Jump to content
Want to remove all ads? ×

Who would you rather have?

K2C

By K2C
in NY Jets Forum

Who would you rather have starting?  

1 member has voted

  1. 1. Who would you rather have starting?

    • Chad Pennington
      19
    • Eli Manning
      30

Recommended Posts

penningtonfan82

penningtonfan82

Posted
Posted
Pennington, really not even close. Eli is far far too inconsistent.

He seems to always regress as the season goes on after amking strong starts.

I'll take Kellen and Chad over Eli, especially Chad.:thumbup:

I have to say, this year Eli looks a lot more consistent though, I would still worry about it, but he doesn't look like the past 2 seasons. Still I'd take Chad.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Irish Jet

Irish Jet

Posted
Posted
I have to say, this year Eli looks a lot more consistent though, I would still worry about it, but he doesn't look like the past 2 seasons. Still I'd take Chad.

I agree, but he has started well the last 2 season I think only to crumble to pieces come the end.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
joiseyjet

joiseyjet

Posted
Posted

Chads smarter but he`s just to limmited in what he can do as far as throwing the ball past 10 yards down field ,it makes things to easy on opposing defenses ,so for right now I`d have to take ELI. It kills me to say that ,but this was supposed to be our year and now it`s looking like we are gonna have a tough time going 8-8 ,I had us going 10-6 but that isn`t gonna happen losing to teams like Buffalo

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Jet27

Jet27

Posted
Posted
Chads smarter but he`s just to limmited in what he can do as far as throwing the ball past 10 yards down field ,it makes things to easy on opposing defenses ,so for right now I`d have to take ELI. It kills me to say that ,but this was supposed to be our year and now it`s looking like we are gonna have a tough time going 8-8 ,I had us going 10-6 but that isn`t gonna happen losing to teams like Buffalo

Chad looked really smart this past sunday, especially the last INT he threw, man he looked like a freakin genius on that one!

Link to comment
Share on other sites
joiseyjet

joiseyjet

Posted
Posted
Chad looked really smart this past sunday, especially the last INT he threw, man he looked like a freakin genius on that one!

I think his brain is pretty good about making the right choices ,I`m just not so sure his arm is cappable of putting the ball where it needs to be at all times

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Steveg

Steveg

Posted
Posted

Eli has no leadership ability. His body language, temperment, and interaction with the players really stinks. That stuff is in-born - either you got it or you don't. The fact that he sounds like Forrest Gump doesn't help either....

Give me Chad..

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Jet27

Jet27

Posted
Posted
I think his brain is pretty good about making the right choices ,I`m just not so sure his arm is cappable of putting the ball where it needs to be at all times

Ok..lets have his brain throw the freakin ball then.......

Link to comment
Share on other sites
BUM-KNEE

BUM-KNEE

Posted
Posted
Eli has no leadership ability. His body language, temperment, and interaction with the players really stinks. That stuff is in-born - either you got it or you don't. The fact that he sounds like Forrest Gump doesn't help either....

Give me Chad..

Not to mention when he get pressure he looks like he drops a deuce in his undies, he gets rattled too easily and has absolutely no mobility. Get pressure on him and the INTs will come. .........never mind, we cant get pressure on a QB.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
KSJets

KSJets

Posted
Posted
I have to say, this year Eli looks a lot more consistent though, I would still worry about it, but he doesn't look like the past 2 seasons. Still I'd take Chad.

Eli gets bailed out a lot by his receivers, especially Plaxico. There are times he just heaves it up and you think there's no way anyone will catch it and Plaxico uses all of his 6'5" to go up and get it. There was one a couple of weeks ago that he looked like he punted the ball it went so high across the field that Shockey got his hands on but it fell incomplete. Chad would have gotten killed for a throw like that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Irish Jet

Irish Jet

Posted
Posted
Eli gets bailed out a lot by his receivers, especially Plaxico. There are times he just heaves it up and you think there's no way anyone will catch it and Plaxico uses all of his 6'5" to go up and get it. There was one a couple of weeks ago that he looked like he punted the ball it went so high across the field that Shockey got his hands on but it fell incomplete. Chad would have gotten killed for a throw like that.

Chad gets killed for every throw that doesnt hit our WR's in stride and on the money, anything else and the crucifiction calls are coming.:roll:

Link to comment
Share on other sites
nugentfan1

nugentfan1

Posted
Posted

Eli gets bailed out a lot by his receivers, especially Plaxico. There are times he just heaves it up and you think there's no way anyone will catch it and Plaxico uses all of his 6'5" to go up and get it. There was one a couple of weeks ago that he looked like he punted the ball it went so high across the field that Shockey got his hands on but it fell incomplete. Chad would have gotten killed for a throw like that.

Plaxico bails out eli?? are you kidding me?? how many passes went into burress' hands that he just flat out dropped??

Link to comment
Share on other sites
The Troll

The Troll

Posted
Posted
Pennington, really not even close. Eli is far far too inconsistent.

He seems to always regress as the season goes on after amking strong starts.

I'll take Kellen and Chad over Eli, especially Chad.:thumbup:

The only things Chad Pennington is consistent at are letting the team down and being inconsistent.

I guess he is pretty consistent.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
KSJets

KSJets

Posted
Posted

Plaxico bails out eli?? are you kidding me?? how many passes went into burress' hands that he just flat out dropped??

Plaxico is so used to having to make acrobatic catches that they easy ones surprise him :)

Seriously, he's great at making acrobatic catches. It's the simple catches he has problems with, and it's mainly because Eli's passes are so off target.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

Content Partnership

Yes Network

Site Sponsor

MILE-Social - NJ Social Media & SEO company

Site Sponsor

MetLife Stadium Tailgate

NY Jets Podcast

NY Jets Podcast

DMCA Page

  • -- DMCA Page
    • ×
    ×
    • Create New...