Who would YOU rather have at QB?

[Gastineau Lives]

Alot of QB's in the past have looked great in two game stretches. That doesn't guarantee they'll be great all year. Vick will be back down to earth and settle in around 15-20 overall. That would be 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, or 20 for those that question. Not 21, that would be 15-21.

Jaguars and Lions. Yeah, he's back. Couldn't be the teams he played.

I say 14. That would be 14-14. 15 if Flacco gets his a$$ together.

P. Manning

Brees

Rodgers

Brady

Roethlisberger

Rivers

Eli

Schaub

Matty Ice

Romo

Sanchize

Cutler

McNabb

[neckdemon]

mcnabb. i could never root for that scumbag vick.

[lancemehl]

If you recall mt, I called this.

I'd still rather have McNabb. Vick needs to prove he can sustain this level of play....but he's not going to be above Manning, Brees, Brady, Rodgers, Rivers, Big Rape...etc.

Shaub,Flacco.... oh, and most definitely McNabb

we are three games into the season and we have Vick in the top 5?? wow

[lancemehl]

Jaguars and Lions. Yeah, he's back. Couldn't be the teams he played.

I say 14. That would be 14-14. 15 if Flacco gets his a$$ together.

P. Manning

Brees

Rodgers

Brady

Roethlisberger

Rivers

Eli

Schaub

Matty Ice

Romo

Sanchize

Cutler

McNabb

yeah, that's about right, except he probably will end up below Favre, I know it's been three games, but...., possibly Carr and Garrard, too...and maybe Cassell, but then Vick, definitely.

[Greenranger]

McNabb, he's a good leader, a good player, and has good Character. Things the other two lack.