Game Thread - CTM Search Party (GAME OVER)

[Leelou]

43 minutes ago, Beaver said:

I didn’t notice the masons not voting together

Why would that matter? 

[Leelou]

Smash. Besides JiF who else do you have as scum? 

[Pac]

48 minutes ago, HessStation said:

Dear God,

please let that dumb **** try and shoot me. You’re the best, thanks for everything.

Hess

I think you very well may be scum but for now I like your jestering.  I may leave you alive to regale us further with your clumsiness. 

[Beaver]

4 minutes ago, Leelou said:

Why would that matter? 

town consensus.  Ideally town comes together and agree that this person should swing and the town lynches scum .  I would think 2 masons would discuss pro's and con's of who is scum and come to a conclusion on who to go after.  2 x scum pretending to be masons might just want to muddy the waters.

[Smashmouth]

6 minutes ago, Leelou said:

Smash. Besides JiF who else do you have as scum? 

At first Verbal Beaver BG

you know I don't usually give out lists I try to find someone who has acted scummy and roll with it. 

The only suspicion I have on those 3 is the way they voted early staying off the AVM train . Not really much other than that so its hard to make a case. 

You and Verbal are Masons and that makes sense but there's the slight chance you could be playing us , ya never know 

 

[Pac]

I might off JVOY.  His play sucks. 

Stork, JVOY, mess, BeeGee, Hail, or lurk. 

1 of them is getting fitted for cement shoes as we speak. 

[Smashmouth]

2 minutes ago, Pac said:

I might off JVOY.  His play sucks. 

Stork, JVOY, mess, BeeGee, Hail, or lurk. 

1 is getting fitted for cement shoes as we speak. 

 I could go with stork, beegee or hail here after JIF swings

[Pac]

This new incarnation of the stupid ape is no great shakes either..  As Leroy pointed out. 

[Pac]

Just now, Smashmouth said:

 I could go with stork or hail here after JIF swings

I gotta read all your posts to see if the pr thing has been consistent 

[Smashmouth]

Just now, Pac said:

I gotta read all your posts to see if the pr thing has been consistent 

Before you do that bring jiffy pop and Monkey Breath with you, maybe they'll learn something

[jvill 51]

7 hours ago, Smashmouth said:

I'm not going to come out and say anything, you guys should see it by now. It also has absolutely nothing to do with my case on JIF . Looking at how I voted says everything that needs to be said from this games subject matter.

 

1 hour ago, Smashmouth said:

What can you not understand ? Seriously . I'm trying to see if you sleuths can pick up on what I'm required to do but I guess your feeble little brains can't handle that kind of thinking. 

Like I said if you disagree with my case which is clear at this point that's 100 % fine but if you can't figure out why I'm posting the way I am  then you are simply not paying attention.

You and JIFiot have your fun laughing and carrying on like 2 school girls like I said you do this every game and you both suck at this so there's that. 

If you need another hint let me know I even bolded sh*t to help you along.

I get it now. And I'm guessing you're not coming out and just saying this because you aren't allowed to? I can't think of any other reason to keep this quiet and create a huge distraction.

[Jetsfan80]

1 hour ago, Smashmouth said:

Ape STFU seriously. You play like your all it all the time and you are usually wrong. You play like this every game and you point at me, insult the way I play constantly, and then try to turn it back around when I come back at you the same way you come at me.

The LD thing was pure stupidity and could have put the Doc in harms way and even cost the COP to alter his play but hey it was an APE move that I even gave you partial credit for drawing the NK but there was 2 sides to it and it was risky. Just a dumb play if you ask me.

Maybe you were bored ? So the bored APE is always more important than the entire town. Every game you play your busy until something triggers you then its calling everyone and their ideas stupid . You have ran off some good people and you get off on it and even brag on it and to me that's ******* disgusting and not in the sprit of the game we come here to have fun playing. Problem most of the time is you don't like the taste of your own medicine 

I always get tunnel vision when I play you know this and you take full advantage to insult me . When it comes to what I'm doing besides the JIF case, like I said you should have figured it out by now sorry you can't . Other than that what other case is there ? you and JIF put yourselves front and center I'm not buying JIF's story is that so hard for you to deal with ? People keep asking me questions I answer them and at some point it starts to get annoying to me when they ask me sh*t I already typed out. Read the game and stop APEing the **** out of it.

* you're

[Smashmouth]

1 minute ago, Jetsfan80 said:

*you're

OMFG did I miss one

Verbal will pounce

[Jetsfan80]

Official Day 3 Vote Count

Peen (6) - Leelou, Hess, JVOR, Stark, Beaver, Hal

JiF (4) - Arsis, Peen, Verbal, Smash

Smash (3) - jvill, BG, JiF

 

Not Voting (4) - Pac, Lurker, Ape, Drums

With 17 players alive, it takes 9 votes to lynch

[Smashmouth]

17 minutes ago, jvill 51 said:

 

I get it now. And I'm guessing you're not coming out and just saying this because you aren't allowed to? I can't think of any other reason to keep this quiet and create a huge distraction.

Not so much "not allowed to" but I just wanted to play it out like 80 intended. I felt like I gave enough hints to make it clear and TBH I really wanted to see if people were paying attention because that's one of my biggest gripes with this game over all people don't pay attention and I find myself repeating the same crap I've been saying for pages and pages. If I don't repeat it, I get the feeling some important points will get lost in the shuffle. Just me and my tunnel vision. I'm a terrible writer Jvill always have been , should be obvious and at times it hampers my game., just one of those things 

[Pac]

[Smashmouth]

1 minute ago, Pac said:

could ya help me out and just shoot JIF ? he 's downvoting all my posts like a big baby, my reputation is on the line here

[Stark]

12 hours ago, Hal N of Provo said:

 

Leelou, And Verbal are linked.  Maybe Masons and maybe lovers - which could be any side.   I think Masons.  Both seem genuine although I’d like to see verbal post more. 
 

You seen town.  Beaver seems town.    

Peen seemed to misstep and get aggressive in defensive.  I think as town you kind of want to win but deep down don’t care that deeply lol.  
 

Id hate to kill JiF today.  What a loss if he’s important to town.  

where did you copy and past this from... Im on dark mode and this post clearly has white background applied to text field

wtf 

 

15 hours ago, Greenseed4 said:

@Stark I'll be taking my 4yo out on our weekly Tuesday night Daddy/Daughter dinner date. 

So, if I don't post for a while it's because I'm busy jumping on trampolines and eating happy meals.  Which is significantly more exciting than this game where I'm just boring old VT; I haven't been as invested in this game as I have in the last few--when I had actual nighttime activities to handle and QT discussions to participate in.   I'm a safe lynch if ya'll want to quit trying to lynch scum and want to focus on the (not even low) middle activity posters. 

 

...this reminds me of a time I snuck into a Phish concert by wearing an event staff polo and I got close enough to the stage to smell the patchouli on Trey Anastasio, when the lead Operations guy tried to kick me out for "not doing anything".  

perfect have fun. also play the game 

14 hours ago, Drums said:

Kinda starting to pick up what you’re saying…. Maybe? 

hinting at something

14 hours ago, Bleedin Green said:

So I've got to ask, is the premature reveal-ulation a common thing around here these days or something?  Lots of early finishes going on around here.

No reason to believe it say anything about alignment, considering evidence has shown it to be coming from both sides, but I just don't get the reasoning behind it at all.

Any logic behind this, or are people just exhausted from this game that quickly?  If anything it seems more likely to be to the benefit of scum than town, for reasons I won't bother explaining just in case they're too stupid to figure that out for themselves.

its becoming a thing especially  last 2 games.

 

13 hours ago, Integrity28 said:

We’re going to need to be more creative than voting the vocal participants. 

Jif is cornered if scum. I say let it ride until we have to deal with it. Too much of the fans is hidden.

JVOR, BG, Beaver, pac, drums, stark, all players there’s almost nothing to base a read on.

Ive often considered including a mechanic that penalizes the bottom posters. Might be time to design a game with it… but I have no time to moderate.

thank you great town announcer and shepherd, you have done nothing this whole game but play announcer except for your fake LD.

most hypocritical post ever. lol 

rule 14

 

47 minutes ago, Leelou said:

Is there some requirement now in mafia that we have to be of the same mind, in lock step and vote the same every phase? 
 

I see things differently than Verb, I’ve given him my opinions in our discord. Neither of us are hiding, but I can guarantee you I’m not going to be a big leader here. 
 

TBH, this is weird. I feel like you came back as a different alignment and I also don’t really like that you’ve been giving tidbits about why your 1.0 version did things. You are a new player and that version of you is dead. 

no it just ape the town do nothing announcer. just coaching and calling people out for not doing things the way he would.

 

8 hours ago, Smashmouth said:

This is a game about CTM the king of early gambits (not that he was actually good at it) so I can easily see JIF and AVM trying to pull this off.

this is dumb... so you thing avm took this into consideration for JiF to bus AVM right out the gate on day 2 in CTM's honor.... lol

dude someone show me the logic to why JIF would bus a Scum Ninja on the start of D2 when the only person voting him was Arsis and he legit had no real heat.

 

what does scum gain from this?

 

 

[Pac]

Eenie, meenie, miney... 

Deadline for death is high noon. 

Making one of you Swiss cheese.. 

YAAAAHOOOO!! 

[Smashmouth]

35 minutes ago, jvill 51 said:

 

I get it now. And I'm guessing you're not coming out and just saying this because you aren't allowed to? I can't think of any other reason to keep this quiet and create a huge distraction.

now that you figured it out I have to also do it angrily which is difficult enough to deal with.

[Integrity28]

1 hour ago, Smashmouth said:

What can you not understand ? Seriously . I'm trying to see if you sleuths can pick up on what I'm required to do but I guess your feeble little brains can't handle that kind of thinking. 

Like I said if you disagree with my case which is clear at this point that's 100 % fine but if you can't figure out why I'm posting the way I am  then you are simply not paying attention.

You and JIFiot have your fun laughing and carrying on like 2 school girls like I said you do this every game and you both suck at this so there's that. 

If you need another hint let me know I even bolded sh*t to help you along.

 

Tempted to put you on ignore.

[Leelou]

10 minutes ago, Pac said:

Eenie, meenie, miney... 

Deadline for death is high noon. 

Making one of you Swiss cheese.. 

YAAAAHOOOO!! 

We have to wait 2 hours? 

[Smashmouth]

3 minutes ago, Stark said:

 

 

this is dumb... so you thing avm took this into consideration for JiF to bus AVM right out the gate on day 2 in CTM's honor.... lol

dude someone show me the logic to why JIF would bus a Scum Ninja on the start of D2 when the only person voting him was Arsis and he legit had no real heat.

 

what does scum gain from this?

 

 

Actually stark its not dumb, for years people playing this game  hide in plain sight to try and get over on the others and look like hero's in the end, if they pull it off. Its difficult to do and its a good challenge.

Like I said, CTM on numerous occasions, wanted me as a scum partner to try gambits early in the game, we used to argue over it in scum chat all the time.  Everyone knows CTM plays this way he loves the challenge. So its not far fetched nor stupid to think JIF and AVM would try to pull this off in a game based around CTM. Obviously its just a theory and the reason I went with it hard is because I felt JIF's claim early was a bit far fetched . In a game with 22 people there could easily be 5 outside chance 6 on the scum team so an early gambit would not be that big of a gamble on their part. 

[Smashmouth]

3 minutes ago, Integrity28 said:

 

Tempted to put you on ignore.

please do and thanks

[Integrity28]

1 hour ago, Smashmouth said:

Ape STFU seriously. You play like your all it all the time and you are usually wrong. You play like this every game and you point at me, insult the way I play constantly, and then try to turn it back around when I come back at you the same way you come at me.

The LD thing was pure stupidity and could have put the Doc in harms way and even cost the COP to alter his play but hey it was an APE move that I even gave you partial credit for drawing the NK but there was 2 sides to it and it was risky. Just a dumb play if you ask me.

Maybe you were bored ? So the bored APE is always more important than the entire town. Every game you play your busy until something triggers you then its calling everyone and their ideas stupid . You have ran off some good people and you get off on it and even brag on it and to me that's ******* disgusting and not in the sprit of the game we come here to have fun playing. Problem most of the time is you don't like the taste of your own medicine 

I always get tunnel vision when I play you know this and you take full advantage to insult me . When it comes to what I'm doing besides the JIF case, like I said you should have figured it out by now sorry you can't . Other than that what other case is there ? you and JIF put yourselves front and center I'm not buying JIF's story is that so hard for you to deal with ? People keep asking me questions I answer them and at some point it starts to get annoying to me when they ask me sh*t I already typed out. Read the game and stop APEing the **** out of it.

I only rejoined the game as a favor to 80. I take and take and take from you, telling you I’m not going to retaliate so that you stay somewhat calm and can enjoy the game. 

This is what I get in return.

Don’t reply. Please.

[Integrity28]

1 hour ago, Smashmouth said:

Problem is when you disagree you have a way of being insulting

There it is. Everyone else started it. 

******* guy.

[Integrity28]

1 hour ago, Leelou said:

Is there some requirement now in mafia that we have to be of the same mind, in lock step and vote the same every phase? 
 

I see things differently than Verb, I’ve given him my opinions in our discord. Neither of us are hiding, but I can guarantee you I’m not going to be a big leader here. 
 

TBH, this is weird. I feel like you came back as a different alignment and I also don’t really like that you’ve been giving tidbits about why your 1.0 version did things. You are a new player and that version of you is dead. 

Oh well. You thought I was scum, so I guess this means Im town?

No requirement. I never said you had to vote together. I asked what the joint thinking is. Way to deflect back to me and not actually answer anything.

[Integrity28]

1 hour ago, Leelou said:

Why would that matter? 

It doesn’t. See what I did there though?

[Pac]

6 minutes ago, Leelou said:

We have to wait 2 hours? 

Next time be nicer to me. 

[Integrity28]

Hal is my favorite for scum. That’s all.

Vote Hal

[Smashmouth]

3 minutes ago, Integrity28 said:

There it is. Everyone else started it. 

******* guy.

Not everyone else just you. You always start and you do it to everyone.  Stating you love the fact you ran people off from this game says it all. Sorry but I didn't say it you did . I always start off civil with you and then it deteriorates 

[Stark]

4 minutes ago, Smashmouth said:

Actually stark its not dumb, for years people playing this game  hide in plain sight to try and get over on the others and look like hero's in the end, if they pull it off. Its difficult to do and its a good challenge.

Like I said, CTM on numerous occasions, wanted me as a scum partner to try gambits early in the game, we used to argue over it in scum chat all the time.  Everyone knows CTM plays this way he loves the challenge. So its not far fetched nor stupid to think JIF and AVM would try to pull this off in a game based around CTM. Obviously its just a theory and the reason I went with it hard is because I felt JIF's claim early was a bit far fetched . In a game with 22 people there could easily be 5 outside chance 6 on the scum team so an early gambit would not be that big of a gamble on their part. 

sorry it doesn't make sense for scum to give up a ninja on D2 for no reason, other than to "honor" CMT and his old gambit running ways. purely theory 

Ninja, not trackable, valuable role, no? Im not seeing it

 

 

Now JiF's role and him adding the 3rd night reveal is the thing im struggling with but I can see players saying they are 1 x and using that to try to make it through a night phase.

[Smashmouth]

2 minutes ago, Stark said:

sorry it doesn't make sense for scum to give up a ninja on D2 for no reason, other than to "honor" CMT and his old gambit running ways. purely theory 

Ninja, not trackable, valuable role, no? Im not seeing it

 

 

Now JiF's role and him adding the 3rd night reveal is the thing im struggling with but I can see players saying they are 1 x and using that to try to make it through a night phase.

Stark play it how you like. We've all been wrong in so many ways just the nature of the game. 

[Stark]

Just now, Smashmouth said:

Stark play it how you like. We've all been wrong in so many ways just the nature of the game. 

and we will be wrong again. 

if I were in that conversation I would have been against selling a ninja so quickly 

[Smashmouth]

5 minutes ago, Stark said:

sorry it doesn't make sense for scum to give up a ninja on D2 for no reason, other than to "honor" CMT and his old gambit running ways. purely theory 

Ninja, not trackable, valuable role, no? Im not seeing it

 

 

Now JiF's role and him adding the 3rd night reveal is the thing im struggling with but I can see players saying they are 1 x and using that to try to make it through a night phase.

Stark here's another angle and I literally just thought of this. Keep in Mind 80 tailored this game to his liking based on all of our play styles. We've already seen post restrictions based on those styles . 80 is well aware of CTM's play style and I would not for a second put it past 80 to require a scum team gambit early in the game.