THE ILK Posted November 5, 2010 Share Posted November 5, 2010 The Top 100: NFL's Greatest Players NFL Rank Fans Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 1 1 Rice, Jerry WR 49ers 1985 18 seasons Draft vote Jerry Rice Jerry Rice WR Drafted: 1985, Round 1, Pick 16Career: 20 seasons, 303 gamesNotes: Arguably the best receiver ever, Rice owns nearly every major receiving record, including most catches (1,549), receiving yards (22,895) and TD catches (197). Rice has at least 400 more catches than any other receiver. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 2 9 Brown, Jim FB Browns 1957 9 seasons Draft vote Jim Brown Jim Brown FB Drafted: 1957, Round 1, Pick 6Career: 9 seasons, 118 gamesNotes: The hard-nosed Brown was a star from day one, and when he surprisingly retired after nine years, he had rewritten the record books. Arguably the best runner ever, Brown remains the only rusher to average over 100 YPG. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 3 12 Taylor, Lawrence LB Giants 1981 13 seasons Draft vote Lawrence Taylor Lawrence Taylor LB Drafted: 1981, Round 1, Pick 2Career: 13 seasons, 184 gamesNotes: Taylor was a playmaking linebacker who dominated opponents. He changed the game with his attacking style. In 1986, Taylor had 20.5 sacks and was named NFL MVP, the first defender to earn the award since 1971. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 4 2 Montana, Joe QB 49ers 1979 12 seasons Draft vote Joe Montana Joe Montana QB Drafted: 1979, Round 3, Pick 82Career: 16 seasons, 192 gamesNotes: Montana turned the 49ers into the team of the ‘80s as he led them to four Super Bowl titles. He was MVP in three of those wins. He directed 31 fourth-quarter comeback wins, including the winning drive in Super Bowl XXIII. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 5 3 Payton, Walter RB Bears 1975 13 seasons Draft vote Walter Payton Walter Payton RB Drafted: 1975, Round 1, Pick 4Career: 13 seasons, 190 gamesNotes: The NFL MVP in 1977 and 1985, Payton was an NFL superstar. He ran for more than 1,000 yards 10 times, including a high of 1,852 yards in 1977, and by the time of his retirement, "Sweetness" had smashed the record books. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 6 14 Unitas, Johnny QB Colts 1955 seasons Draft vote Johnny Unitas Johnny Unitas QB Drafted: 1955, Round 9, Pick 102Career: 19 seasons, 211 gamesNotes: With 40,239 yards and 290 TDs, Unitas was the NFL's most prolific passer at the time of his retirement. But numbers tell only part of the story. His leadership and poise are what really make him one of the all-time greats. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 7 11 White, Reggie DE Eagles 1984 seasons Draft vote Reggie White Reggie White DE Drafted: 1984, Round 1, Pick 4Career: 17 seasons, 232 gamesNotes: The "Minister of Defense" had 198 sacks (still No. 2 all-time) in 15 NFL seasons. After posting 124 sacks in 121 games with the Eagles, he signed with Green Bay in 1993 and soon helped the Packers win a Super Bowl. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 8 5 Manning, Peyton QB Colts 1998 Active 11 seasons Draft vote Peyton Manning Peyton Manning QB Drafted: 1998, Round 1, Pick 1Career: 12 seasons, 192 gamesNotes: Blessed with a strong arm, intelligence, determination and leadership, Manning has been compared to the NFL's greats. He has smashed the record books, with more marks destined to fall. He has started 192 straight games. Active NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 9 - Hutson, Don WR Packers 1935 seasons Draft vote Don Hutson Don Hutson WR UndraftedCareer: 11 seasons, 116 gamesNotes: The NFL's first great pass catcher, Hutson's numbers far exceeded those of his peers. He led the league in receiving eight times in his 11 seasons, and his 99 career TD catches stood 44 years as a league record. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 10 18 Butkus, Dick LB Bears 1965 9 seasons Draft vote Dick Butkus Dick Butkus LB Drafted: 1965, Round 1, Pick 3Career: 9 seasons, 119 gamesNotes: Driven to succeed, Butkus was one of the most feared defenders of his era. He racked up 22 interceptions and a then-record 27 fumble recoveries over his illustrious career. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 11 17 Lott, Ronnie DB 49ers 1981 14 seasons Draft vote Ronnie Lott Ronnie Lott DB Drafted: 1981, Round 1, Pick 8Career: 14 seasons, 192 gamesNotes: A ferocious tackler, Lott anchored the 49ers' first four Super Bowl teams and he finished his career with 63 INTs, adding an NFL-record nine more in the playoffs. Lott made 10 Pro Bowls at three positions (CB FS, SS). Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 12 80 Munoz, Anthony T Bengals 1980 12 seasons Draft vote Anthony Munoz Anthony Munoz T Drafted: 1980, Round 1, Pick 3Career: 13 seasons, 185 gamesNotes: Munoz was a fixture at left tackle for the Bengals for 13 seasons, beginning with his rookie campaign. His 11 Pro Bowls (all consecutive) were the most by an NFL player at the time of Munoz's retirement (1992). Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 13 29 Greene, Joe DT Steelers 1969 12 seasons Draft vote Joe Greene Joe Greene DT Drafted: 1969, Round 1, Pick 4Career: 13 seasons, 181 gamesNotes: The leader of the “Steel Curtain” defense of the 1970s, Greene was a disruptive force who dominated foes. He had strength and determination, and twice he was named the NFL Defensive Player of the Year (1972, 1974). Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 14 74 Baugh, Sammy QB Redskins 1937 22 seasons Draft vote Sammy Baugh Sammy Baugh QB Drafted: 1937, Round 1, Pick 6Career: 16 seasons, 165 gamesNotes: An accurate thrower, Baugh's passing ability helped change the game. He won a record six NFL passing titles, while also setting marks as a punter and defensive back. He led the NFL in passing, punting and INTs in 1943. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 15 43 Jones, Deacon DE Rams 1961 13 seasons Draft vote Deacon Jones Deacon Jones DE Drafted: 1961, Round 14, Pick 186Career: 14 seasons, 191 gamesNotes: Jones came out of almost nowhere and blossomed into a dominating pass rusher at defensive end. Jones missed just five games in 14 NFL campaigns and was selected to play in eight Pro Bowls, including seven in a row. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 16 75 Graham, Otto QB Browns 1944 12 seasons Draft vote Otto Graham Otto Graham QB Drafted: 1944, Round 1, Pick 4Career: 12 seasons, 126 gamesNotes: The consummate leader, Graham played four years in the AAFC and six in the NFL, and he guided the Browns to the league title game in each of them. He passed for 174 touchdowns and ran for 44. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 17 4 Sanders, Barry RB Lions 1989 10 seasons Draft vote Barry Sanders Barry Sanders RB Drafted: 1989, Round 1, Pick 3Career: 10 seasons, 153 gamesNotes: One of the most electrifying runners until his surprise retirement after 10 seasons, Sanders smashed the record books despite being the Lions' only real weapon. He was the first player to have five 1,500-yard seasons. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 18 16 Lewis, Ray LB Ravens 1996 Active 11 seasons Draft vote Ray Lewis Ray Lewis LB Drafted: 1996, Round 1, Pick 26Career: 14 seasons, 194 gamesNotes: Lewis is an intimidating linebacker with the ability to change a game with his aggressive play. Twice he was named NFL Defensive Player of the Year (2000, 2003) and he also took home MVP honors for Super Bowl XXXV. Active NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 19 - Nagurski, Bronko FB Bears 1930 14 seasons Draft vote Bronko Nagurski Bronko Nagurski FB UndraftedCareer: 14 seasons, 97 gamesNotes: The legendary Nagurski's reputation as a bulldozing runner, fierce blocker, and rugged linebacker survives 80 years after he made his NFL debut. A charter member of the Hall of Fame, he helped the Bears win three titles. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 20 6 Favre, Brett QB Packers 1991 Active 17 seasons Draft vote Brett Favre Brett Favre QB Drafted: 1991, Round 2, Pick 33Career: 19 seasons, 289 gamesNotes: The first player to be named MVP three straight years, Favre is the all-time leader in almost every passing category, including yards (69,329) and TDs (497). He broke Jim Marshall's mark for consecutive starts at any position. Active NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 21 20 Brady, Tom QB Patriots 2000 Active 10 seasons Draft vote Tom Brady Tom Brady QB Drafted: 2000, Round 6, Pick 199Career: 10 seasons, 129 gamesNotes: Brady ranks among the best in the NFL ever, having assaulted the record books in his 10 years in the league en route to leading the Pats to three Super Bowl wins in four years and a perfect 2007 regular season. Active NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 22 26 Sayers, Gale RB Bears 1965 5 seasons Draft vote Gale Sayers Gale Sayers RB Drafted: 1965, Round 1, Pick 4Career: 7 seasons, 68 gamesNotes: The Hall's youngest inductee (34), the "Kansas Comet" burned out far too early due to injury. A dynamic runner and kick returner, Sayers danced through defenders for 9,435 combined net yards in just 68 games. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 23 8 Elway, John QB Broncos 1983 16 seasons Draft vote John Elway John Elway QB Drafted: 1983, Round 1, Pick 1Career: 16 seasons, 234 gamesNotes: Elway's cannon arm and football savvy produced 51,475 passing yards and a remarkable 47 fourth-quarter comebacks. He capped his 16-year career by leading the Broncos to back-to-back Super Bowl victories. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 24 - Hannah, John G Patriots 1973 13 seasons Draft vote John Hannah John Hannah G Drafted: 1973, Round 1, Pick 4Career: 13 seasons, 183 gamesNotes: Hannah was a top guard in the NFL, earning Pro Bowl status nine times. A fierce blocker, he was the anchor of a talented front line that paved the way for the Pats to pile up a then-record 3,165 yards rushing in 1978. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 25 7 Marino, Dan QB Dolphins 1983 16 seasons Draft vote Dan Marino Dan Marino QB Drafted: 1983, Round 1, Pick 27Career: 17 seasons, 242 gamesNotes: The Dolphins got the steal of the 1983 draft when Marino surprisingly fell to them at No. 27. By the time he retired following the 1999 season, the prolific Marino had put his name atop nearly every NFL passing record. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 26 97 Lilly, Bob DT Cowboys 1961 14 seasons Draft vote Bob Lilly Bob Lilly DT Drafted: 1961, Round 1, Pick 13Career: 14 seasons, 196 gamesNotes: Dallas' first-ever draft pick and first Hall of Famer, Lilly started out at defensive end but moved to tackle later with impressive results. He was dominant as a pass rusher and run defender, using his quickness to create havoc. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 27 92 Olsen, Merlin DT Rams 1962 15 seasons Draft vote Merlin Olsen Merlin Olsen DT Drafted: 1962, Round 1, Pick 3Career: 15 seasons, 208 gamesNotes: Olsen anchored the Rams' "Fearsome Foursome" from his defensive tackle position. He made the Pro Bowl as a rookie in 1962...and every season after that through 1975 for a record 14 all-star nods in a row. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 28 10 Smith, Emmitt RB Cowboys 1990 14 seasons Draft vote Emmitt Smith Emmitt Smith RB Drafted: 1990, Round 1, Pick 17Career: 15 seasons, 226 gamesNotes: The all-time rushing leader (18,355), Smith was the heart and soul of Dallas' 1990s championship teams. In 1993, he was MVP of both the season and Super Bowl XXVIII. He ran for 1,000 yards in a record 11 straight years. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 29 41 Lambert, Jack LB Steelers 1974 10 seasons Video Draft vote Jack Lambert Jack Lambert LB Drafted: 1974, Round 2, Pick 46Career: 11 seasons, 146 gamesNotes: Lambert was a vicious tackler who was recognized as the premier linebacker of his era. He started in the middle as a rookie and remained there. He led Pittsburgh in tackles every season except his last. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 30 59 Train Lane, Night CB Lions 1952 14 seasons Draft vote Night Train Lane Night Train Lane CB UndraftedCareer: 14 seasons, 157 gamesNotes: Lane holds one of the NFL's longest-standing individual records: 14 interceptions in a season. He set the mark as a rookie in 1952, and he went on to pick off 68 passes in his 14-year career. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 31 33 Smith, Bruce DE Bills 1985 18 seasons Draft vote Bruce Smith Bruce Smith DE Drafted: 1985, Round 1, Pick 1Career: 19 seasons, 279 gamesNotes: The NFL's sack leader (200) despite constant double-teaming, Smith terrorized offenses with his speed and strength. He was Defensive Player of the Year in '90 and '96, and had 10-plus sacks in an NFL-record 13 years. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 32 - Parker, Jim T Colts 1957 10 seasons Draft vote Jim Parker Jim Parker T Drafted: 1957, Round 1, Pick 8Career: 11 seasons, 135 gamesNotes: The first full-time offensive lineman inducted into the Hall, Parker had been a two-way tackle in college but settled in on the offensive side in the pros. He wound up playing half of his career at tackle and half at guard. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 33 - Luckman, Sid QB Bears 1939 17 seasons Draft vote Sid Luckman Sid Luckman QB Drafted: 1939, Round 1, Pick 2Career: 12 seasons, 128 gamesNotes: The first successful T-formation quarterback in NFL history, Luckman led the Bears to four championships, including one in his MVP season of 1943. Luckman still owns most of the Bears passing records. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 34 19 Sanders, Deion DB Falcons 1989 12 seasons Draft vote Deion Sanders Deion Sanders DB Drafted: 1989, Round 1, Pick 5Career: 17 seasons, 188 gamesNotes: Sanders was arguably the most feared corner of his era, using his speed and glue-like cover skills to shut down receivers. A return specialist and occasional receiver, Sanders scored 22 TDs, including nine off his 53 INTs. NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 35 - Bednarik, Chuck LB Eagles 1949 14 seasons Draft vote Chuck Bednarik Chuck Bednarik LB Drafted: 1949, Round 1, Pick 1Career: 14 seasons, 169 gamesNotes: The No. 1 pick in 1949, Bednarik started at both center and linebacker. But while he was a two-way player for a large part of his career, it was his fierce linebacker play that turned heads. He missed just three games in 14 years. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 36 - Berry, Raymond E Colts 1954 13 seasons Draft vote Raymond Berry Raymond Berry E Drafted: 1954, Round 20, Pick 232Career: 14 seasons, 154 gamesNotes: A longshot to make the Colts, Berry tirelessly practiced running precise routes. It worked, as Berry and Johnny Unitas became one of the all-time best pitch-and-catch duos. He had a then-record 631 catches in 13 years. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 37 76 Thorpe, Jim RB Cardinals 1920 9 seasons Draft vote Jim Thorpe Jim Thorpe RB UndraftedCareer: 9 seasons, 52 gamesNotes: Thorpe excelled at every sport he played, and already was the most famous athlete in America when he began playing pro football in 1915. Five years later, he was named the fledgling NFL's president. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 38 - Alworth, Lance FL Chargers 1962 10 seasons Draft vote Lance Alworth Lance Alworth FL Drafted: 1962, Round 2, Pick 9Career: 11 seasons, 136 gamesNotes: The first AFL star to enter the Hall, "Bambi" was a graceful receiver who used his blazing speed to average 18.94 yards on 542 catches. He averaged more than 50 catches and 1,000 yards in nine years in San Diego. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 39 - Marchetti, Gino DE Colts 1952 15 seasons Draft vote Gino Marchetti Gino Marchetti DE Drafted: 1952, Round 2, Pick 14Career: 15 seasons, 161 gamesNotes: An 11-time Pro Bowl pick, Marchetti could do it all, but he was especially fearsome as a pass rusher. In 1969, the Pro Football Hall of Fame named him the best defensive end of the NFL's first 50 years. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 40 44 Simpson, O.J. RB Bills 1969 11 seasons Draft vote O.J. Simpson O.J. Simpson RB Drafted: 1969, Round 1, Pick 1Career: 11 seasons, 135 gamesNotes: The first player to rush for 2,000 yards in a season (1973), Simpson is the only one to do it over a 14-game campaign. Simpson won four rushing titles (1972, 1973, 1975 and 1976) and ran for 11,236 yards in his career. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 41 23 Woodson, Rod DB Steelers 1987 15 seasons Draft vote Rod Woodson Rod Woodson DB Drafted: 1987, Round 1, Pick 10Career: 17 seasons, 238 gamesNotes: Woodson was the first player to be voted to the Pro Bowl at corner, safety and kick returner. The 1993 NFL Defensive Player of the Year, Woodson ranks third all time with 71 INTS, an NFL-record 12 were returned for TDs. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 42 - Mackey, John TE Colts 1963 8 seasons Draft vote John Mackey John Mackey TE Drafted: 1963, Round 2, Pick 19Career: 10 seasons, 139 gamesNotes: Mackey revolutionized the tight end position, using his speed to stretch defenses. He averaged 15.8 yards on 331 receptions over his injury-shortened career, with two seasons in which he averaged over 20 yards per catch. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 43 91 Page, Alan DT Vikings 1967 15 seasons Draft vote Alan Page Alan Page DT Drafted: 1967, Round 1, Pick 15Career: 15 seasons, 218 gamesNotes: Smart and quick, Page was a key member of the "Purple People Eaters” defensive line. In 1971, he became only the second defender to be named NFL MVP. He was also Defensive Player of the Year in 1971 and 1973. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 44 65 Blount, Mel DB Steelers 1970 14 seasons Draft vote Mel Blount Mel Blount DB Drafted: 1970, Round 3, Pick 53Career: 14 seasons, 200 gamesNotes: Blount had size, speed and intelligence and was a major reason why the Steelers defense dominated opponents. The NFL Defensive MVP in 1975, Blount's 57 career interceptions remain a Steelers record. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 45 45 Gonzalez, Tony TE Chiefs 1997 Active 11 seasons Draft vote Tony Gonzalez Tony Gonzalez TE Drafted: 1997, Round 1, Pick 13Career: 13 seasons, 206 gamesNotes: Gonzalez's career receptions, receiving yards and touchdowns already top the seven tight ends in the Hall of Fame. He has missed just two starts since becoming a starter in 1998 and he enters 2010 one catch shy of 1,000. Active NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 46 30 Staubach, Roger QB Cowboys 1964 8 seasons Draft vote Roger Staubach Roger Staubach QB Drafted: 1964, Round 10, Pick 129Career: 16 seasons, 131 gamesNotes: Staubach was a playmaker for the Cowboys, leading them to six NFC title games and a pair of Super Bowl triumphs in his nine years at the helm. Along the way, he passed for 22,700 yards and 153 touchdowns. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 47 67 Nitschke, Ray LB Packers 1958 13 seasons Draft vote Ray Nitschke Ray Nitschke LB Drafted: 1958, Round 3, Pick 36Career: 15 seasons, 190 gamesNotes: An aggressive, determined competitor, Nitschke was the cornerstone of the great Packers defenses of the 1960s. He had 25 INTs and 20 fumble recoveries while playing on five NFL title teams and two Super Bowl winners. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 48 - Grange, Red RB Bears 1925 10 seasons Draft vote Red Grange Red Grange RB UndraftedCareer: 10 seasons, 96 gamesNotes: As the NFL's first big drawing card, "The Galloping Ghost" helped make pro football financially viable. He joined the Bears in 1925 and immediately went on a 17-game barnstorming tour. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 49 - Haynes, Mike DB Patriots 1976 12 seasons Draft vote Mike Haynes Mike Haynes DB Drafted: 1976, Round 1, Pick 5Career: 14 seasons, 177 gamesNotes: Blessed with speed and quickness, Haynes had a dazzling rookie debut with eight INTs and the Patriots' first-ever TDs on punt returns. In 14 seasons with the Pats and later the Raiders, he had a career total of 46 INTs. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 50 22 Bradshaw, Terry QB Steelers 1970 13 seasons Draft vote Terry Bradshaw Terry Bradshaw QB Drafted: 1970, Round 1, Pick 1Career: 14 seasons, 168 gamesNotes: The strong-armed Bradshaw displayed strong leadership in leading the Steelers to an unprecedented four Super Bowl titles in six years (1974-79). He was MVP of Super Bowl XIII and Super Bowl XIV. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 51 36 Starr, Bart QB Packers 1956 13 seasons Draft vote Bart Starr Bart Starr QB Drafted: 1956, Round 17, Pick 200Career: 16 seasons, 196 gamesNotes: From 17th-rounder to the Hall of Fame, Starr didn't blossom into a star and legend until Vince Lombardi arrived. He guided the Pack to five NFL titles and was MVP of the two Super Bowls. He led the NFL in passing three times. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 52 28 Dickerson, Eric RB Rams 1983 10 seasons Draft vote Eric Dickerson Eric Dickerson RB Drafted: 1983, Round 1, Pick 2Career: 11 seasons, 146 gamesNotes: Dickerson burst onto the scene with a record-setting rookie campaign. The following year (1984), he shattered the season rushing mark with 2,105 yards. Dickerson retired as the second-leading rusher (13,259 yards). Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 53 - Lanier, Willie LB Chiefs 1967 11 seasons Draft vote Willie Lanier Willie Lanier LB Drafted: 1967, Round 2, Pick 50Career: 11 seasons, 149 gamesNotes: A tenacious defender with fierce tackling ability, Lanier grabbed the starting middle linebacker job as a rookie and never let go. He intercepted at least two passes every year -- except for his first and last seasons. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 54 - Gregg, Forrest T Packers 1956 11 seasons Draft vote Forrest Gregg Forrest Gregg T Drafted: 1956, Round 2, Pick 20Career: 16 seasons, 193 gamesNotes: Gregg made up for his smallish size at right tackle by watching film to perfect his craft. He ended up playing in a then-record 188 straight games. When needed, he moved to guard and excelled there as well. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 55 35 Campbell, Earl RB Oilers 1978 7 seasons Draft vote Earl Campbell Earl Campbell RB Drafted: 1978, Round 1, Pick 1Career: 8 seasons, 115 gamesNotes: Campbell was a bruising runner whose impact was immediate. He led the NFL in rushing in each of his first three seasons, including a 1,934-yard performance in 1980. In eight years, he rushed for 9,407 yards and 74 TDs. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 56 77 Upshaw, Gene G Raiders 1967 14 seasons Draft vote Gene Upshaw Gene Upshaw G Drafted: 1967, Round 1, Pick 17Career: 15 seasons, 217 gamesNotes: Upshaw entered the NFL with experience at every offensive line position, but he settled in at guard and remained there for the next 15 seasons. He was a team leader and an integral part of a powerful Raiders front. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 57 15 Singletary, Mike LB Bears 1981 12 seasons Draft vote Mike Singletary Mike Singletary LB Drafted: 1981, Round 2, Pick 38Career: 12 seasons, 179 gamesNotes: An intense, intimidating middle linebacker twice named NFL Defensive Player of the Year (1985, 1988), Singletary was the Bears' first- or second-leading tackler each of his last 11 seasons. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 58 - Van Buren, Steve HB Eagles 1944 8 seasons Draft vote Steve Van Buren Steve Van Buren HB Drafted: 1944, Round 1, Pick 5Career: 8 seasons, 83 gamesNotes: Van Buren was a tough runner who won four rushing titles, including one in 1945, when he led the NFL in scoring and kickoff returns too. With Van Buren powering the way, the Eagles won NFL titles in 1948 and 1949. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 59 55 Ditka, Mike TE Bears 1961 8 seasons Draft vote Mike Ditka Mike Ditka TE Drafted: 1961, Round 1, Pick 5Career: 12 seasons, 158 gamesNotes: The first tight end to be inducted into the Hall, Ditka was feared as both a receiver and blocker. The rugged tight end didn't miss a start (84 games) with Chicago and ended his career with 427 catches for 5,812 yards and 43 TDs. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 60 70 Ham, Jack LB Steelers 1971 12 seasons Draft vote Jack Ham Jack Ham LB Drafted: 1971, Round 2, Pick 34Career: 12 seasons, 162 gamesNotes: A big-play outside linebacker, Ham teamed with DE L.C. Greenwood and DT Joe Greene to give the Steelers an exceptionally strong, hard-hitting left side of the defense during the team's Super Bowl run. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 61 31 Tomlinson, LaDainian RB Chargers 2001 Active 8 seasons Draft vote LaDainian Tomlinson LaDainian Tomlinson RB Drafted: 2001, Round 1, Pick 5Career: 9 seasons, 141 gamesNotes: One of the greatest runners in history, Tomlinson has rewritten the record books, including setting the NFL mark for most TDs in a season (31). Twice he won rushing titles and he sits eighth in career rushing yards (12,490). Active NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 62 72 White, Randy DT Cowboys 1975 11 seasons Draft vote Randy White Randy White DT Drafted: 1975, Round 1, Pick 2Career: 14 seasons, 209 gamesNotes: White developed into a star after moving from linebacker to defensive tackle, where he earned nine straight Pro Bowl invites. The co-MVP of Super Bowl XII, White missed one game in 14 years and posted 111 career sacks. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 63 - Otto, Jim C Raiders 1960 15 seasons Draft vote Jim Otto Jim Otto C UndraftedCareer: 15 seasons, 210 gamesNotes: The center on the All-Time AFL Team, Otto played in 12 AFL All-Star Games or AFC-NFC Pro Bowls in his 15 seasons. He was the starting center for each of the first 210 games that the Raiders ever played. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 64 - Adderley, Herb DB Packers 1961 12 seasons Draft vote Herb Adderley Herb Adderley DB Drafted: 1961, Round 1, Pick 12Career: 12 seasons, 164 gamesNotes: Adderley had all the tools to excel at corner -- instincts, speed and size. He picked off 48 career passes. First with Green Bay (1961-69) then Dallas (1970-72), he played in four of the first six Super Bowls, winning three. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 65 24 Moss, Randy WR Vikings 1998 Active 11 seasons Draft vote Randy Moss Randy Moss WR Drafted: 1998, Round 1, Pick 21Career: 12 seasons, 186 gamesNotes: The more Moss plays, the more records that fall. In 2009, Moss became the second player (Jerry Rice) to record 10 or more years with 1,000 receiving yards. He also tied Rice for the most career 10-plus TD seasons with nine. Active NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 66 - Brown, Willie CB Raiders 1963 16 seasons Draft vote Willie Brown Willie Brown CB UndraftedCareer: 16 seasons, 204 gamesNotes: Brown intercepted 54 passes and was an all-star nine times in 16 years with the Broncos and Raiders. He made a key play in Oakland's win over Minnesota in Super Bowl XI when he returned a theft 75 yards for a TD. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 67 69 Winslow, Kellen TE Chargers 1979 7 seasons Draft vote Kellen Winslow Kellen Winslow TE Drafted: 1979, Round 1, Pick 13Career: 9 seasons, 109 gamesNotes: Hampered by knee injuries much of his career, Winslow still gave defenders fits. He had 89 catches for 1,290 yards in '80 and twice had seasons of 88 grabs. In nine years, he had 541 catches for 6,741 yards and 45 TDs. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 68 - Webster, Mike C Steelers 1974 14 seasons Draft vote Mike Webster Mike Webster C Drafted: 1974, Round 5, Pick 125Career: 17 seasons, 245 gamesNotes: Webster anchored one of the strongest lines of his era. He played in 150 straight games, and suited up for more seasons (15) and more games (220) than any other Steeler. He ended his career in Kansas City (1989-90). Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 69 - Bell, Bobby LB Chiefs 1963 12 seasons Draft vote Bobby Bell Bobby Bell LB Drafted: 1963, Round 7, Pick 56Career: 12 seasons, 168 gamesNotes: The first Chiefs player to be elected to the Hall, Bell began his career as a defensive end but then shifted to outside linebacker. Overall, Bell had 26 INTs, returning six for TDs, adding two more scores on fumble recoveries. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 70 21 Faulk, Marshall RB Rams 1994 11 seasons Draft vote Marshall Faulk Marshall Faulk RB Drafted: 1994, Round 1, Pick 2Career: 12 seasons, 176 gamesNotes: While Faulk had success as a Colt (1994-98), he was a bigger all-around threat as the catalyst for the Rams' prolific attack. In '99, he set a then-record with 2,429 yards from scrimmage and he was the NFL MVP in 2000. NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 71 - Warfield, Paul WR Browns 1964 11 seasons Draft vote Paul Warfield Paul Warfield WR Drafted: 1964, Round 1, Pick 11Career: 14 seasons, 157 gamesNotes: A long-ball threat whose presence greatly benefited the running game, Warfield's 52 catches as a rookie was his career high. He excelled in Cleveland for six seasons before his 1970 trade to Miami gave the Dolphins a boost. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 72 81 Ogden, Jonathan OL Ravens 1996 12 seasons Video Draft vote Jonathan Ogden Jonathan Ogden OL Drafted: 1996, Round 1, Pick 4Career: 12 seasons, 177 gamesNotes: The first draft pick in Ravens' history, the hulking lineman made it a great choice. He started at guard as a rookie, then moved to tackle in 1997 and made the Pro Bowl 11 seasons in a row at that position. NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 73 88 Newsome, Ozzie TE Browns 1978 13 seasons Draft vote Ozzie Newsome Ozzie Newsome TE Drafted: 1978, Round 1, Pick 23Career: 13 seasons, 198 gamesNotes: Named the Browns' Offensive Player of the Year as a rookie, Newsome wound up becoming a team leader and a fixture at tight end, catching at least one pass in 150 straight games. He left as the leading TE in NFL history. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 74 - Motley, Marion FB Browns 1946 10 seasons Draft vote Marion Motley Marion Motley FB UndraftedCareer: 10 seasons, 106 gamesNotes: Motley, who helped break pro football's color barrier in 1946, was the AAFC's all-time leading rusher. When the Browns joined the NFL in 1950, he topped that league in rushing in his first year, too. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 75 58 Green, Darrell DB Redskins 1983 15 seasons Video Draft vote Darrell Green Darrell Green DB Drafted: 1983, Round 1, Pick 28Career: 20 seasons, 295 gamesNotes: With his blazing speed and covering ability, Green developed into a premier corner and remained one over his 20-season career. He had at least one INT in a record 19 straight years, and had a club-record 54 overall. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 76 90 Shell, Art T Raiders 1968 12 seasons Draft vote Art Shell Art Shell T Drafted: 1968, Round 3, Pick 80Career: 15 seasons, 207 gamesNotes: One of the best Raiders offensive linemen ever, Shell teamed with left guard Gene Upshaw to give the Raiders a dominant front line. Shell excelled at both run blocking and pass protecting. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 77 37 Dorsett, Tony RB Cowboys 1977 11 seasons Draft vote Tony Dorsett Tony Dorsett RB Drafted: 1977, Round 1, Pick 2Career: 12 seasons, 173 gamesNotes: Dorsett made quite a splash as a rookie, rushing for 1,007 yards and 12 TDs to help lead Dallas to a Super Bowl win. He wound up hitting 1,000 yards rushing in eight of his first nine years and retiring with 12,739 yards. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 78 79 Matthews, Bruce G Titans 1983 19 seasons Draft vote Bruce Matthews Bruce Matthews G Drafted: 1983, Round 1, Pick 9Career: 19 seasons, 296 gamesNotes: Matthews had tremendous versatility, lining up at every position, with the most starts at guard and center. He was voted to 14 straight Pro Bowls (nine at guard, five at center), tied for the most ever. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 79 - Tunnell, Emlen DB Giants 1948 14 seasons Draft vote Emlen Tunnell Emlen Tunnell DB UndraftedCareer: 14 seasons, 167 gamesNotes: Tunnell was called the Giants' "offense on defense" for his ability to make big plays from his defensive back position. His 79 career interceptions ranks second in NFL history, and his 1,282 yards on those picks ranks fourth. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 80 25 Aikman, Troy QB Cowboys 1989 12 seasons Draft vote Troy Aikman Troy Aikman QB Drafted: 1989, Round 1, Pick 1Career: 12 seasons, 165 gamesNotes: Aikman was thrown to the wolves as a rookie starter, but as he improved, so too did the Cowboys. Aikman was a steady leader of an explosive attack and he directed Dallas to three Super Bowl wins, earning SB XXVII MVP. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 81 13 Young, Steve QB 49ers 1984 16 seasons Draft vote Steve Young Steve Young QB Drafted: 1984, Round 1, Pick 1Career: 16 seasons, 169 gamesNotes: Young led the NFL in passing a record-tying six times. His signature moment came in Super Bowl XXIX, when he passed for 6 touchdowns and was named the MVP of the 49ers' rout of the Chargers. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 82 - Hendricks, Ted LB Raiders 1969 15 seasons Draft vote Ted Hendricks Ted Hendricks LB Drafted: 1969, Round 2, Pick 33Career: 15 seasons, 215 gamesNotes: Hendricks, a Pro Bowl linebacker in Baltimore, Green Bay, and Oakland, never missed a game in his 15 seasons. His speed and strength helped him block 25 kicks, intercept 26 passes, and recover 16 fumbles. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 83 - Van Brocklin, Norm QB Rams 1949 18 seasons Draft vote Norm Van Brocklin Norm Van Brocklin QB Drafted: 1949, Round 4, Pick 37Career: 12 seasons, 140 gamesNotes: Despite sharing passing duties wih Bob Waterfield, Van Brocklin still topped the NFL in passing in 1950 and '52, and once again in 1954. After his trade to the Eagles in 1958, Van Brocklin led the team to the NFL title in 1960. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 84 - Schmidt, Joe LB Lions 1953 11 seasons Draft vote Joe Schmidt Joe Schmidt LB Drafted: 1953, Round 7, Pick 85Career: 13 seasons, 155 gamesNotes: Schmidt fell in the draft due to injuries not talent. He quickly became a defensive leader and was voted to 10 straight Pro Bowls. He was a fast, fierce-tackling middle linebacker whose best asset may have been his instincts. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 85 32 Allen, Marcus RB Raiders 1982 12 seasons Draft vote Marcus Allen Marcus Allen RB Drafted: 1982, Round 1, Pick 10Career: 16 seasons, 222 gamesNotes: Allen was a versatile back who became the first player ever to gain more than 10,000 yards rushing and 5,000 yards receiving. He had a nose for the end zone, retiring with 145 TDs, including a then-record 123 on the ground. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 86 - Davis, Willie DE Packers 1956 11 seasons Draft vote Willie Davis Willie Davis DE Drafted: 1956, Round 15, Pick 181Career: 14 seasons, 162 gamesNotes: Davis struggled as an offensive tackle his first two seasons, but a trade to Green Bay changed his position -- and his fortunes. Davis developed into a speedy, big-play defensive end who recovered 21 fumbles over his career. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 87 - Hirsch, Crazylegs WR Rams 1945 13 seasons Draft vote Crazylegs Hirsch Crazylegs Hirsch WR Drafted: 1945, Round 1, Pick 5Career: 13 seasons, 127 gamesNotes: A three-time Pro Bowl pick, Hirsch had one of the best years ever by a wide receiver in 1951. He helped the Rams win the NFL title by leading the league with 66 catches for 1,495 yards and 17 TDs in the 12-game season. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 88 46 Reed, Ed DB Ravens 2002 Active 7 seasons Draft vote Ed Reed Ed Reed DB Drafted: 2002, Round 1, Pick 24Career: 8 seasons, 118 gamesNotes: Reed was a sensation almost from the start, making one big play after another. In 2004, he was the NFL Defensive Player of the Year. Reed holds the Ravens record for career picks with 46, six of which were returned for scores. Active NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 89 - Nevers, Ernie FB Cardinals 1926 6 seasons Draft vote Ernie Nevers Ernie Nevers FB UndraftedCareer: 6 seasons, 54 gamesNotes: Nevers was an iron man who rarely left the field on offense, defense, or special teams. He holds the NFL's longest-standing individual record: 40 points in a game against the rival Bears in 1929. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 90 27 Warner, Kurt QB Rams 1998 12 seasons Draft vote Kurt Warner Kurt Warner QB UndraftedCareer: 12 seasons, 125 gamesNotes: Though undrafted out of Northern Iowa, Warner went on to pass for 32,344 yards and 208 TDs in a stellar career. He was a two-time NFL MVP, including 1999, when he led the Rams to victory in Super Bowl XXXIV. NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 91 50 Tarkenton, Fran QB Vikings 1961 18 seasons Draft vote Fran Tarkenton Fran Tarkenton QB Drafted: 1961, Round 3, Pick 29Career: 18 seasons, 246 gamesNotes: Tarkenton's career got off to an exciting start with four TD passes in his first game. By the time he left after stints with the Vikings and Giants, he owned every major passing record, including 47,003 yards passing and 342 TDs. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 92 40 Irvin, Michael WR Cowboys 1988 10 seasons Draft vote Michael Irvin Michael Irvin WR Drafted: 1988, Round 1, Pick 11Career: 12 seasons, 159 gamesNotes: Irvin's career didn't take off until Troy Aikman and Emmitt Smith came on board. Irvin then rang up seven 1,000-yard seasons in eight years from 1991-98. He retired with 750 catches for 11,904 yards and 65 TDs. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 93 - Huff, Sam LB Giants 1956 13 seasons Draft vote Sam Huff Sam Huff LB Drafted: 1956, Round 3, Pick 30Career: 14 seasons, 168 gamesNotes: The hard-hitting Huff entered the NFL as a defensive lineman but moved to middle linebacker in the club's new 4-3 scheme. He went to five Pro Bowls, four with the Giants and one with the Redskins, and had 30 INTs. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 94 - Moore, Lenny HB Colts 1956 10 seasons Draft vote Lenny Moore Lenny Moore HB Drafted: 1956, Round 1, Pick 9Career: 12 seasons, 143 gamesNotes: Moore's main responsibility was to catch passes, forming a dangerous pitch-catch combo with Johnny Unitas. When Moore retired, he had amassed 12,451 combined net yards, 363 pass receptions and 113 TDs. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 95 89 Allen, Larry G Cowboys 1994 13 seasons Draft vote Larry Allen Larry Allen G Drafted: 1994, Round 2, Pick 46Career: 14 seasons, 203 gamesNotes: Allen bounced between guard and tackle over his career but was successful at both. An 11-time Pro Bowler, Allen was only the third player in NFL history to earn a Pro Bowl spot at more than one offensive line position. NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 96 - Hein, Mel C Giants 1931 15 seasons Draft vote Mel Hein Mel Hein C UndraftedCareer: 15 seasons, 170 gamesNotes: For 15 years, as a center on offense and a linebacker on defense, Hein rarely left the field. An All-NFL choice eight times, he never missed a game, and helped the Giants win a pair of league titles. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 97 66 Brooks, Derrick LB Buccaneers 1995 14 seasons Draft vote Derrick Brooks Derrick Brooks LB Drafted: 1995, Round 1, Pick 28Career: 14 seasons, 224 gamesNotes: One of the best players ever to don a Buccaneers uniform, Brooks was the heart and soul of his team's Tampa 2 defense. He could do it all, and the 11-time Pro Bowler finished with 1,689 tackles, 25 INTs and 13.5 sacks. NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 98 - Roy Selmon, Lee DE Buccaneers 1976 9 seasons Draft vote Lee Roy Selmon Lee Roy Selmon DE Drafted: 1976, Round 1, Pick 1Career: 9 seasons, 121 gamesNotes: The Bucs' first-ever draft pick, Selmon quickly established himself as a leader and earned team MVP honors as a rookie. Selmon was named the NFL Defensive Player of the Year in 1979, the Bucs' first winning season. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 99 47 Strahan, Michael DE Giants 1993 14 seasons Draft vote Michael Strahan Michael Strahan DE Drafted: 1993, Round 2, Pick 40Career: 15 seasons, 216 gamesNotes: Strahan gave opposing linemen fits, using his speed and strength to record 141.5 career sacks. He set the NFL record for sacks in a season with 22.5 in 2001, and was named the 2001 NFL Defensive Player of the Year. NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 100 42 Namath, Joe QB Jets 1965 9 seasons Video Draft vote Joe Namath QB Drafted: 1965, Round 1, Pick 1 Career: 13 seasons, 140 gamesNotes: Namath is best remembered for the Super Bowl III upset. However, "Broadway Joe" was actually one of the game’s most prolific passers. He still holds most Jets records, and in 1967, became the first to pass for 4,000 yards. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
T0mShane Posted November 5, 2010 Share Posted November 5, 2010 Q: Was Jerry Rice as dominant in his sport as Michael Jordan was in his? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
THE ILK Posted November 5, 2010 Author Share Posted November 5, 2010 Q: Was Jerry Rice as dominant in his sport as Michael Jordan was in his? That's a tough one, but I would say yes, and I think he deserved to be #1. With 2 different sports, it's hard to determine who was more dominate. I think records is the best indicator, to determine dominance among different sports. If that's the case Wayne Gretzky dominated way more than both of them, and he probably has more records than all of the rest bests combined. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SenorGato Posted November 5, 2010 Share Posted November 5, 2010 Q: Was Jerry Rice as dominant in his sport as Michael Jordan was in his? Rice's career, like Emmit Smith's career, was a clusterf*ck of things that have to go right to have a crazy good career. Winning, stable franchise at the time, arguably the GOAT at QB, an offense that fit his skills perfectly and was maybe 5-10 years ahead of it's time, an all time great coach who was the creator of said offense, and a whole lot of great players on offense. That said, Smith is a douchebag (IMO) while Jerry is as humble and intelligent as it gets in the sport. His longevity and work ethic are more than enough to make him a legend...to throw his tangibles on top of it... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Garb Posted November 5, 2010 Share Posted November 5, 2010 I do not agree with this #1 at all. I don't think a Reciever should ever be #1 regardless of stats, stature, etc. A great receiver needs a great QB to get the ball to him. You think Rice would have the stats he has if...say...Akili Smith was his QB? All the work ethic in the world wouldn't help Rice with that QB. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
JiF Posted November 5, 2010 Share Posted November 5, 2010 My choice would have been LT. Dude was the baddest mofo on the planet. And his success wasnt predicated on anything other than pure ability. Where as, Rice was part of a dominate team with an all time great QB, surrounded by talent and an all time great coach playing in a sh*tty division for his entire career. LT just dominated, didnt matter the circumstance. He revolutionized the game on both sides of the ball. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
HessStation Posted November 5, 2010 Share Posted November 5, 2010 No way you can argue with the top 5 imo. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
JiF Posted November 5, 2010 Share Posted November 5, 2010 No way you can argue with the top 5 imo. There is room for argument for the order, but not the player selected...IMO Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Klecko73isGod Posted November 5, 2010 Share Posted November 5, 2010 My choice would have been LT. Dude was the baddest mofo on the planet. And his success wasnt predicated on anything other than pure ability. Where as, Rice was part of a dominate team with an all time great QB, surrounded by talent and an all time great coach playing in a sh*tty division for his entire career. LT just dominated, didnt matter the circumstance. He revolutionized the game on both sides of the ball. In Rice's defense he didn't play his entire career with Joe Montana and didn't play his entire career with the 49ers. He had his best years with Steve Young but also take a look at his first two years with the Raiders, which were pretty damn good - 175 catches, 13.43 yards per catch, 16 TDs, he was 40 at the end of the second of those years - just insane. One of his most amazing accomplishments to me was when he cam back in 1998 after missing all but two games due to injury in '97 and caught 82 passes for 1157 yards and 9 TDs - at the age of 36! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
The Crusher Posted November 5, 2010 Share Posted November 5, 2010 My choice would have been LT. Dude was the baddest mofo on the planet. And his success wasnt predicated on anything other than pure ability. Where as, Rice was part of a dominate team with an all time great QB, surrounded by talent and an all time great coach playing in a sh*tty division for his entire career. LT just dominated, didnt matter the circumstance. He revolutionized the game on both sides of the ball. If LT forgets to rape that girl he's #1. Guy changed the game and made DC's poop their pants EVERY time he faced them. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
#27TheDominator Posted November 5, 2010 Share Posted November 5, 2010 I do not agree with this #1 at all. I don't think a Reciever should ever be #1 regardless of stats, stature, etc. A great receiver needs a great QB to get the ball to him. You think Rice would have the stats he has if...say...Akili Smith was his QB? All the work ethic in the world wouldn't help Rice with that QB. Oh please. Young took over that team and they improved. Maybe Akili Smith would have had a real career if he were throwing to Rice and Taylor with Walsh or Seifert as his coach. Young made the list. How'd he look in Tampa? Let alone Klecko's post SF stats. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
#27TheDominator Posted November 5, 2010 Share Posted November 5, 2010 30 59 Train Lane, Night CB Lions 1952 14 seasons LOL Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Smashmouth Posted November 5, 2010 Share Posted November 5, 2010 Q: Was Jerry Rice as dominant in his sport as Michael Jordan was in his? Cant compare. But were either of them as great as Wayne Gretsky ? heh Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Smashmouth Posted November 5, 2010 Share Posted November 5, 2010 No Don Maynard ? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
THE ILK Posted November 5, 2010 Author Share Posted November 5, 2010 8 active players made the list, all future hall of famers. Manning, Peyton Lewis, Ray Favre, Brett Brady, Tom Gonzalez, Tony Tomlinson, LaDainian Moss, Randy Reed, Ed Everybody else is already in the hall, except 7 players. Will they all get in? Sanders, Deion Faulk, Marshall Ogden, Jonathan Warner, Kurt Allen, Larry Brooks, Derrick Strahan, Michael Jones, Deacon was #15 behind 5 other defensive players. Should he have been higher? Greene, Joe Lott, Ronnie Butkus, Dick White, Reggie Taylor, Lawrence Warren Sapp was not in the top 100. Should he have been? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
JiF Posted November 5, 2010 Share Posted November 5, 2010 In Rice's defense he didn't play his entire career with Joe Montana and didn't play his entire career with the 49ers. He had his best years with Steve Young but also take a look at his first two years with the Raiders, which were pretty damn good - 175 catches, 13.43 yards per catch, 16 TDs, he was 40 at the end of the second of those years - just insane. One of his most amazing accomplishments to me was when he cam back in 1998 after missing all but two games due to injury in '97 and caught 82 passes for 1157 yards and 9 TDs - at the age of 36! Oh, so he traded one HOF QB for another HOF QB, then joined a team who produced an NFL MVP at QB. . Guy is top 3, but I'd have both Jim Brown and LT in front of him. If LT forgets to rape that girl he's #1. Guy changed the game and made DC's poop their pants EVERY time he faced them. Even with crack and rapes, he's #1 IMO. Changed the game like no defender has done before or since. Warren Sapp was not in the top 100. Should he have been? Absolutely. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
JohnnyHector Posted November 5, 2010 Share Posted November 5, 2010 Q: Was Jerry Rice as dominant in his sport as Michael Jordan was in his? Not even remotely close IMO. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SenorGato Posted November 5, 2010 Share Posted November 5, 2010 Jones, Deacon was #15 behind 5 other defensive players. Should he have been higher? I wish I got to see Deacon Jones...from what I hear about him he's basically LT before LT, except as straight up DE rather than stand up LB. Didn't they start recording sacks because of Jones? I'm still stunned Rice beat out Brown...Jim Brown made grown men look like little girly men. Even then I'm not even sure I'd go offense with #1...LT, White, or Jones are all guys I would argue as #1. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
THE ILK Posted November 5, 2010 Author Share Posted November 5, 2010 I wish I got to see Deacon Jones...from what I hear about him he's basically LT before LT, except as straight up DE rather than stand up LB. Didn't they start recording sacks because of Jones? I'm still stunned Rice beat out Brown...Jim Brown made grown men look like little girly men. Even then I'm not even sure I'd go offense with #1...LT, White, or Jones are all guys I would argue as #1. I think the only defensive guy I would take over Deacon is LT, that being said I would not argue if Brown or LT got #1, but I can understand Rice too. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
THE ILK Posted November 5, 2010 Author Share Posted November 5, 2010 Absolutely. I agree. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
JohnnyHector Posted November 5, 2010 Share Posted November 5, 2010 I wish I got to see Deacon Jones...from what I hear about him he's basically LT before LT, except as straight up DE rather than stand up LB. Didn't they start recording sacks because of Jones? I'm still stunned Rice beat out Brown...Jim Brown made grown men look like little girly men. Even then I'm not even sure I'd go offense with #1...LT, White, or Jones are all guys I would argue as #1. I think the only defensive guy I would take over Deacon is LT, that being said I would not argue if Brown or LT got #1, but I can understand Rice too. Give LT the head slap as part of his arsenal and we're not having this discussion. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
T0mShane Posted November 5, 2010 Share Posted November 5, 2010 Five best players I've actually witnessed in my lifetime: 1. Ronnie Lott 2. Lawrence Taylor 3. Reggie White 4. Jerry Rice 5. Ray Lewis Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
THE ILK Posted November 5, 2010 Author Share Posted November 5, 2010 Five best players I've actually witnessed in my lifetime: 1. Ronnie Lott 2. Lawrence Taylor 3. Reggie White 4. Jerry Rice 5. Ray Lewis Good list, care to add a RB and a QB? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
T0mShane Posted November 5, 2010 Share Posted November 5, 2010 Good list, care to add a RB and a QB? Montana is the best QB I've ever seen, but I'm not sure how to rank him because he played in an offense that turned the league on its ear and in which Steve Bono looked awesome. The best RB I've ever seen goes to two guys: Eric Dickerson and Emmit Smith. I loved watching Sanders run the ball, but I also watched him get shut down a few times because he danced in the backfield so much. Emmit and Dickerson always seemed to get 4 yards minimum, even out of a bad play. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
THE ILK Posted November 5, 2010 Author Share Posted November 5, 2010 Montana is the best QB I've ever seen, but I'm not sure how to rank him because he played in an offense that turned the league on its ear and in which Steve Bono looked awesome. The best RB I've ever seen goes to two guys: Eric Dickerson and Emmit Smith. I loved watching Sanders run the ball, but I also watched him get shut down a few times because he danced in the backfield so much. Emmit and Dickerson always seemed to get 4 yards minimum, even out of a bad play. I hear you on Montana, as for the running backs if you take the O line out of the equation, it makes picking one more easier, no? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SenorGato Posted November 5, 2010 Share Posted November 5, 2010 Montana is the best QB I've ever seen, but I'm not sure how to rank him because he played in an offense that turned the league on its ear and in which Steve Bono looked awesome. The best RB I've ever seen goes to two guys: Eric Dickerson and Emmit Smith. I loved watching Sanders run the ball, but I also watched him get shut down a few times because he danced in the backfield so much. Emmit and Dickerson always seemed to get 4 yards minimum, even out of a bad play. I'm the biggest Emmit Smith hater alive...To me he was a product of the best OL of the 90's and a great passing game. Best RB I've seen in my lifetime would be Sanders and then Tomlinson. Also, there isn't enough Randy Moss in this thread. He's probably the most explosive receiving weapon in any passing game in the history of the league...Guy could catch 10 TDs in his sleep. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Larz Posted November 5, 2010 Share Posted November 5, 2010 jim brown will always be #1 to me and jim thorpe should have been in the top 30 just on historical significance Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bobbyjet69 Posted November 6, 2010 Share Posted November 6, 2010 I'm the biggest Emmit Smith hater alive...To me he was a product of the best OL of the 90's and a great passing game. Best RB I've seen in my lifetime would be Sanders and then Tomlinson. Also, there isn't enough Randy Moss in this thread. He's probably the most explosive receiving weapon in any passing game in the history of the league...Guy could catch 10 TDs in his sleep. i agree with you on Emmitt, I think Sanders was hands down better! and if Randy Moss had Rice's work ethic and heart, he'd be unstoppable!! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bobbyjet69 Posted November 6, 2010 Share Posted November 6, 2010 I wish I got to see Deacon Jones...from what I hear about him he's basically LT before LT, except as straight up DE rather than stand up LB. Didn't they start recording sacks because of Jones? I'm still stunned Rice beat out Brown...Jim Brown made grown men look like little girly men. Even then I'm not even sure I'd go offense with #1...LT, White, or Jones are all guys I would argue as #1. they didn't start compiling sacks until the late 70's. supposedly Deacon Jones coined the term "sack" Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Vudu Posted November 6, 2010 Share Posted November 6, 2010 If Jerry Rice didnt have Montana and Steve Young throwing at him he wouldnt be the force he was. How stupid it is to put a WR @ #1. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
gg Posted November 6, 2010 Share Posted November 6, 2010 i think this is an impossible discussion.. its like comparing rembrandt, degas, monet and picasso.. cant be done well. all that being said.. i wouldnt have picked jerry rice.. not to delude his total awesomeness .. i do believe that the duo of montana and rice are the best offensive combo ever. i have to admit that i think sweetness should be higher. I am biased.. he is my favorite former non-JET player. BUT to watch him run was something of beauty and amazement.. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bitonti Posted November 6, 2010 Share Posted November 6, 2010 If Jerry Rice didnt have Montana and Steve Young throwing at him he wouldnt be the force he was. How stupid it is to put a WR @ #1. Joe Cool should be #1. If there was an all-time all-eras draft, Jerry Rice Wouldn't be the 1st overall pick. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bugg Posted November 6, 2010 Share Posted November 6, 2010 No Don Maynard ? This is a really weak underbelly, putting these guys on the list, and this high. Maynard is a HoFer and a contemporary of both guys . And I would take Maynard over both of 'em. They are all good WRs, but Maynard was better. Maynard stats wise is right there. heck, Fred Billitnikoff is there too. Berry was blessed to be Unitas' go to guy, Alworth a flashy rep. Not sure any of e'm except Maynard belongs. http://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/M/MaynDo00.htm- 36 - Berry, Raymond E Colts 1954 13 seasons Draft vote Raymond Berry Raymond Berry E Drafted: 1954, Round 20, Pick 232Career: 14 seasons, 154 gamesNotes: A longshot to make the Colts, Berry tirelessly practiced running precise routes. It worked, as Berry and Johnny Unitas became one of the all-time best pitch-and-catch duos. He had a then-record 631 catches in 13 years. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch 38 - Alworth, Lance FL Chargers 1962 10 seasons Draft vote Lance Alworth Lance Alworth FL Drafted: 1962, Round 2, Pick 9Career: 11 seasons, 136 gamesNotes: The first AFL star to enter the Hall, "Bambi" was a graceful receiver who used his blazing speed to average 18.94 yards on 542 catches. He averaged more than 50 catches and 1,000 yards in nine years in San Diego. Hall of Famer NFL Rank Rank Name Position Team First Year Status Career Watch Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Irish Jet Posted November 6, 2010 Share Posted November 6, 2010 Not even remotely close IMO. By the very nature of the two sports, it would be impossible for him to be as dominant. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
InstantClassic Posted November 6, 2010 Share Posted November 6, 2010 Maybe a spoiler alert so you don't ruin it for those of us that havent watched it yet? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.