD Smith: 26.6/74/3 Washington: 25.5/117/4 Morton: 25.1/70/2 Miller: 26.9/114/3 I guess you can make an argument for any one of them also for comparison sake: Roberts: 29.4/40/1 Harper: 22.3/243/0 T. Mathis: 18.5/107/0 Adrian Murrell: 16.2/38/0 Enumwa: 54.0/1/0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
More Cowbell 1,510 #32 Posted November 13 2 hours ago, peebag said: <cough><cough>John Riggins<cough><cough> I think Riggo was great but he was great on a different team. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
More Cowbell 1,510 #33 Posted November 13 37 minutes ago, Copernicus said: LT- Ferguson LG: Faneca Center: Mangold TE: Mickey Shuler RG: Brandon Moore RT: Damien Woody RB1: Freeman McNeil RB2: Curtis Martin WR1; Al Toon WR2: Wesley Walker Slot: Wayne Chrebet QB: Ken O'Brien Punt/Kick Return: Leon Washington K. John Hall P. Dave Jennings I would never had thought we'd see Kenny O over Vinnie or Penny Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
nyjunc 10,302 #34 Posted November 13 55 minutes ago, More Cowbell said: I would never had thought we'd see Kenny O over Vinnie or Penny The further away we get from his career the better Kenny seems to get in Jets game eyes. The guy that inherited one of the best young teams in the AFC and never won a playoff game in his career is more highly thought if by many than Vinny, Chad and Sanchez. 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
#27TheDominator 208,285 #35 Posted November 13 27 minutes ago, nyjunc said: The further away we get from his career the better Kenny seems to get in Jets game eyes. The guy that inherited one of the best young teams in the AFC and never won a playoff game in his career is more highly thought if by many than Vinny, Chad and Sanchez. Vinny had a phenomenal year, but **** the three of them. I will take Kenny O. You can throw around whatever bullsh*t you want, but he was stuck with those two moronic coaches - Walton with Kotite as an OC. I will stand by him over the others. He could throw the ******* ball Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
