Jump to content

Open WR's


GangisGreen

Recommended Posts

Is it me or does it seem that our WR's are never open. Even when we complete a pass it is becuase Sanchez put the ball in a small window or the wr/te makes a great catch. Watching other teams, in particular the bills/pats game, it seems that there is always a open target with at least few yards separation. Now i know we love bashing Shotty, and I dont mean to start it again but is there any other factor than bad play design? Maybe bad routes by the WR? Whatever the reason it sure seems to be a constant problem.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was thinking about this too...we have 3 pretty good threats in Plax, Holmes & Keller...one of those guys HAS to be open on every play...those are 3 guys that a defense has to account for. So if all 3 are covered we should be having a field day with the running game! Doesn't seem to be happening though

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've wondered this sometimes as well, because teams constantly stack the box against us. I don't think Holmes is nearly as good as other people seem to think he is,

On Sunday early, receivers were open as the Raiders were in man and the receivers could put moves on their guys and get separation. Midway through the 2nd quarter the Raider adjusted and went to a zone. Dumbass Schotty did not adjust and he had his receivers running routes into the teeth of the zone.

Holmes mentioned it in an interview Monday. The OC's failure to adjust was just terrible. He had a good game plan. It worked early. But when the opponent adjusted he either failed to recognize it refused to change things up for some odd reason.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

when I played football in high school, our coach (on certain plays) used to have what he called a "floater". could be a WR, TE or HB, and whoever was the floater on that play would simply go where the coverage wasn't, worked pretty well actually

That would work in the NFL. I know most defenses don't account for every potential target going into each play. I say we just let a designated player that the defense isn't paying attention to run to the area in the defense where there is no coverage....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It think its design. I feel like we've been saying this for years with Schotty. The only game I can remember our WR's running lose was Arizona during the Favre game where he threw 6 TD's.

Seems like he throws a lot of dumby routes into the offense that are supposed to be decoy's but that just doesnt happen.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That would work in the NFL. I know most defenses don't account for every potential target going into each play. I say we just let a designated player that the defense isn't paying attention to run to the area in the defense where there is no coverage....

believe it or not it actually worked, the only problem is the QB had a tendency to automatically look at the floater, and in some cases just blatantly stare him down looking to get him the ball...but that was high school football. I'm sure professional athletes who do this for a living could make it work much better

Link to comment
Share on other sites

believe it or not it actually worked, the only problem is the QB had a tendency to automatically look at the floater, and in some cases just blatantly stare him down looking to get him the ball...but that was high school football. I'm sure professional athletes who do this for a living could make it work much better

I thought you were describing Sanchez, not the HS quarterback.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I thought you were describing Sanchez, not the HS quarterback.

haha! I like Sanchez, I really do, he's got a great attitude...but he definitely has his issues. 3rd year is the year the game is supposed to start slowing down for a QB...not seeing it yet though! He does make some great plays, just not consistently.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On Sunday early, receivers were open as the Raiders were in man and the receivers could put moves on their guys and get separation. Midway through the 2nd quarter the Raider adjusted and went to a zone. Dumbass Schotty did not adjust and he had his receivers running routes into the teeth of the zone.

Holmes mentioned it in an interview Monday. The OC's failure to adjust was just terrible. He had a good game plan. It worked early. But when the opponent adjusted he either failed to recognize it refused to change things up for some odd reason.

If Holmes called out the OC once again, it's even more reason to be negative about this guy. He's a big time whiner.

I do remember watching one particular replay where Holmes is running open for a loooong time... about 20 yards worth of time, but kept running his route straight into coverage instead of breaking it off for a potential big gainer.

I dunno... I suppose you could be right about the adjustments.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If Holmes called out the OC once again, it's even more reason to be negative about this guy. He's a big time whiner.

I do remember watching one particular replay where Holmes is running open for a loooong time... about 20 yards worth of time, but kept running his route straight into coverage instead of breaking it off for a potential big gainer.

I dunno... I suppose you could be right about the adjustments.

Except Holmes wasn't whining at all. He wants the team to be better and win. He went out of his way to say he doesn't give a damn if he catches a single pass so long as the team wins.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

None of our receivers are ever open, going all the way back to when Pennington was running this offense with Coles and Cotchery. I believe those threads would contain words like "no separation".

We replaced, upgraded, all of our WR talent... and yet the problem still exists. I've hypothesized about the cause being route design - but others blame the players for not execution. Probably somewhere in the middle.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On Sunday early, receivers were open as the Raiders were in man and the receivers could put moves on their guys and get separation. Midway through the 2nd quarter the Raider adjusted and went to a zone. Dumbass Schotty did not adjust and he had his receivers running routes into the teeth of the zone.

Holmes mentioned it in an interview Monday. The OC's failure to adjust was just terrible. He had a good game plan. It worked early. But when the opponent adjusted he either failed to recognize it refused to change things up for some odd reason.

This.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If Holmes called out the OC once again, it's even more reason to be negative about this guy. He's a big time whiner.

I do remember watching one particular replay where Holmes is running open for a loooong time... about 20 yards worth of time, but kept running his route straight into coverage instead of breaking it off for a potential big gainer.

I dunno... I suppose you could be right about the adjustments.

Holmes has a ring on his finger and has the taste of what it feels like to be on top of the world. Would expect a player of his caliber to want to win it all over again. But when he sees the OC coming up short in what is the basic requirement of being successful at this level like making in game adjustments its only natural to get frustrated.

And its not the first time. In the game against Cleveland last year it was Holmes idea for the JETS to throw on a slant which Schotty had not done the entire game and did end up resulting in winning the game.

When a leader like Holmes expresses this feelings against the OC to the media its not just a raw after game reaction. This must be the feeling in the locker room for quite sometime on this issue and shows how much respect Schotty commands from his own players.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

When a leader like Holmes expresses this feelings against the OC to the media its not just a raw after game reaction. This must be the feeling in the locker room for quite sometime on this issue and shows how much respect Schotty commands from his own players.

I disagree with all of this, starting from calling Holmes a leader. I've seen no evidence of that. What you say could possible be true, but I doubt it. When you consider how rarely the team ever says anything bad about Schotty when Rex lets them run their mouths at every opportunity I think to say this must be some long term feeling in the locker room is ridiculous.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I disagree with all of this, starting from calling Holmes a leader. I've seen no evidence of that. What you say could possible be true, but I doubt it. When you consider how rarely the team ever says anything bad about Schotty when Rex lets them run their mouths at every opportunity I think to say this must be some long term feeling in the locker room is ridiculous.

He is one of the captains on the team.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Is it me or does it seem that our WR's are never open. Even when we complete a pass it is becuase Sanchez put the ball in a small window or the wr/te makes a great catch. Watching other teams, in particular the bills/pats game, it seems that there is always a open target with at least few yards separation. Now i know we love bashing Shotty, and I dont mean to start it again but is there any other factor than bad play design? Maybe bad routes by the WR? Whatever the reason it sure seems to be a constant problem.

When teams know that you're running slant routes 95% of the time who the hell is going to be open?

Shotty needs to be fired. Then we'll get some open WR's

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I disagree with all of this, starting from calling Holmes a leader. I've seen no evidence of that. What you say could possible be true, but I doubt it. When you consider how rarely the team ever says anything bad about Schotty when Rex lets them run their mouths at every opportunity I think to say this must be some long term feeling in the locker room is ridiculous.

sorry Dom but i've watched too many offensive plays under schott's tenure to question Holmes' motive here. He is simply stating what we all know. schooty is a poor playcaller, bad gameplanner and a lousy in game adjuster.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

sorry Dom but i've watched too many offensive plays under schott's tenure to question Holmes' motive here. He is simply stating what we all know. schooty is a poor playcaller, bad gameplanner and a lousy in game adjuster.

We all agree on his motive, the question is was is a heat of the moment blow up or a bubble from festering unrest in the locker room? Despite all the Schotty hate on here, it is very rare to hear a player complain about him. That made sense under Mangini who wouldn't let anybody talk, but Rex practically encourages it and this is his third year. I have heard Holmes spout off a bit both with Jets and Steelers. I don't think there is much to it besides frustration over a loss.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...