How many NFL QBs are currently better than Aaron Rodgers?

[Jimmy 2 Times]

Just now, Hex said:

So what would happen if Mahomes became a Jet in his prime?

I bump him from one to ONE

[Hex]

Just now, Skeptable said:

I am going to love when Rodgers healthy and a chip on his shoulder shows you guys that he is light years ahead of Hurts, and Herbert... and Easily Top 3-4 

We'll see. We all saw how much Hurts elevated an already stacked Eagles team from his absence. He was an MVP frontrunner. Herbert had a much better season than Rodgers did. I saw Rodger's season as an anomaly, but Herbert still had a better season.

Here's to hoping Rodgers does better on a much better team, though.

[nycdan]

28 minutes ago, Flightattendant said:

Mahommes

Prescott

Lawrence

Allen 

Hurts

Burrow

Herbert

Jackson

Fields

Are all ahead of him at this stage of his career.

I'd say he's amongst the next group of.

Murray

Tua

Goff 

Carr 

Watson 

Wilson

 

It never ceases to amaze me that no matter how awful the baited hook looks, someone always bites down hard.

 

[#27TheDominator]

2 minutes ago, nycdan said:

It never ceases to amaze me that no matter how awful the baited hook looks, someone always bites down hard.

 

How are we supposed to eat if the fish are get smart?

[slats]

34 minutes ago, Flightattendant said:

Mahommes

Prescott

Lawrence

Allen 

Hurts

Burrow

Herbert

Jackson

Fields

Are all ahead of him at this stage of his career.

I'd say he's amongst the next group of.

Murray

Tua

Goff 

Carr 

Watson 

Wilson

 

 

No politics, this was just the funniest one. 

[undertow]

11 minutes ago, Jetsfan80 said:

So per JN his floor is no worse than the 11th-best QB in the league, and yet a few here don't want him at all.

Some Jets fans are very sensitive they are looking for someone with an awesome personality and stability. 

[Jetsfan80]

Just now, undertow said:

Some Jets fans are very sensitive they are looking for someone with an awesome personality and stability. 

Good thing we can just pluck one of those off the tree in this league

[nycdan]

19 minutes ago, #27TheDominator said:

How are we supposed to eat if the fish are get smart?

[Joe Willie White Shoes]

It really depends on whether last season was an anomaly or the beginning of the end for Rodgers.  I hope  he is somewhere between 5-10 at this stage of his career, best case being closer to 5 than 10.

Mahomes, Allen, Burrow are clearly better than him.  You can argue that Herbert is as well, although he had an off year as well.  

Rodgers falls in the next group with Jackson, Watson, Lawrence, and maybe Prescott, Hurts, and Stafford.  If last year's performance was thumb-related and not age related, he is better than this group and comes in at 5 or so.  If not, he is in this group, which puts him in the 6-12 range.

If Rodgers continues to decline, he could fall in the middle of the pack group with Tua, Carr, Cousins, Murray with players like D. Jones,  Goff, Garappolo below them.  

The issues that make Rodgers a risk and no sure thing, and why I think almost everyone who responded to this poll is overrating him, are his age, his ridiculous contract, and the potential for him to play only one or two more seasons.  When QBs decline, they fall off a cliff.  It's hard to tell if Rodgers is at the cliff's edge or not.  Very very few NFL QBs have been successful at age 40 (Brady?).  And older players are both injury prone and contact-averse.  Then he could retire after one season, putting the Jets in the same bind a year from now.  So this is no slam dunk move at all. It is a gamble on many fronts.  

Given Wilson's poor outlook, I understand taking the risk, but JD needs to hold the line on the trade compensation so that the downside risk is mitigated to some extent.

I don't care about the past. I think those like Stephen A Smith are idiots when they claim that the Jets failure to make the playoffs the past 12 years and the misses at drafting a QB make Rodgers worth more to the Jets than he would be for another team that needs a QB.  Rodgers is worth what he is worth from an NFL standpoint. 

[#27TheDominator]

3 minutes ago, nycdan said:

I asked you not to tell me that!

[bicketybam]

The only QBs better than Rodgers right now is Patrick Mahomes and Derek Montana Carr

You forgot Lamar "Superstar" Jackson, QB and Professional Sports Agent.

[nycdan]

Just now, #27TheDominator said:

I asked you not to tell me that!

Okay.  into the Cone of Silence I go...

[Pac]

Rodgers with no WRs and a broken thumb had a better day against our D than Allen did in his 2 games with Stefon Diggs.  

I love that people are underrating our boy this much.  2023 is going to be Arods revenge tour. 

[JETS SB]

1 hour ago, Flightattendant said:

Mahommes

Prescott

Lawrence

Allen 

Hurts

Burrow

Herbert

Jackson

Fields

Are all ahead of him at this stage of his career.

I'd say he's amongst the next group of.

Murray

Tua

Goff 

Carr 

Watson 

Wilson

 

This is the hardest I have laughed in a long time. Thank you.

[T0mShane]

Regrettably, Aaron Rodgers is worse than every quarterback in football because, as everybody knows, when a person hits 40 years of age, their arms and legs immediately detach from their body and they melt into a gelatinous mass of porridge. Pity to those who are unaware of this scientific fact. 

[CrazyCarl40]

6 minutes ago, T0mShane said:

Regrettably, Aaron Rodgers is worse than every quarterback in football because, as everybody knows, when a person hits 40 years of age, their arms and legs immediately detach from their body and they melt into a gelatinous mass of porridge. Pity to those who are unaware of this scientific fact. 

It’s true. I just turned 40 and this happened to me. 

[HighPitch]

1 hour ago, Warfish said:

I'd say he's current between ~8-12.  Based on 2022.

If he rebounds from a down year and injury, he's top 10 again. 

If he doesn''t, he's middle of the pack or worse.

Kindly name the 8 that are better than him at a minimum

ill start:

burrow

mahomes

allen

 

who are the 5

[JETS SB]

16-20: He's now slightly below average

• 

  bitonti

  28 minutes ago

[bicketybam]

What's up with that avatar?

[slimjasi]

1 hour ago, Pac said:

Rodgers with no WRs and a broken thumb had a better day against our D than Allen did in his 2 games with Stefon Diggs.  

I love that people are underrating our boy this much.  2023 is going to be Arods revenge tour. 

[Embrace the Suck]

3 hours ago, Flightattendant said:

Mahommes

Prescott

Lawrence

Allen 

Hurts

Burrow

Herbert

Jackson

Fields

Are all ahead of him at this stage of his career.

I'd say he's amongst the next group of.

Murray

Tua

Goff 

Carr 

Watson 

Wilson

 

[bitonti]

2 hours ago, JETS SB said:

16-20: He's now slightly below average

• 

  bitonti

  28 minutes ago

 

These are the 2022 QB Ratings 

 

1    Brock Purdy    San Francisco 49ers    QB    108.0
2    Patrick Mahomes    Kansas City Chiefs    QB    106.4
3    Tua Tagovailoa    Miami Dolphins    QB    105.5
4    Jimmy Garoppolo    San Francisco 49ers    QB    103.0
5    Jalen Hurts    Philadelphia Eagles    QB    100.8
6    Geno Smith    Seattle Seahawks    QB    100.8
7    Jared Goff    Detroit Lions    QB    99.3
8    Joe Burrow    Cincinnati Bengals    QB    99.0
9    Andy Dalton    New Orleans Saints    QB    95.2
10    Ryan Tannehill    Tennessee Titans    QB    94.6
11    Josh Allen    Buffalo Bills    QB    94.5
12    Kirk Cousins    Minnesota Vikings    QB    93.7
13    Dak Prescott    Dallas Cowboys    QB    92.7
14    Justin Herbert    Los Angeles Chargers    QB    92.7
15    Trevor Lawrence    Jacksonville Jaguars    QB    92.2
16    Daniel Jones    New York Giants    QB    92.0
17    Aaron Rodgers    Green Bay Packers    QB    91.1

Below average. That's not my opinion. It's a fact.

everyone is going to say, "but Bitonti, he was playing with a broken thumb" 

Yeah, dude. That's what happens to 40 year olds. They get hurt 

it happened to Favre who was an iron man before he went to the NYJ, it happened to Vinny T in 1999, and, most likely, it's going to happen to Aaron Rodgers this year 

no way this dude plays all 17 games. 

people saying he's top 5 or top 10 or whatever. That's considering the player he used to be, not the player he is.

Zach was 34th, by the way.  The lowest qualifying score. I don't know how he did it, considering there were only 32 starters, but he did. 

 

1 hour ago, bicketybam said:

What's up with that avatar?

it's my f**king face thanks

[bicketybam]

TIL that Geno Smith is better than Tom Brady.

Holy sh*t, what a terrible take.

[slimjasi]

12 minutes ago, bitonti said:

 

These are the 2022 QB Ratings 

 

1    Brock Purdy    San Francisco 49ers    QB    108.0
2    Patrick Mahomes    Kansas City Chiefs    QB    106.4
3    Tua Tagovailoa    Miami Dolphins    QB    105.5
4    Jimmy Garoppolo    San Francisco 49ers    QB    103.0
5    Jalen Hurts    Philadelphia Eagles    QB    100.8
6    Geno Smith    Seattle Seahawks    QB    100.8
7    Jared Goff    Detroit Lions    QB    99.3
8    Joe Burrow    Cincinnati Bengals    QB    99.0
9    Andy Dalton    New Orleans Saints    QB    95.2
10    Ryan Tannehill    Tennessee Titans    QB    94.6
11    Josh Allen    Buffalo Bills    QB    94.5
12    Kirk Cousins    Minnesota Vikings    QB    93.7
13    Dak Prescott    Dallas Cowboys    QB    92.7
14    Justin Herbert    Los Angeles Chargers    QB    92.7
15    Trevor Lawrence    Jacksonville Jaguars    QB    92.2
16    Daniel Jones    New York Giants    QB    92.0
17    Aaron Rodgers    Green Bay Packers    QB    91.1

Below average. That's not my opinion. It's a fact.

everyone is going to say, "but Bitonti, he was playing with a broken thumb" 

Yeah, dude. That's what happens to 40 year olds. They get hurt 

it happened to Favre who was an iron man before he went to the NYJ, it happened to Vinny T in 1999, and, most likely, it's going to happen to Aaron Rodgers this year 

no way this dude plays all 17 games. 

people saying he's top 5 or top 10 or whatever. That's considering the player he used to be, not the player he is.

Zach was 34th, by the way.  The lowest qualifying score. I don't know how he did it, considering there were only 32 starters, but he did. 

 

it's my f**king face thanks

So, just so I understand your logic - 

You believe Brock Purdy is the best QB in the NFL? 

[JETS SB]

22 minutes ago, bitonti said:

 

These are the 2022 QB Ratings 

 

1    Brock Purdy    San Francisco 49ers    QB    108.0
2    Patrick Mahomes    Kansas City Chiefs    QB    106.4
3    Tua Tagovailoa    Miami Dolphins    QB    105.5
4    Jimmy Garoppolo    San Francisco 49ers    QB    103.0
5    Jalen Hurts    Philadelphia Eagles    QB    100.8
6    Geno Smith    Seattle Seahawks    QB    100.8
7    Jared Goff    Detroit Lions    QB    99.3
8    Joe Burrow    Cincinnati Bengals    QB    99.0
9    Andy Dalton    New Orleans Saints    QB    95.2
10    Ryan Tannehill    Tennessee Titans    QB    94.6
11    Josh Allen    Buffalo Bills    QB    94.5
12    Kirk Cousins    Minnesota Vikings    QB    93.7
13    Dak Prescott    Dallas Cowboys    QB    92.7
14    Justin Herbert    Los Angeles Chargers    QB    92.7
15    Trevor Lawrence    Jacksonville Jaguars    QB    92.2
16    Daniel Jones    New York Giants    QB    92.0
17    Aaron Rodgers    Green Bay Packers    QB    91.1

Below average. That's not my opinion. It's a fact.

everyone is going to say, "but Bitonti, he was playing with a broken thumb" 

Yeah, dude. That's what happens to 40 year olds. They get hurt 

it happened to Favre who was an iron man before he went to the NYJ, it happened to Vinny T in 1999, and, most likely, it's going to happen to Aaron Rodgers this year 

no way this dude plays all 17 games. 

people saying he's top 5 or top 10 or whatever. That's considering the player he used to be, not the player he is.

Zach was 34th, by the way.  The lowest qualifying score. I don't know how he did it, considering there were only 32 starters, but he did. 

 

it's my f**king face thanks

So Jimmy G, Andy Dalton, and Ryan Tannehill are better than Aaron Rodgers. You are brilliant in your trolling. 

[Pac]

10 minutes ago, slimjasi said:

So, just so I understand your logic - 

You believe Brock Purdy is the best QB in the NFL? 

Tua significantly better than Burrow and Andy Dalton edges out Josh Allen. 

Numbers don't lie. 

[JETS SB]

31 minutes ago, bitonti said:

 

These are the 2022 QB Ratings 

 

1    Brock Purdy    San Francisco 49ers    QB    108.0
2    Patrick Mahomes    Kansas City Chiefs    QB    106.4
3    Tua Tagovailoa    Miami Dolphins    QB    105.5
4    Jimmy Garoppolo    San Francisco 49ers    QB    103.0
5    Jalen Hurts    Philadelphia Eagles    QB    100.8
6    Geno Smith    Seattle Seahawks    QB    100.8
7    Jared Goff    Detroit Lions    QB    99.3
8    Joe Burrow    Cincinnati Bengals    QB    99.0
9    Andy Dalton    New Orleans Saints    QB    95.2
10    Ryan Tannehill    Tennessee Titans    QB    94.6
11    Josh Allen    Buffalo Bills    QB    94.5
12    Kirk Cousins    Minnesota Vikings    QB    93.7
13    Dak Prescott    Dallas Cowboys    QB    92.7
14    Justin Herbert    Los Angeles Chargers    QB    92.7
15    Trevor Lawrence    Jacksonville Jaguars    QB    92.2
16    Daniel Jones    New York Giants    QB    92.0
17    Aaron Rodgers    Green Bay Packers    QB    91.1

Below average. That's not my opinion. It's a fact.

everyone is going to say, "but Bitonti, he was playing with a broken thumb" 

Yeah, dude. That's what happens to 40 year olds. They get hurt 

it happened to Favre who was an iron man before he went to the NYJ, it happened to Vinny T in 1999, and, most likely, it's going to happen to Aaron Rodgers this year 

no way this dude plays all 17 games. 

people saying he's top 5 or top 10 or whatever. That's considering the player he used to be, not the player he is.

Zach was 34th, by the way.  The lowest qualifying score. I don't know how he did it, considering there were only 32 starters, but he did. 

 

it's my f**king face thanks

It’s like we have just been in the presence of greatness. I feel tingly. 

[slimjasi]

5 minutes ago, Pac said:

Tua significantly better than Burrow and Andy Dalton edges out Josh Allen. 

Numbers don't lie. 

Jimmy G TOP 4

Tannehill top 10

That's a list for ya

 

[Joe Willie White Shoes]

35 minutes ago, bicketybam said:

TIL that Geno Smith is better than Tom Brady.

Holy sh*t, what a terrible take.

He was a much better QB than Brady in 2022.  It wasn't even close.  

[Joe W. Namath]

At this stage of his career, Rodgers is prob about the 10th best qb in the league.  And that is trending down.

[bitonti]

3 hours ago, T0mShane said:

Regrettably, Aaron Rodgers is worse than every quarterback in football because, as everybody knows, when a person hits 40 years of age, their arms and legs immediately detach from their body and they melt into a gelatinous mass of porridge. Pity to those who are unaware of this scientific fact. 

The Jets are going to win 20 games with Aaron Rodgers next year and the next 3 super bowls in a row 

Is that better? 

40 minutes ago, slimjasi said:

So, just so I understand your logic - 

You believe Brock Purdy is the best QB in the NFL? 

I did not employ logic or use any belief system. The stats are the stats

In fact Aaron Rodgers is so below average he lost to a team qb'ed by Zach Wilson 

Yikes 

[slimjasi]

Just now, bitonti said:

 

I did not employ logic or use any belief system.

Indeed! 

[The Crusher]

58 minutes ago, bitonti said:

 

These are the 2022 QB Ratings 

 

1    Brock Purdy    San Francisco 49ers    QB    108.0
2    Patrick Mahomes    Kansas City Chiefs    QB    106.4
3    Tua Tagovailoa    Miami Dolphins    QB    105.5
4    Jimmy Garoppolo    San Francisco 49ers    QB    103.0
5    Jalen Hurts    Philadelphia Eagles    QB    100.8
6    Geno Smith    Seattle Seahawks    QB    100.8
7    Jared Goff    Detroit Lions    QB    99.3
8    Joe Burrow    Cincinnati Bengals    QB    99.0
9    Andy Dalton    New Orleans Saints    QB    95.2
10    Ryan Tannehill    Tennessee Titans    QB    94.6
11    Josh Allen    Buffalo Bills    QB    94.5
12    Kirk Cousins    Minnesota Vikings    QB    93.7
13    Dak Prescott    Dallas Cowboys    QB    92.7
14    Justin Herbert    Los Angeles Chargers    QB    92.7
15    Trevor Lawrence    Jacksonville Jaguars    QB    92.2
16    Daniel Jones    New York Giants    QB    92.0
17    Aaron Rodgers    Green Bay Packers    QB    91.1

Below average. That's not my opinion. It's a fact.

everyone is going to say, "but Bitonti, he was playing with a broken thumb" 

Yeah, dude. That's what happens to 40 year olds. They get hurt 

it happened to Favre who was an iron man before he went to the NYJ, it happened to Vinny T in 1999, and, most likely, it's going to happen to Aaron Rodgers this year 

no way this dude plays all 17 games. 

people saying he's top 5 or top 10 or whatever. That's considering the player he used to be, not the player he is.

Zach was 34th, by the way.  The lowest qualifying score. I don't know how he did it, considering there were only 32 starters, but he did. 

 

it's my f**king face thanks

No way your that handsome 

[BigRy56]

The locks are Mahomes, Burrow, and Josh Allen. The problem here is that all 3 are in the AFC and 1 is in the division

[Barry McCockinner]

46 minutes ago, slimjasi said:

So, just so I understand your logic - 

You believe Brock Purdy is the best QB in the NFL? 

it's a fact.