Who would you rather have

[Blackout]

which of these?

[Bob]

which of these?

Which of what?

Edit: The poll was not there when I posted. I voted for Ryan Howard.

[Blackout]

look harder

[Kidhuman]

I went with Howard, but wouldnt mind Albert.

[Blackout]

Howard over Fat Albert?

[Kidhuman]

[quote name='Blackout

[Blackout]

i'd say defensively albert is much better, base running wise he's much better

and offensively it's a draw IMO

[Sharrow]

I have a feeling that Pujols is going to have a monster season this year.

[Mavrik]

Right this moment, I would take Ryan Howard.

Albert Pujols is one arrant HBP away from having major reconstructive elbow surgery.

[Scott Dierking]

I voted Fielder. He is the youngest and has the most upside.

Don't forget though, Lee is a Gold Glove quality First baseman (the rest of these guys are pretty wretched), and if Lee can get to his 30 homerun platform again, he may take it as best overall.

[uart]

I voted Fielder. He is the youngest and has the most upside.

I voted Fielder as well.

7 stolen bases in 2006... I'd like to see Ryan Howard do THAT.

[Blackout]

pujols had 16 SB in 05

[Matt39]

How could you forget Giambi?

[Scott Dierking]

[quote name='Blackout

[Kidhuman]

Tough coices SD. I might have to take Santana if he is available.

[The Troll]

Before yesterday, I would have said Pujols, as much as I hate him. But with the serious injury risk, I'd have to go with Ryan Howard.

[Blackout]

i got Lee on my fantasy team, i hope he hits 30

[TaborJet]

I voted for Big Papi. Being a Yankee fan, I don't care if he plays 1st base. Let him DH.

The 2-3-4 in the lineup would be:

Jeter

Ortiz

ARod

Yeah, I could live with that.

[Kidhuman]

I voted for Big Papi. Being a Yankee fan, I don't care if he plays 1st base. Let him DH.

The 2-3-4 in the lineup would be:

Jeter

Ortiz

ARod

Yeah, I could live with that.

But you could have

Jeter

Howard

Arod

And a guy who is as big a threat and can play 1B better than Ortiz.

[TaborJet]

But you could have

Jeter

Howard

Arod

And a guy who is as big a threat and can play 1B better than Ortiz.

I would like to see Duncan develop at 1st.

IMO, Duncan + Ortiz > Howard.

[Kidhuman]

I wouldnt mind seeing Duncan at 1st myself.

Duncan and Howard > Ortiz

It can work both ways when you have numbers games

Andy Phillips and Howard(DH) > Ortiz