Who would YOU rather have at QB?

[Blackout]

with the big game this Sunday I'm wondering what everyone thinks.

[SoFlaJets]

x Mark Sanchez

[The Crusher]

Mike Vick looks like his rehabilitation worked. He went into jail a scrambling undisciplined QB and came out a pocket passer with patience and accuracy. Vic will be a top 5 QB this year. Book it.

[Blackout]

Mike Vick looks like his rehabilitation worked. He went into jail a scrambling undisciplined QB and came out a pocket passer with patience and accuracy. Vic will be a top 5 QB this year. Book it.

top 5??

[The Crusher]

top 5??

Yes, either 1 or 2 or 3 or 4 or 5. Not 6, that would be top six.

[dolphann4life]

Mike Vick no doubt.

[Maxman]

LOL Crusher

Vick has looked good and I root for him. Right now though I will still have to go with McNabb.

Good thread though Blackout.

[Jetsfan80]

Good thread though Blackout.

Only took him 25,000 posts to come up with one.

[Blackout]

Yes, either 1 or 2 or 3 or 4 or 5. Not 6, that would be top six.

hahaha thanks for clarifying the math sir

but I still forsee him being more of a top 6-10 QB than 1-5

[The Crusher]

hahaha thanks for clarifying the math sir

but I still forsee him being more of a top 6-10 QB than 1-5

Peyton, Tom, Drew, Vick, ? ,

Carson Palmer is in a slump and Philip Rivers lost his weapons.

[JustInFudge]

Mike Vick looks like his rehabilitation worked. He went into jail a scrambling undisciplined QB and came out a pocket passer with patience and accuracy. Vic will be a top 5 QB this year. Book it.

If you recall mt, I called this.

I'd still rather have McNabb. Vick needs to prove he can sustain this level of play....but he's not going to be above Manning, Brees, Brady, Rodgers, Rivers, Big Rape...etc.

[The Crusher]

If you recall mt, I called this.

I'd still rather have McNabb. Vick needs to prove he can sustain this level of play.

Yes you did call it. McNabb fades at the end of the season and is prone to injury. The new Mike Vick is wrapped in awesome and will have a Pro Bowl quality year.

[ZachEY]

I work with an Eagles fan... Today he said, "I never really liked dogs much anyway".

[PatsFanTX]

Peyton, Tom, Drew, Vick, ? ,

Rodgers, Schaub

[visajets]

Michael Vick is an elite NFL prototype QB. He can run and pass effectively. The NYJETS should have signed him.

[hoping4ASuperBowl]

Not even one for Kolb? I can't imagine no one out there will pull the sympathy vote.

[Jetsfan80]

Michael Vick is an elite NFL prototype QB. He can run and pass effectively. The NYJETS should have signed him.

We have a starting QB, and Vick is anything but prototypical.

[SenorGato]

Give me Mike Vick. He's back b*tches.

[Sharrow]

For this one game Skins vs Philly, I'd take McNabb. For the year and future, I'd take Vick.

Better games, McNabb vs the Eagles, or Favre vs GB last year?

[THE ILK]

For this one game Skins vs Philly, I'd take McNabb. For the year and future, I'd take Vick.

Better games, McNabb vs the Eagles, or Favre vs GB last year?

McNabb vs the Eagles, Eff Favre!

[Boozer76]

Alot of QB's in the past have looked great in two game stretches. That doesn't guarantee they'll be great all year. Vick will be back down to earth and settle in around 15-20 overall. That would be 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, or 20 for those that question. Not 21, that would be 15-21.

[kelticwizard]

True, Vick looked unstoppable in short stretches before incarceration.

Why are we so sure he will sustain this level of play now?

[Larz]

I voted mcnabb cuz I like agile QB's who are smart enought not to run around and take hits. vick is an out of this world talent, and an improved passer, but as a GM, I just don't want the key to my career running around with a twig body

[THE ILK]

Mcnabb has better numbers than Kurt Warner, it's close but Donavon's are better.

[CoachTsurfing]

Vick at the moment minus the dog abuse charges.

[visajets]

We have a starting QB, and Vick is anything but prototypical.

Explain your definition of prototypical.

[Irish Jet]

Vick at worst would always be a decent starter because of his legs. I'd take him over McNabb who can you just kill you when he's off and Kolb who has done nothing.

[Irish Jet]

Alot of QB's in the past have looked great in two game stretches. That doesn't guarantee they'll be great all year. Vick will be back down to earth and settle in around 15-20 overall. That would be 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, or 20 for those that question. Not 21, that would be 15-21.

[The Crusher]

Alot of QB's in the past have looked great in two game stretches. That doesn't guarantee they'll be great all year. Vick will be back down to earth and settle in around 15-20 overall. That would be 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, or 20 for those that question. Not 21, that would be 15-21.

He ain't settling down. He was worth a hundred million and Atlanta was a freaking shrine to this guy. All the while he was a "gimmick" QB who provided plenty of video highlights for ESPN. Then BOOM.. He ends up in prison with no money, no career not even a ******* job when he came out. ]\

Eagles brought him in a mere shadow of himself with people just waiting for him to play and be down to Earth. Boot Mcnabb and paid Colb naming him the starter without even a competition. It was assumed Vic would not start for them and take a lesser role. Lottery strikes and Kolb gets a ringer and Vic gets a chance to prove everyone right. Vic is done, never that good, blah blah blah and what do we end up with?

A new mature patient thoughtful QB, THANKFUL TO BE PLAYING AGAIN, and with not a ******* thing to lose. Nothing, guy is basically flat busted after being Elvis big.

He doens;t even look like himself in the pocket, he looks more like Steve Young. The way he plays QB first and then takes off if it isn;t their. The guy is playing the position like he is playing for the first time. I find it awesome to watch.

I did kinda forget about Rodgers and Schaub, thank you Tx you Patsie troll savant for pointing that pout. I say he will be top 8. Thats 1 or 2 or 3 or...

[slats]

Vick looked great against the Packers, and followed that up against two really bad teams in Detroit and Jacksonville. I'm not sold on him just yet. He'll probably have another great week against a crappy Washington team this week, but then it starts to get a little tougher for him.

I'd take McNabb.

[MikeyJig]

Lol Not a lot of love for Kolb thus far....

[Jbro22]

I can't wait to see the Movie that comes after all of this. I'm thinking it will be released in the late 20's early 30's.

Btw, who else can't wait to say 'Hey it's the Twenties'. I might buy a zoot suit now.

[Jbro22]

Oh and now would be a good time to point out that zoot suits weren't popular till the 40s. Jbro Fail.

[slats]

Lol Not a lot of love for Kolb thus far....

I think a big part of Andy Reid was hoping that Vick would fall on his face so he could get his boy back out out there.

Who knows? Kolb could still wind up being a great pro.

[Klecko73isGod]

If you recall mt, I called this.

I'd still rather have McNabb. Vick needs to prove he can sustain this level of play....but he's not going to be above Manning, Brees, Brady, Rodgers, Rivers, Big Rape...etc.

Don't forget Sanchez.