How good is Bill Belichick….really?

[jetstream23]

 

[More Cowbell]

[Origen]

Brady def made him but he still did it.  I won't say he's the best but I'll give him the credit that it was done.  Now the Pats need to spend 40 years in the wilderness for karma to rebound.

[Beerfish]

One of the all time best coaches but like his former QB he is a rampant cheater, penalized three times but probably cheated many many more.  Good thing the poll was only about him as a head coach because he is a terrible general manager.

[Paradis]

10 minutes ago, jetstream23 said:

 

misrepresentative (stats pre NE days), and we all know it. If anyone can attest to his tenure, its us Jets fans. Everything from game clock management, scheming, managing team, cosnsistency, lack of mental mistakes, etc...  In today's NFL, he is without an equal. 

[rangerous]

i hesitate to select him as the best of all time because he had his success with brady at qb.  he had the patsies playing very well with jones but they really got beat badly by buffalo.  another problem is he's only coaching in his era.  i guess the same can be said of most coaches but guys like landry, shula, dan reeves all coached with an evolving nfl and were successful.  and then there are guys like gibbs and reid who have had good success with more than one team.  my gaging of the bellichiken is whether or not i'd want him as jets coach over any of them since 2000 and the answer has always been yes.

[jamesr]

No option for "scumbag"? Disappointed.