<><><>You be John Idzik Super Poll Mock<><><>

[T0mShane]

EJ Manuel has everything you want in a quarterback other than the ability to play quarterback.

[JiFtheOracle]

I think he failed to live up to expectations at FSU. He was suppose to be the guy that brought them back to national prominence and really, never did...even backed by a stellar defense. The biggest knock is accuracy issues and inconsistency. ////file under: every QB in this draft////

So all things equal, IMO, either you take Geno or you go into that second tier of mishmash. Well then give me the 6'4 guy with a big arm who can run, seems like a good character kid and is built like a brick sh*thouse.

 

He was absolute let down at FSU.  His leadership was often questioned.  A quiet guy who doesnt have a big lockerroom presence who apparently gets rattled very easily.  His accuracy wasnt awful but thats because he's a check down Charlie.  His biggest issues are he's just not a talented passer, at all.  He has zero touch and no mid-deep range accuracy.  He's the prototypical, throw the ball up in the air and let the WR make a play type college QB.    He doesnt scan the field well and tucks and runs too often.  Shrinks is big games, never really had to do anything special for them to win (maybe once or twice but very lousy teams).  He doesnt play any big time competition and when he does, its typically not pretty (look at his games vs. Florida). 

 

He's going to get over drafted because he's an athletic freak.  He'll never be starter.  Bray is a much more natural passer and I'd rather take a flier on him in the 4th or beyond then waste a high draft pick on Manuel who will be  the next Jason Campbell.