Jump to content

Idol Hot and Cold List


afosomf

Recommended Posts

Hot 2 night

Ladies

1a Brook

1b Irish Tat

Guys that Did Well

1. Dave Cook eleanor Rigby rocked

2. Aussie Mike

Cold as Ice

Ladies

1.Kristy Lee (ba bye)

2.Amanda- this song was dreadful

Guys who Sh1t the bed

1. Dave A (forgot words)

2. Dave H (Ba Bye)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 219
  • Created
  • Last Reply

this is the problem i have with idol

judges have no input, popularity contest instead of talent

Daughtry and Doolittle were the best talent in their years.

I have no doubt that Dave A will be in the finals, but he sucked

last night, forgeting lyrics is a big no no

My final 2 are Dave Cook and Brooke

the 3rd best is irish tat( she already has had a contract should be inelgible)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I watched it last night for the 1st time this year. I thought they were all pretty talented actually. the country girl sucked & yeah that kid forgetting the words sucked too but I was surprised at the talent.

ryan seacrest & paula make the show hard to watch though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Who did well last night:

-Chikezie finally did something well and I think it'll buy him an extra week.

-David Cook was very good and I thought probably the best of the night.

-Brooke did well again, but something about her weirds me out.

-Carly did well. I don't like to talk about her because she already had her chance.

People who didn't fair well but should pass through:

-David A. His fan base is ridiculous, and his past performances make up for the flub this week.

-Michael Johns. He was ok, but he's been better.

-Jason Castro. Could be in trouble on a different week, but there were much worse.

-Ramiele. She's hot. That is all.

People in Trouble to go Home:

-Kristy Lee Cook. Should have went home last week. A'siah was far and away better. She took a classic Beatles song and murdered it. She should be arrested.

-David H might have to go back to stripping because he's just not that good.

-Amanda Overmeyer. She's a one trick pony. Rock and roll and that's it. If she ever had to sing a ballad she'd be done. She also seems like she's 40 for only being 23.

-Syesha. I don't think this week suited her very well for her voice, but she is gorgeous and does have a good voice.

Prediction:

Kristy Lee Cook goes home. David H could be next.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Who did well last night:

-Chikezie finally did something well and I think it'll buy him an extra week.

-David Cook was very good and I thought probably the best of the night.

-Brooke did well again, but something about her weirds me out.

-Carly did well. I don't like to talk about her because she already had her chance.

People who didn't fair well but should pass through:

-David A. His fan base is ridiculous, and his past performances make up for the flub this week.

-Michael Johns. He was ok, but he's been better.

-Jason Castro. Could be in trouble on a different week, but there were much worse.

-Ramiele. She's hot. That is all.

People in Trouble to go Home:

-Kristy Lee Cook. Should have went home last week. A'siah was far and away better. She took a classic Beatles song and murdered it. She should be arrested.

-David H might have to go back to stripping because he's just not that good.

-Amanda Overmeyer. She's a one trick pony. Rock and roll and that's it. If she ever had to sing a ballad she'd be done. She also seems like she's 40 for only being 23.

-Syesha. I don't think this week suited her very well for her voice, but she is gorgeous and does have a good voice.

Prediction:

Kristy Lee Cook goes home. David H could be next.

Concur CC

BTW happy belated Bday!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

brooke has a niche in slow carly simon-esque songs..

i think she might be inb trouble down road where she will have to diversify ..

she kind of wierds me ou talso,,

seems like she is 25 going on 50

She has a pure voice though and it doesn;t appear to me that she is playing games like some contestants

Amanda needs to go quickly, to hear her butcher a Beatles song is sacrilege.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hot 2 night

Ladies

1a Brook

1b Irish Tat

Guys that Did Well

1. Dave Cook eleanor Rigby rocked

2. Aussie Mike

Cold as Ice

Ladies

1.Kristy Lee (ba bye)

2.Amanda- this song was dreadful

Guys who Sh1t the bed

1. Dave A (forgot words)

2. Dave H (Ba Bye)

How in the hell could anyone think that Dave Cook Wannabe's rendition of eleanor rigby was good in the slightest. It was the worst performance of that song I have ever heard. Absolutely Terrible, ruined the song.

but then again, america bought that fake daughtry crap too.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

How in the hell could anyone think that Dave Cook Wannabe's rendition of eleanor rigby was good in the slightest. It was the worst performance of that song I have ever heard. Absolutely Terrible, ruined the song.

but then again, america bought that fake daughtry crap too.

OK skippy we will call u music maven from now on.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

OK skippy we will call u music maven from now on.

Either way, thanks. The song was absolutely horrendous though, although it was one of the worst weeks of american idol, ever. Only 3 or 4 of the songs were good at all. But I must say, David H, Amanda and Dave **** all sucked very very badly. How anyone who remotely even liked the beatles could stand that **** is beyond me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i think the fillipino girl is boring as hell

i cant stand amanda and her deep rocking screams-one dimensional

the young kid with black hair has a very good voice

chickeze just sucks all the way around

the aussie guy is pretty good

the texan guy losing his hair makes me want to vomit although he is a good song picker

the sweet blonde nanny is very talented. man id do her good

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...