HOTEL CALIFORNIA - TOWN WINS

[Spoot-Face]

We should also track and keep a list of everyone claiming to have used their knife, and who they stabbed.

[a_very_fat_raccoon]

1 hour ago, Andrej The Giant said:

The first one

Me and you got this.

[Spoot-Face]

3 minutes ago, a_very_fat_raccoon said:

Me and you got this.

Okay, so far to stab Shad, we have

1. AJ

2. Racoon

3. If I do it, that makes three, but we should have one more.

4. @Jetsfan80?

 

Has anyone else already used their knife on Shad N1? I recall at least one other person saying they stabbed someone, but I can't remember who.

And, of course, we need to realize that if this works and Shad is cleared, he's probably as good as dead anyway, but that should at least clear some of the people who volunteered to stab.

[a_very_fat_raccoon]

I already stabbed him last night.

[Spoot-Face]

Just now, a_very_fat_raccoon said:

I already stabbed him last night.

Okay, then tonight, it can be:

1. AJ

2. Spoot

3. @Jetsfan80?

 

If Shad is scum and dies, then we can reasonably assume that 3 of the following are Town

1. Raccoon

2. AJ

3. Spoot

4. 80

If he doesn't, then either:

(A) Shad is Town

(B) At least 2 of the four are Scum

 

Either way, we'll keep a track of everyone claiming to have used their knife, and on who. I've started a list, but everyone else should, too, if I should be NK'd.

So far we've got:

Steely Knives

1. Raccoon -- stabbed Shad N1

[Krak]

2 hours ago, JiF said:

We spent 50 pages chasing our tails trying to figure out these stupid messages he was lying about and then what?  

Speak for yourself

[Krak]

Pac, Nolder, Hallia gone - from OP

 

11. Nolder - MK'd

18. Pac - MK'd

19. Hallia - MK'd

 

14 left alive

[Krak]

I can't help but think 2/3 at least are town

[Krak]

Lizard still alive makes me think scum

[Spoot-Face]

5 minutes ago, Krak said:

Lizard still alive makes me think scum

Could be.

[A.J.]

1 hour ago, Spoot-Face said:

We should also track and keep a list of everyone claiming to have used their knife, and who they stabbed.

I used mine this phase. Someone knows who I am targeting.

[The Crusher]

3 hours ago, Shad said:

Scum is probably shooting me tonight anyway but whatever.

Yes. Because scum shoots those that are likely to be lynched. Werid

[The Crusher]

2 hours ago, Spoot-Face said:

I think we should have 4 people volunteer to stab someone, even though it only takes 3 to kill scum.

Who has already used their steely knife, and on who?

Still have mine. Planning on slamming it into Lizzie's forehead and make the worlds first Lizardcorn. 

[Spoot-Face]

27 minutes ago, Andrej The Giant said:

I used mine this phase. Someone knows who I am targeting.

I think it's beneficial to the Town if we keep a public record of who stabbed who, so we can easily coordinate and evaluate if a stabbing did or did not work. Our knives are limited, we've already lost two Town to NKs, are about to loose two more, and possibly have lost more out of Nolder, Pac, and Hallia dropping out. We cannot afford any more missteps. I don't think this is a time for being secretive.

[A.J.]

4 minutes ago, Spoot-Face said:

I think it's beneficial to the Town if we keep a public record of who stabbed who, so we can easily coordinate and evaluate if a stabbing did or did not work. Our knives are limited, we've already lost two Town to NKs, are about to loose two more, and possibly have lost more out of Nolder, Pac, and Hallia dropping out. We cannot afford any more missteps. I don't think this is a time for being secretive.

I stabbed Shad.

I also messaged someone telling them I was going to and asking them to join.

they can confirm later

[Jetsfan80]

I'll gladly stab Shad tonight.  If Shad can't be killed by steely knives it's possible he's the Beast:

 

Quote

And in the master's chambers, they gathered for the feast
They stab it with their steely knives, but they just can't kill the beast

 

[Dicetosser]

5 hours ago, Spoot-Face said:

Anyone else notice that the reads list that LK posted is stolen from 80's?

I really wish we could've lynched him now.

I had them all quoted up to compare.

4 hours ago, Spoot-Face said:

Gonna be away for a bit, but we should figure out who we want to steely knife. I think it should be one of the three competing trains before LK.

1. Shad

2. Chrja

3. 80

2 knives should be thrown at pral

2 hours ago, Spoot-Face said:

I think we should have 4 people volunteer to stab someone, even though it only takes 3 to kill scum.

Who has already used their steely knife, and on who?

me at pral

 

[Krak]

38 minutes ago, Spoot-Face said:

I think it's beneficial to the Town if we keep a public record of who stabbed who, so we can easily coordinate and evaluate if a stabbing did or did not work. Our knives are limited, we've already lost two Town to NKs, are about to loose two more, and possibly have lost more out of Nolder, Pac, and Hallia dropping out. We cannot afford any more missteps. I don't think this is a time for being secretive.

 

**** the Librarian 

[Dicetosser]

14 minutes ago, Jetsfan80 said:

I'll gladly stab Shad tonight.  If Shad can't be killed by steely knives it's possible he's the Beast:

 

 

this bugs me. 2 of these things are not the same

 

if shad dies I don't think we clear 80 for it

[Krak]

3 minutes ago, Dicetosser said:

this bugs me. 2 of these things are not the same

 

if shad dies I don't think we clear 80 for it

how do you mean?

[Dicetosser]

the veats thing is conjecture. if Shad does not die I am aware of one definite reason for it.

 

and there could be conjecture about roles as per usual.

 

but if 80 has a knife he should know the one definite reason and I don't get why he would throw that out there if he does.

[Dicetosser]

and I am quite serious that 2 knives should go at pral

[Krak]

Not trying to be a Verbal (read:douche)

 

does veats=beast?

[Jetsfan80]

14 minutes ago, Dicetosser said:

the veats thing is conjecture. if Shad does not die I am aware of one definite reason for it.

I said he COULD be the beast, not that it's the ONLY explanation. 

[Spoot-Face]

1 hour ago, Andrej The Giant said:

I stabbed Shad.

I also messaged someone telling them I was going to and asking them to join.

they can confirm later

Then that person needs to step forward. We should only have 4 people stabbing Shad, so as not to waste more knives than needed. So far it's:

1. Racoon.

2. AJ

3. Spoot (pending)

4. 80 (pending)

5. Mystery person (pending or already done?)

55 minutes ago, Jetsfan80 said:

I'll gladly stab Shad tonight.  If Shad can't be killed by steely knives it's possible he's the Beast:

 

 

Okay. Not sure how I feel about that speculation, though.

40 minutes ago, Krak said:

 

**** the Librarian 

lol Imma take that as a joke.

44 minutes ago, Dicetosser said:

I had them all quoted up to compare.

2 knives should be thrown at pral

me at pral

 

Noted.

39 minutes ago, Dicetosser said:

this bugs me. 2 of these things are not the same

 

if shad dies I don't think we clear 80 for it

My thoughts, too.

[Spoot-Face]

49 minutes ago, Dicetosser said:

I had them all quoted up to compare.

2 knives should be thrown at pral

me at pral

 

Just for clarification, what night did you stab Pral?

[Krak]

1 minute ago, Spoot-Face said:

Just for clarification, what night did you stab Pral?

******* csarmi all over again

[Spoot-Face]

1 minute ago, Krak said:

******* csarmi all over again

?Que?

[The Crusher]

I havent stabbed Lizzie yet.  Anybody need a third stabbing?

[Krak]

I'm stabbing Pral tonight and Dice said he already did soooooo

[Spoot-Face]

2 minutes ago, The Crusher said:

I havent stabbed Lizzie yet.  Anybody need a third stabbing?

Shad so far has 2 claimed stabs (Raccoon, AJ), with 3 other people willing to stab (Spoot, 80, AJ's Mystery Person). We only need two out of those three to stab, but we need them to openly claim it.

Pral has one claimed stab (Dice), so needs 3 more stabs, just to be safe.

I'm willing to stab Pral with you and someone else, if 80 and AJ's mystery person comes forward to stab Shad.

[Spoot-Face]

3 minutes ago, Krak said:

I'm stabbing Pral tonight and Dice said he already did soooooo

Okay. Noted.

[Spoot-Face]

Steely Knife Victim Log

Victim: Shad

1. Raccoon (N1)

2. AJ (N2)

3. 80 (pending)

4. Mystery Person (pending)

5. Spoot (pending)

 

Victim: Pral

1.Dice (N1)

2. Crusher (pending)

3. Krak (pending)

4. Spoot (pending)

[Spoot-Face]

Once you stab someone, confirm it by saying "I stabbed __"

I want AJ's mystery person to come forward. If he does, and both he and 80 confirm stabbing Shad, then Crusher, Krak, and I can confirm stabbing Pral.

This can give us some good intel and we'll go from there.

[a_very_fat_raccoon]

I've already sent in my knife on Shad for tonight. Can change if you need.