Brett Gardiner or Jacoby Ellsbury?

[Blackout]

who is the better OFer?

[Jetsfan80]

Well, seeing as Gardner is playing out of his mind and Ellsbury is hurt, its clear who the better player is at the moment. But like anything else, especially in baseball where everything is in flux, this is subject to change.

[CrazyCarl40]

They're the same age and are almost the same player. Gardener walks more, Jacoby hits more. They're both lightning fast. Ellsbury has no real arm in the OF, don't know about Gardener, but he also gets to fly balls not many other humans would. It's close. It's like the Hughes/BUchholz thing. Going to be a few years before we find out.