Jump to content

Wow, did anyone see this Ryan Moats Dallas police officer story?


Matt39

Recommended Posts

Yes - pointing a gun at someone can be considered battery, assault, and/or threatening depending on the jurisdiction. It would be considered battery or assault in my neck of the woods.

I was under the impression that battery requires physical contact. But then it's never come up for me. Not since college anyway.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was under the impression that battery requires physical contact. But then it's never come up for me. Not since college anyway.

I'm not an expert, but I don't believe there is a requirement for physical contact. At any rate, I have read news articles where people were charged wth battery but nothing indicated physical contact.

I do know that you can be charged for assault without any physical contact. There's been several stories recently where a person has been charged with assault on a government official just by pointing a gun at them (no struggle or contact - just the act of pointing the gun). Doesn't make much since really by using the term assault, but that's what they were charged with.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not an expert, but I don't believe there is a requirement for physical contact. At any rate, I have read news articles where people were charged wth battery but nothing indicated physical contact.

I do know that you can be charged for assault without any physical contact. There's been several stories recently where a person has been charged with assault on a government official just by pointing a gun at them (no struggle or contact - just the act of pointing the gun). Doesn't make much since really by using the term assault, but that's what they were charged with.

I'm wasn't questioning assault or threats or any subsequent things you brought up. Only that he didn't commit battery.

Doesn't matter. This cop's a tool. Gee, no one could have a reason to do a rolling-stop at a red light as they're pulling into the emergency room of a hospital. The fact that they call it the emergency room is pure coincidence. No one is ever in an emergency situation at such a place.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not an expert, but I don't believe there is a requirement for physical contact. At any rate, I have read news articles where people were charged wth battery but nothing indicated physical contact.

I do know that you can be charged for assault without any physical contact. There's been several stories recently where a person has been charged with assault on a government official just by pointing a gun at them (no struggle or contact - just the act of pointing the gun). Doesn't make much since really by using the term assault, but that's what they were charged with.

Assault is unlawfully causing someone to perceive an imminent threat of physical harm. Battery is unlawful touching. So you can have assault without a battery (point the gun, no follow through), battery with no assault (hit someone from behind, they never knew it was coming), or assault and battery (typical)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not an expert, but I don't believe there is a requirement for physical contact. At any rate, I have read news articles where people were charged wth battery but nothing indicated physical contact.

I do know that you can be charged for assault without any physical contact. There's been several stories recently where a person has been charged with assault on a government official just by pointing a gun at them (no struggle or contact - just the act of pointing the gun). Doesn't make much since really by using the term assault, but that's what they were charged with.

In wisconsin at least, assault is an attempt at injuring or threatening someone...battery is making contact. Like Sperm said, i learned this one in college too. :lol:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Assault is unlawfully causing someone to perceive an imminent threat of physical harm. Battery is unlawful touching. So you can have assault without a battery (point the gun, no follow through), battery with no assault (hit someone from behind, they never knew it was coming), or assault and battery (typical)

Thank God there wasn't any mayhem!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...