Choose One To Return in '25

[Barry McCockinner]

 

[rangerous]

I think I have to go with carter.  Reed is very good but getting up in years.  Carter is a home grown player.  Obviously it would be great to keep both.

[Barry McCockinner]

15 minutes ago, rangerous said:

I think I have to go with carter.  Reed is very good but getting up in years.  Carter is a home grown player.  Obviously it would be great to keep both.

They're both very good players I'd like to see the Jets keep but if I'm forced to choose it's MCII. He's better at slot CB compared to his peers than Reed is at CB2. Not a huge gap but MC2 is probably the best slot CB in the game at 25.

[slimjasi]

I’d choose Carter because of age and because he’s probably a top 3 slot corner, while Reed is probably a top 5-10 CB2

[Untouchable]

Carter

Cheaper, younger and has all the makings of one of the top slot corners in the league over the next 5 years.

[jetsons]

I want Both, but gun to head, I choose Carter, Great Slot Corners are a Difficult Find.

[JKlecko]

I hope that we can keep both, but if we can only keep one, I'd keep MC II for a couple of reasons.  One, even though I think Reed is better than MC II, he's older and is more expensive, and the Jets are gonna have a tight cap.  Two, MC II is home-grown.  Also, I have hopes that Stiggers can develop into the Jets #2 CB.

[Joe W. Namath]

Reed aint coming back unfortunately.  Cant pay everybody.