HBO WATCHMEN Mafia - Game Thread -TULSA WINS!!!

[Jetsfan80]

9 minutes ago, CTM said:

discovered my refrigerator is dead and have to deal with food, and probably pick a new fridge and figure out where to buy since it's almost 13 years old ..  I'm going to be mia for awhile ..

Purchase some soap and shampoo while you're at it.  

Good luck.  

[Arsis]

1 minute ago, Jetsfan80 said:

JiF is a gay man pretending he's straight.  

Arsis is a straight man pretending he's gay.  

Or maybe you're just that good looking that you can turn a straight man gay.

[The Crusher]

Just now, Nynaeve said:

He is being truthful

Oh I know. Dude shared a pick few years back had the Jason Mamoa hair going. 

[Jetsfan80]

11 minutes ago, Arsis said:

You can say anything about me you want but I draw the line at little. I'm a 6'3 285lb powerlifter. I haven't been little since 3rd grade.

 

6 minutes ago, The Crusher said:

Pics of GTFO

Shirtless.

@joewilly12

[The Crusher]

Just now, Arsis said:

Or maybe you're just that good looking that you can turn a straight man gay.

It took him 30 years For him to get laid. I think we are all safe. 

[The Crusher]

3 minutes ago, Arsis said:

The hair started to get too long and annoying so I chopped it and donated it to a cancer wig thing.

Solid bro. My wife and youngest daughter  have done that. Locks of love I think. 

[Jetsfan80]

1 minute ago, Arsis said:

Or maybe you're just that good looking that you can turn a straight man gay.

 

[Jetsfan80]

2 minutes ago, The Crusher said:

It took him 30 years For him to get laid. I think we are all safe. 

* 33

[Pac]

54 minutes ago, DPR said:

You misspelled Stark lol

I'm going to look around a bit.  Especially since playing on a phone sucks.

[SMC]

15 minutes ago, CTM said:

discovered my refrigerator is dead and have to deal with food, and probably pick a new fridge and figure out where to buy since it's almost 13 years old ..  I'm going to be mia for awhile ..

PC Richards is saying they'll deliver appliances in 24 hours.  They deliver it to your doorstep but you have to bring it in the house and install.  They'll take away old fridge if left outside.  You and the misses can take care of that.

BTW, my washer died the 1st week of quarantine and PC Richards sent a repairmen to fix, but it was 2 weeks later.

[SMC]

Official Vote Count:

Stark (3) - JIF, Hess, 80

Arsis (1) - Dice

80 (1) - Nyn

Smash (1) - Pac

JIF (1) - AVM

With 17 Citizens of Tulsa, it takes 9 to arrest 

[HessStation]

13 minutes ago, Jetsfan80 said:

JiF is a gay man pretending he's straight.  

Arsis is a straight man pretending he's gay.  

Arsis is an eater of worlds.

[The Crusher]

1 minute ago, SMC said:

PC Richards is saying they'll deliver appliances in 24 hours.  They deliver it to your doorstep but you have to bring it in the house and install.  They'll take away old fridge if left outside.  You and the misses can take care of that.

BTW, my washer died the 1st week of quarantine and PC Richards sent a repairmen to fix, but it was 2 weeks later.

Lucky for CTM he doesn’t wash his clothes 

[HessStation]

12 minutes ago, Arsis said:

Or maybe you're just that good looking that you can turn a straight man gay.

Naw that’s me 

[Pac]

Dpr is playing like a wounded pig.  Later on I'll have to do a deep dive into his spastic game thus far.

[Drums]

On 4/26/2020 at 11:59 AM, Nolder said:

Sorry sorry, was around yesterday but then got distracted.

Here is Nolder admitting he is purposely avoiding the thread

[JustInFudge]

21 hours ago, Drums said:

Ended my class early bitches.

I have a few minutes to decide if I want to vote for JC. This is my third game with him. Last game he did a lot of the same stuff, plus a screech porn review, and I was calling for his head for a few days and no one wanted to go along with it. Ironically it seems opposite this time. He seems the same except more aggressive and I am not sure if that is good or bad.

Being that I am a noob, the Dandie situation stands out to me and JC was one of the people fanning the flames. DPR was another so that's what caused me to look closer at him. JC is going to **** with my reads the entire game probably because of his play style so maybe it is better to vote him now and cross it off the list.

Now that Dandie situation, as I said, had me looking at DPR and I feel my notes on DPR start off pretty ugly but then I come away unsure. I don't have much to go on after the Dandie incident. I expect to be attacked for these notes but I would like to hear what people think of them and that's why I will share:

 DPR (copied from my google doc so suck it):

• Has a weird vote on Barry in post 500

• Got carried away about CTM revealing (multiple posts)

• Really wants CTM to reveal or at least promise to reveal in post 550

• The very next post (post 551) he puts off anything with Dandie until D2, I like that

• But quite quickly, he heated up on Dandie and votes Dandie in post 668 -- barely a page later. He agrees with Jif to “kill it” 

• Was low key fanning the Dandie flames

  • For example, quoting a CTM post where CTM was quoting JC, DPR gives his thoughts on Dandie ending with “why not clear this account with a run up and reveal” in post 712 - why is he so into reveals?

• Calls out Barry for overcorrecting in post 744 but I don’t really see it

• Gets into a weird little tussle with Nyn about JC 

• Unvotes Dandie in post 862

• He does seem to be paying attention

Overall, I feel like DPR is either gullible or scum, looking to latch onto something but I am unsure and since there is no train even close to happening for him and we are super close to deadline:

vote JC

 

While I was looking back for Stark's reveal, I came across this that I must have missed during my catch up...

another post of goobly gook to vote the biggest train.  2nd time he did this on D1.

[DPR]

8 minutes ago, SMC said:

PC Richards is saying they'll deliver appliances in 24 hours.  They deliver it to your doorstep but you have to bring it in the house and install.  They'll take away old fridge if left outside.  You and the misses can take care of that.

BTW, my washer died the 1st week of quarantine and PC Richards sent a repairmen to fix, but it was 2 weeks later.

How many are there?

2 minutes ago, Pac said:

Dpr is playing like a wounded pig.  Later on I'll have to do a deep dive into his spastic game thus far.

What does this even mean? Deep dive away Cousteau and pay attention this time so you can come up with something better than you did earlier with the super-fake theory omg 

[DPR]

6 minutes ago, Drums said:

Here is Nolder admitting he is purposely avoiding the thread

Every Nolder post from the past 72 hours is admitting he is avoiding the thread, except for his trains vote 

[JustInFudge]

21 hours ago, Stark said:

wth.

 

I am:

Calvin "Cal" Abar, a form of Doctor Manhattan. If I am lynched or killed the game is over. However, I have the ability to transfer my power. 

 

21 hours ago, Stark said:

i am not giving the specifics to the power or mechanics on how i have to transfer the power because that information would likely be helpful to scum and maybe even more that town

 

 

 

21 hours ago, Stark said:

no, i win with town

Here's the reveal.  He gave this type of pieced meal reveal last game as rolled town.  Not overly concerned with the flow of it more so the content.

Has he not posted since? 

 

[Drums]

9 minutes ago, JiF said:

While I was looking back for Stark's reveal, I came across this that I must have missed during my catch up...

another post of goobly gook to vote the biggest train.  2nd time he did this on D1.

We were consolidating our votes due to deadline. JC always seems a little scummy and Stark didn't seem scummy to me so I voted JC. That's all there is to that. Interesting that you said I was spinning a narrative but here you are doing that. 

[Drums]

8 minutes ago, DPR said:

Every Nolder post from the past 72 hours is admitting he is avoiding the thread, except for his trains vote 

I know, it's happened quite a bit. That comes off to me as scummy. 

[Drums]

Vote Nolder

[JustInFudge]

Just now, Drums said:

We were consolidating our votes due to deadline. JC always seems a little scummy and Stark didn't seem scummy to me so I voted JC. That's all there is to that. Interesting that you said I was spinning a narrative but here you are doing that. 

Huh?  2 time on D1 you posted a big long post of meh to vote the leading train.  Those are facts.  

It's more genuine when you just say, JC seems scummier than Stark and then vote.

The ridiculous over the top rationale is pingy.

[DPR]

1 minute ago, JiF said:

Huh?  2 time on D1 you posted a big long post of meh to vote the leading train.  Those are facts.  

It's more genuine when you just say, JC seems scummier than Stark and then vote.

The ridiculous over the top rationale is pingy.

What? Rationale and details ware what helps town - providing them is harder for scum than it is for town. Just saying "JC seems scummier than Stark" and then voting is next to useless. 

[HessStation]

3 minutes ago, DPR said:

What? Rationale and details ware what helps town - providing them is harder for scum than it is for town. Just saying "JC seems scummier than Stark" and then voting is next to useless. 

Agreed

[AVM]

1 hour ago, JiF said:

Smash also has weird obsession and vendetta's.  I could totally see him as scum following my lead to a townie so he could use it against me in a get behind the JiF fashion.  He's also someone on my list of who would kill Crusher N1. 

We need to kill Stark but Smash will be easy to read soon enough. 

This is a great point, though...

Not specific to Smash, but it tells me the scum team is probably "vet heavy" this game. Crush is a difficult lynch, as we talked about during this very game. 

1 hour ago, JiF said:

I dont see how I'm off, just doing my thing over here.

What's your thoughts on Starks role? 

It's kind of hard to explain, honestly...can't put my finger on it.

As for Stark, I think I said at some point yesterday that both he and AJ had oddly specific reveals to be fake. Would have to be given a safe reveal, or to a point I think you made....is being honest but is somehow a 3rd party player? That just didn't make sense me to theme-wise.

I haven't seen the show, but it fits with the story that I know. The fact that he's said he can pass it on and implied there is more to the role he doesn't want to share also contributes to me feeling pretty good about him...a complex set-up but absolutely doable. When you factor in that there have been at least two "deaths" that

48 minutes ago, Drums said:

That actually makes sense to me but his reveal was so specific that it seemed plausible. 

Yes

[Drums]

2 minutes ago, JiF said:

Huh?  2 time on D1 you posted a big long post of meh to vote the leading train.  Those are facts.  

It's more genuine when you just say, JC seems scummier than Stark and then vote.

The ridiculous over the top rationale is pingy.

I see what you mean about making a long post and then voting someone like I did with you but even though my notes were more on someone else it doesn't mean I think they're scummy. I actually came away feeling more town leans on the longer note people so I voted elsewhere. I still think you are scum I still am fine with the way I voted you. 

 

[JustInFudge]

9 minutes ago, DPR said:

What? Rationale and details ware what helps town - providing them is harder for scum than it is for town. Just saying "JC seems scummier than Stark" and then voting is next to useless. 

Rationale and details? Coming from you after last game. dude

And I'm specifically talking about when joining a train.  If he did this genuinely on his own, totally different story but it was contrived to vote JC. 

 

[Stark]

9 hours ago, Jetsfan80 said:

Just checked the opening scene to see what SMC said about Doctor Manhattan. It does seem that, using words like “domination” and “unlimited power” (which match what we know about Dr Manhattan from the show/movie), that Town is f**cked without Dr Manhattan. Not sure how his death = straight up game over though.

 

@Stark what else can you tell us about your role?

I said about as much as i was comfortable with for the reveal. 

57 minutes ago, JiF said:

He also said he could pass his powers on...if he's town, why would he let the game end if he was killed?  

He cant just sit out there with that claim, sorry.

telling how the powers can be passed could play into scums hands. that's all i really want to say about it.

33 minutes ago, Jetsfan80 said:

* 33

you have a jamal adams jersey? the double entendre .... 

--------------------

as far as the role / power... i can't just pass it on a whim. i do have some protections against certain events and that is part of the reason i claimed because i had some protection. 

[Drums]

18 minutes ago, AVM said:

This is a great point, though...

Not specific to Smash, but it tells me the scum team is probably "vet heavy" this game. Crush is a difficult lynch, as we talked about during this very game. 

It's kind of hard to explain, honestly...can't put my finger on it.

As for Stark, I think I said at some point yesterday that both he and AJ had oddly specific reveals to be fake. Would have to be given a safe reveal, or to a point I think you made....is being honest but is somehow a 3rd party player? That just didn't make sense me to theme-wise.

I haven't seen the show, but it fits with the story that I know. The fact that he's said he can pass it on and implied there is more to the role he doesn't want to share also contributes to me feeling pretty good about him...a complex set-up but absolutely doable. When you factor in that there have been at least two "deaths" that

Yes

It's kind of interesting that you say that because when I was rereading last night I saw this:

On 4/28/2020 at 8:14 PM, Pac said:

Today I'm poking multiple players and casting suspicion at what I deem to be curious posts.

Today you are locked in on trying to get me lynched using false pretenses.  

I don't think there's a chance people will lynch you today out of fear or admiration or whatever..  at this point I'm content to have you at least explain your reason for wanting me lynched.  People can decide whether or not they like your answers later in the game if you're still around.

Out of respect for SMC I'll be trying this game from the beginning.  That will likely lead to my early demise from fearful scum but that goes with the territory when you are a scum killer extraordinaire.

Edit: Just in case it is unclear, Pac is talking to Crusher 

[deckerfan]

Official Vote Count:

Stark (3) - JIF, Hess, 80

Arsis (1) - Dice

80 (1) - Nyn

Smash (1) - Pac

JIF (1) - AVM

Nolder (1) - Drums

 

With 17 Citizens of Tulsa, it takes 9 to arrest 

[Drums]

On 4/26/2020 at 4:44 PM, Jetsfan80 said:

 

 

 

 

 

 

Hmm, So CTM had plenty of opportunities to reveal at L-2 from the looks of it.  

Odd that Hess changed his vote for Pac and THEN asked for CTM's reveal.

This game quickly broke out of the joke phase here.  Getting the Hippie's alignment looks like it would be a good result.  

80 you said your thing on Stark was your best but I think this was a good post. It's the one I asked Nolder to explain is gross on "multiple levels", but I thought it gave me something to think about.

Looking back at the CTM vote:

Crusher jumps off when it gets serious (L2) which basically saves CTM so 1-2 people peel off and then...

Hess jumps on the train for what I think is to try to get it back to going. It isn't working so Hess jumps off and goes to Pac then asks CTm if he is going to reveal. @HessStation what was the reasoning for that?

Then Nolder votes CTM

Then Hess jumps back on CTM's train putting him at L3

I know Hess is a weird player but this sequence did jump out to me a bit.

Early D1 actually has some pretty interesting little things so I was wrong early in the game, but I am still rereading. 

 

[A.J.]

5 hours ago, Dicetosser said:

no i thought i spotted a lie in a post. Had nothing to do with meta

and yet you never bothered to end the argument you just let AJ get run up and played the confused hillbilly

actually aj SAID he didnt know him

Careful Nyn   you know how powerful that phrase is lol   

 

 

Vote Arsis

Again, why did you assume lie first?

[Arsis]

Just now, A.J. said:

Again, why did you assume lie first?

That's what I don't get at all. That's a huge leap in logic for something so tiny.