Jump to content

JN Mafia Game 2: Dawn of The Dead Edition


ZachEY
 Share

Recommended Posts

You've been undermining me probably most out of everyone the entire game and curiously enough pushed for my questions more then Woody's out of everyone here.

Anyways, at this point I would hope more people would take a look at Doggins and my arguments on Crusher.

Argument on Crusher? I will not be on after 3 today I have to get back to work. I hope you idiots don't go ahead and lynch me while Im not here. Would be a pity.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You've been undermining me probably most out of everyone the entire game and curiously enough pushed for my questions more then Woody's out of everyone here.

Anyways, at this point I would hope more people would take a look at Doggins and my arguments on Crusher.

That's because the circumstances of your reveal were pretty shady especially in light of the fact that you almost made the exact same mistake that Jets Babe did. Suspicion on you was highly warranted.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, now that I think about it I guess they actually could have just tried to roll the dice to try and take out the cop. That way they see if the doctor is active, and then in night 3 they go after doctor suspects. I retract my "throw off the scent" argument.

Good, because the only player who would benefit from a purposeful no kill would be Vicious if he were scum. You're arguing that point seemed like you were planting that thought in peoples heads maybe...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Good, because the only player who would benefit from a purposeful no kill would be Vicious if he were scum. You're arguing that point seemed like you were planting that thought in peoples heads maybe...

It just confused me why they would go after Vicious knowing woody was guilty because the probability of actually killing vicious was pretty low since the real doc would protect him. But like I said, I can now see they would just take the chance just to actually take out the cop.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That's because the circumstances of your reveal were pretty shady especially in light of the fact that you almost made the exact same mistake that Jets Babe did. Suspicion on you was highly warranted.

My "mistake" was after taking two days of bashing.

My reveal was perfectly fine and I've proven it so.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Alright I didn't want to do this so early but I seem to not have much of a choice. I am the doctor. Unfortunately I'm going to be away from my computer for the most of the night. I have been busy with school work lately and have a couple of midterms this week. Thats why I have been posting so infrequently this game. Hopefully I won't get killed before I get a chance to get back to the computer which most likely won't be until tomorrow afternoon.

Since Im the hot topic. I have to say one more thing. I will get back here when and if I can. I am not a zombie. I will be on around 7, if you lynch me before then you will feel stupid.

Similar enough for you guys? Feel the heat, run away and hope we get onto another topic.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm thinking they killed JiF because he was basically a confirmed innocent. It was he who went after Woody initially and exploited him for what he was.

That being said, they could have had an agenda against him for his last post, which IMO gave some good ideas. To go after the guys who did not say much regarding Woody.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm thinking they killed JiF because he was basically a confirmed innocent. It was he who went after Woody initially and exploited him for what he was.

That being said, they could have had an agenda against him for his last post, which IMO gave some good ideas. To go after the guys who did not say much regarding Woody.

I don't agree and also debunks the theory that someone posted where maybe mafia did not log in a kill the night nothing happened to throw us off.

I'm thinking they went for Vicious, who was protected. Then, knowing that Vicious would be protected again by the Doc, decided to take out a smart player, JiF.

I have no proof, it just make sense to me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't agree and also debunks the theory that someone posted where maybe mafia did not log in a kill the night nothing happened to throw us off.

I'm thinking they went for Vicious, who was protected. Then, knowing that Vicious would be protected again by the Doc, decided to take out a smart player, JiF.

I have no proof, it just make sense to me.

That's my guess.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Doggin? You taught me how to be scum, and you know I'm not now. Why your pressuring me is interesting and should be to all. Funny how easily the brightest cat in this game is assuming vic is absolutely innocent because he investigated Woody. Tell me who the hell didn't know Woody wasn't lying?

Odd activity? Voting for scum and not voting for innocents is weird? Cause thats exactly what I have done this game.

I did indeed, which is why you voting for Woody rings bells for me. Not loud ones, but still - given the odds, and the fact that you're one of the people vicious is unclear on, it's worth a shot. Like I said to Norway, clear out the underbrush and the innocents win.

I'm kind of suspicious of Bleedin, too, but only because I always am. :biggrin:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I did indeed, which is why you voting for Woody rings bells for me. Not loud ones, but still - given the odds, and the fact that you're one of the people vicious is unclear on, it's worth a shot. Like I said to Norway, clear out the underbrush and the innocents win.

I'm kind of suspicious of Bleedin, too, but only because I always am. :biggrin:

I understand Doggin. I only have the towns best interest in mind. I

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I did indeed, which is why you voting for Woody rings bells for me. Not loud ones, but still - given the odds, and the fact that you're one of the people vicious is unclear on, it's worth a shot. Like I said to Norway, clear out the underbrush and the innocents win.

I'm kind of suspicious of Bleedin, too, but only because I always am. :biggrin:

Right back at you, buddy. :biggrin:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I did indeed, which is why you voting for Woody rings bells for me. Not loud ones, but still - given the odds, and the fact that you're one of the people vicious is unclear on, it's worth a shot. Like I said to Norway, clear out the underbrush and the innocents win.

I'm kind of suspicious of Bleedin, too, but only because I always am. :biggrin:

Was this the game that ragu was bumrushed and was the doc?

I don't remember scum voting for on another in that game, but I do remember Crusher being coached. Are you saying you gave him advice to distance from other mafia early?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Was this the game that ragu was bumrushed and was the doc?

I don't remember scum voting for on another in that game, but I do remember Crusher being coached. Are you saying you gave him advice to distance from other mafia early?

I wasn't in the game with Ragu. The game I'm talking about only Doggin and I were mafia and we kicked ass.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wasn't in the game with Ragu. The game I'm talking about only Doggin and I were mafia and we kicked ass.

Yep. The day before endgame we decided he'd come out firing hard for me. I got lynched, flipped as mafia on coroner, and nobody questioned Crush for the rest of the game.

Teamwork ftw

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yep. The day before endgame we decided he'd come out firing hard for me. I got lynched, flipped as mafia on coroner, and nobody questioned Crush for the rest of the game.

Teamwork ftw

You are sneaky.....

Still, I think your old compadre smells a little of scum. I'm glad we somewhat see eye to eye on this matter.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am not undermining vicious right now. I even said that i happen to believe him now. If there was a counterclaiming cop this current day phase would be the time to step forward and no one is doing so.

I still don't buy Doggin's argument about the mafia "happening" to find the real doctor. A lot of coincidence has to occur for this to occur.

What has to go right for Doggin's theory to work

1) Mafia found out the real doctor

2) Doctor chose to protect himself and not vicious

Again, BOTH have to work out for Doggin's belief to work out. That's too unlikely for my taste. My read on the mafia is that an experienced member is running the show. The NKs have shown to be so with taking out SMC, a potential threat. My read is the 2nd night was to throw off the scent. And day 3 was to go after Jif who played like he had a role in the beginning and was the only one to act strangely in public with all the mall talk. I'm not saying this as fact, just my theory on what's happening.

I have another theory on how this may have played out that I didn't even consider last night. I understand what Doggin was suggesting now (amazing how different comprehension skills are from 1am to 5pm) and for now I just want to keep that to myself just in case.

I think Crusher is a safe pick for us to look at now. War would be a decent pick too as he's been erratic at best, and one can't discount the distancing vote possibility with Woody. Yeah Crusher left his vote on Woody even longer than Vicious, JiF, and I, but he wasn't really active during that time period. There's also been enough Crusher posts that he's mostly avoided "inactivity suspicion" but I can't recall seeing to many posts of substance.

Personally I'd think War would be the better target as even if he is a townie he's only voted once this entire game and it was on JB so he's essentially (advanced apology for the pun) dead weight to the rest of us. No votes, no posts, no use...

No disrespect Vic, but:

Vote: War

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have another theory on how this may have played out that I didn't even consider last night. I understand what Doggin was suggesting now (amazing how different comprehension skills are from 1am to 5pm) and for now I just want to keep that to myself just in case.

I think Crusher is a safe pick for us to look at now. War would be a decent pick too as he's been erratic at best, and one can't discount the distancing vote possibility with Woody. Yeah Crusher left his vote on Woody even longer than Vicious, JiF, and I, but he wasn't really active during that time period. There's also been enough Crusher posts that he's mostly avoided "inactivity suspicion" but I can't recall seeing to many posts of substance.

Personally I'd think War would be the better target as even if he is a townie he's only voted once this entire game and it was on JB so he's essentially (advanced apology for the pun) dead weight to the rest of us. No votes, no posts, no use...

No disrespect Vic, but:

Vote: War

vote: War Ensemble

I think we've had enough wagons to start looking at voting patterns. How many days has this been going? One vote from War? Two votes from Jets Things? (one on Jets babe and one retaliatory vote on me?)

Crusher may not be the most experienced, but like he's mentioned in past games he's very receptive to direction. For now, Crusher is being active but WE is not. I say we make them both start talking a lot. I'm open to go in between the two depending on what seems to be the right direction to go.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have another theory on how this may have played out that I didn't even consider last night. I understand what Doggin was suggesting now (amazing how different comprehension skills are from 1am to 5pm) and for now I just want to keep that to myself just in case.

I think Crusher is a safe pick for us to look at now. War would be a decent pick too as he's been erratic at best, and one can't discount the distancing vote possibility with Woody. Yeah Crusher left his vote on Woody even longer than Vicious, JiF, and I, but he wasn't really active during that time period. There's also been enough Crusher posts that he's mostly avoided "inactivity suspicion" but I can't recall seeing to many posts of substance.

Personally I'd think War would be the better target as even if he is a townie he's only voted once this entire game and it was on JB so he's essentially (advanced apology for the pun) dead weight to the rest of us. No votes, no posts, no use...

No disrespect Vic, but:

Vote: War

No post of substance? I'm doing my best here. I don't throw out random theories that parade thru my head because I prefer to play a thinking mans game. But, when I do decide to share what I have it will be very interesting.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Vicious89x 243 Jets Voice of Reason 111 EY 98 shutout 85 CTM 74 Norway'sWaddlingMarmaloof 69 The Crusher 61 Jets Things 58 JiF 55 Doggin94it 54 Bleedin' Green 41 Irish Jet 34 war ensemble 29 Jets Babe 17 RaoulDuke 17 WoodyPaige 14 Thor99 13 SMC 7 BP 1 Show Thread & Close Window

Everybody keeps telling me Im not posting enough. I post plenty, sorry if it's not up to the standards of our full of himself little friend shutout.

Why is nobody wondering why Irish Jet is not posting much. Oh yeah he's sking in Bulgaria with the cast of the sound of music.

Didn't Raoul replace thor? Hell add those post and it's not even 40.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...