best pitcher in the AL

[Thor99]

It's obviously Halladay. Put him on the Sox or the Yanks, and he's winning 25-28 games a year.

[PS17]

Halladay has been the best over the longest period of time...this is a no brainer.

[RexRyanRules]

6-8

3.83 era

1.234 whip

You realize that the numbers you're posting are included in the stats he's posting and that his stats give a much clearer picture than you cherrypicking whats above right?

[yisman]

absolutely not. Mine are AL stats. His include NL stats.

Since we're talking about AL pitchers, it would make sense to use AL stats. That's not cherrypicking. That's common sense. You want cherrypicking? Look at Durden attempting to throw CC's April stats out the window.

Oh, I want to congratulate CC on getting a win on Saturday. He's now up to 7-9 over the past two seasons in the AL.

[adb280z]

It's obviously Halladay. Put him on the Sox or the Yanks, and he's winning 25-28 games a year.

No one in modern baseball is winning 25-28 games. They only get 33-34 starts in a season.

[adb280z]

absolutely not. Mine are AL stats. His include NL stats.

Since we're talking about AL pitchers, it would make sense to use AL stats. That's not cherrypicking. That's common sense. You want cherrypicking? Look at Durden attempting to throw CC's April stats out the window.

.

Cherrypicking is referring to the last 2 seasons and not referring to 2007 & 2008 when we're only a week into 2009.