Poll Deleted (I screwed up) SORRY!

[Sarge4Tide]

Sorry......made a mistake on the poll.  My bad.  I apologize y'all!

[32EBoozer]

Keeping the BYU guy over Lewis and Edoga. Pretty simple exercise apart from that. If they keep 10, as they should, I keep Lewis or Teton Saltes

Edited July 12, 2021 by 32EBoozer

[mrcoops]

Missing Conor McDermott, who the Jets seem to like. He probably has a decent shot to stick over Edoga.

[Rolloffjet]

I picked 10 sorry. Think we will go with 10 anyway 

[Sarge4Tide]

I messed the poll up, sorry!  

[32EBoozer]

1 minute ago, Sarge4Tide said:

I messed the poll up, sorry!  

I’m not certain it required deletion over Conor McDermott.

[joewilly12]

[SAR I]

I chose Mark Sanchez as #1 QB in Jets history and put Namath #2 and Favre as #3.

SAR I

[joewilly12]

5 hours ago, SAR I said:

I chose Mark Sanchez as #1 QB in Jets history and put Namath #2 and Favre as #3.

SAR I

[jgb]

Damn, I missed this. Too late to enter a vote for Tom Tupa?

Hear me out. 4 of the top 5 Jets in career passer rating are skill position players (C-Mart, Jamison Crowder, Blaire Thomas and Freeman McNeil) who combined for 5 attempts between them.

The only one in the top-5 who took snaps as an actual QB? Tommy T. The best QB in Jets history.

Trivia: The 5 attempts referenced above resulted in 5 completions for 5 TDs.

[Smashmouth]

On 7/12/2021 at 2:45 PM, Sarge4Tide said:

I messed the poll up, sorry!  

I will never vote in your poll's ever again. 

[jgb]

On 7/12/2021 at 11:36 PM, SAR I said:

I chose Mark Sanchez as #1 QB in Jets history and put Namath #2 and Favre as #3.

SAR I

Now do the same for worst HCs in Jets history 

[SAR I]

12 minutes ago, jgb said:

Now do the same for worst HCs in Jets history 

1.  Rex Ryan

2.  Herman Edwards

3.  Walt Michaels

All three had teams capable of getting to and winning a Super Bowl.  And all failed miserably.

SAR I

[Defense Wins Championships]

31 minutes ago, SAR I said:

1.  Rex Ryan

2.  Herman Edwards

3.  Walt Michaels

All three had teams capable of getting to and winning a Super Bowl.  And all failed miserably.

SAR I

Herm Edwards as a Jet = .488% (3 playoff appearances in 5 years).

Rex Ryan as a Jet = .479% (2 AFC Championship Games). 

Walt Michaels as a Jet = .454% (2 playoff appearances in 6 years).

Vs 

(Your favorite coach who failed miserably)...

Adam Gase as a Jet = .281% (@ 9-23 with 0 playoffs throughout 2 years and FIRED after his embarrassing 2nd year of 2-14 (.125%). 

? ?

Adam Gase was pure trash and only Rich Kotite was ever worse than Gase. It's alarming how you think Gase was "better than" Herm/Rex/Walt etc especially since you told us the other day that you "don't like Adam Gase anymore".

[jgb]

6 hours ago, SAR I said:

1.  Rex Ryan

2.  Herman Edwards

3.  Walt Michaels

All three had teams capable of getting to and winning a Super Bowl.  And all failed miserably.

SAR I

Thanks. It's very interesting how you punish success (could've done even more!) and reward failure (bad situation!). Seems backwards, to me.

[SAR I]

4 hours ago, jgb said:

Thanks. It's very interesting how you punish success (could've done even more!) and reward failure (bad situation!). Seems backwards, to me.

When a team has a terrible roster, the expectations for growth fall on the GM.

When a team has a stacked roster, the expectations for success falls on the HC.

Rex Ryan had one of the most talented rosters in team history and blew it because he was trying to solidify his reputation as a defensive genius and spent no money on offense and went with a raw rookie QB on a win-right-now team.  His defense failed, his strategy was flawed, he had a huge hand in drafts and free agency, and he selfishly cost us additional playoff runs and a Super Bowl appearance.

Herman Edwards had the most talented roster in team history courtesy of Bill Parcells and blew it because of his in-game decision making, clock management, and playcalling.  Stuck with Testaverde way too long costing us homefield in 2002.  Stuck with Pennington way too long with no backup plan costing us 2003, 2005, and 2007 seasons due to injury.

Walt Michaels had the most talented defense in team history and a young offense with loads of potential but was outsmarted by Don Shula and imploded, putting the team in the hands of buffoon Joe Walton who was too new and too stupid and didn't draft Dan Marino ensuring a decade of Jets futility.

These were the worst head coaches in team history.  Because they had very good rosters and did nothing with them.  Because they had critical flaws that were on display in important games.  Bowles, Gase, even Kotite, had horrible rosters and no chance to win at all. 

SAR I

[BettyBoop]

10 hours ago, SAR I said:

When a team has a terrible roster, the expectations for growth fall on the GM.

When a team has a stacked roster, the expectations for success falls on the HC.

Rex Ryan had one of the most talented rosters in team history and blew it because he was trying to solidify his reputation as a defensive genius and spent no money on offense and went with a raw rookie QB on a win-right-now team.  His defense failed, his strategy was flawed, he had a huge hand in drafts and free agency, and he selfishly cost us additional playoff runs and a Super Bowl appearance.

Herman Edwards had the most talented roster in team history courtesy of Bill Parcells and blew it because of his in-game decision making, clock management, and playcalling.  Stuck with Testaverde way too long costing us homefield in 2002.  Stuck with Pennington way too long with no backup plan costing us 2003, 2005, and 2007 seasons due to injury.

Walt Michaels had the most talented defense in team history and a young offense with loads of potential but was outsmarted by Don Shula and imploded, putting the team in the hands of buffoon Joe Walton who was too new and too stupid and didn't draft Dan Marino ensuring a decade of Jets futility.

These were the worst head coaches in team history.  Because they had very good rosters and did nothing with them.  Because they had critical flaws that were on display in important games.  Bowles, Gase, even Kotite, had horrible rosters and no chance to win at all. 

SAR I

There once was a poster named SORE,

Who just didn’’t know what was in store,

He’d post his yuck,

We’d call him a schmuck,

And he would just post some more.

[jeremy2020]

On 7/12/2021 at 12:56 PM, Sarge4Tide said:

Sorry......made a mistake on the poll.  My bad.  I apologize y'all!

Apology not accepted. It's going to take 100 years to make this up to me. 

[BettyBoop]

2 hours ago, BettyBoop said:

There once was a poster named SORE,

Who just didn’’t know what was in store,

He’d post his yuck,

We’d call him a schmuck,

And then he would just post some more.

 

[jgb]

12 hours ago, jeremy2020 said:

Apology not accepted. It's going to take 100 years to make this up to me. 

So you'll get over it before the Jets win another ring

[Jet2020]

On 7/12/2021 at 4:36 PM, SAR I said:

I chose Mark Sanchez as #1 QB in Jets history and put Namath #2 and Favre as #3.

SAR I

I’m fairly confident this is a serious sentence. 

[jgb]

14 minutes ago, Jet2020 said:

I’m fairly confident this is a serious sentence. 

Either that or he's setting a record for longest time spent in-character. This is a level of method acting that would impress Daniel Day Lewis.

[Fantasy Island]

On 7/12/2021 at 1:56 PM, Sarge4Tide said:

Sorry......made a mistake on the poll.  My bad.  I apologize y'all!

[Savage69]

On 7/14/2021 at 8:51 AM, SAR I said:

When a team has a terrible roster, the expectations for growth fall on the GM.

When a team has a stacked roster, the expectations for success falls on the HC.

Rex Ryan had one of the most talented rosters in team history and blew it because he was trying to solidify his reputation as a defensive genius and spent no money on offense and went with a raw rookie QB on a win-right-now team.  His defense failed, his strategy was flawed, he had a huge hand in drafts and free agency, and he selfishly cost us additional playoff runs and a Super Bowl appearance.

Herman Edwards had the most talented roster in team history courtesy of Bill Parcells and blew it because of his in-game decision making, clock management, and playcalling.  Stuck with Testaverde way too long costing us homefield in 2002.  Stuck with Pennington way too long with no backup plan costing us 2003, 2005, and 2007 seasons due to injury.

Walt Michaels had the most talented defense in team history and a young offense with loads of potential but was outsmarted by Don Shula and imploded, putting the team in the hands of buffoon Joe Walton who was too new and too stupid and didn't draft Dan Marino ensuring a decade of Jets futility.

These were the worst head coaches in team history.  Because they had very good rosters and did nothing with them.  Because they had critical flaws that were on display in important games.  Bowles, Gase, even Kotite, had horrible rosters and no chance to win at all. 

SAR I

And Mangini had a future HOF QB and never won a playoff game yet the QB he let go took a 1-15 team to the playoffs and won the East..

[SAR I]

2 hours ago, Savage69 said:

And Mangini had a future HOF QB and never won a playoff game yet the QB he let go took a 1-15 team to the playoffs and won the East..

I don't have Mangini bottom three because he was sitting at 8-3 and if Brett Favre didn't get injured we would have won the division and perhaps even made a Super Bowl appearance.

SAR I

[Savage69]

7 minutes ago, SAR I said:

I don't have Mangini bottom three because he was sitting at 8-3 and if Brett Favre didn't get injured we would have won the division and perhaps even made a Super Bowl appearance.

SAR I

When Farve was injured he has his 3rd year 2nd rd QB on the bench I guess he never developed him huh?? Rex got to 2 AFCCG's with a rookie and 2nd year QB(That you love) that alone puts him passed Mangini.

[Defense Wins Championships]

2 hours ago, SAR I said:

I don't have Mangini bottom three because he was sitting at 8-3 and if Brett Favre didn't get injured we would have won the division and perhaps even made a Super Bowl appearance.

SAR I

But yet you have Rex Ryan as your bottom 3 despite 2 AFC championship game Appearances with a Rookie/2nd year QB? 

What did your favorite Adam Gase ever do as a Jets HC before being FIRED that deserves to be ranked ahead of Rex Ryan by your expert HC standards? 

2-14?

[SAR I]

4 hours ago, Defense Wins Championships said:

But yet you have Rex Ryan as your bottom 3 despite 2 AFC championship game Appearances with a Rookie/2nd year QB? 

What did your favorite Adam Gase ever do as a Jets HC before being FIRED that deserves to be ranked ahead of Rex Ryan by your expert HC standards? 

2-14?

You are supposed to be leaving me alone. Don’t force me to report you.

SAR I

[slimjasi]

On 7/14/2021 at 3:47 AM, jgb said:

Thanks. It's very interesting how you punish success (could've done even more!) and reward failure (bad situation!). Seems backwards, to me.

Indeed. The psychological aspect to this sort of thing is very interesting to me. I see this among other fanbases, as well. 

[slimjasi]

On 7/14/2021 at 7:51 AM, SAR I said:

Herman Edwards had the most talented roster in team history courtesy of Bill Parcells and blew it because of his in-game decision making, clock management, and playcalling.  Stuck with Testaverde way too long costing us homefield in 2002.  Stuck with Pennington way too long with no backup plan costing us 2003, 2005, and 2007 seasons due to injury.

Which Herm roster was the best in team history? 

[CSNY]

On 7/13/2021 at 9:51 PM, SAR I said:

1.  Rex Ryan

2.  Herman Edwards

3.  Walt Michaels

All three had teams capable of getting to and winning a Super Bowl.  And all failed miserably.

SAR I

SAR 1 you are very entertaining in your analysis. You truly know how to get a rise out of individuals that wish to engage on these posts as we all know that you don’t even believe what you post Keep it up it’s good for the board. 

[Defense Wins Championships]

Speaking of Adam Gase? 

@bla bla bla

 

Proof that this man along with 99.9% of our fan base never wanted Adam Gase from day one and hated Adam Gase from day one and why? Because (as a fan base) we were the opposite of SAR I and never wanted that p.o.s scumbag as HC to begin with.