Would you be in favor of the Jets starting Bryce Petty this season 2015

[joewilly12]

It seems we have Geno haters,Fitzpatrick haters and Flynn haters.

 

Discuss and vote. 

[JoeC36]

no. At the practices Ive been at and the game on thursday, it looked to me like he was not ready to be on an NFL field. Will he ever be? I dont know, but I do know I do not want to just thrown him out there and possibly ruin any confidence he may gain by sitting and learning for a year or two. 

[JustInFudge]

Hell No!!!!!

 

He's a project and he's not ready.  The Jets finally have a chance to bring a rookie QB along and you to force him into action?

 

Start Fitz and start doing whatever the **** you have to do to get a QB in 2016.  

[JoeC36]

It seems we have Geno haters,Fitzpatrick haters and Flynn haters.

 

Discuss and vote. 

 

Why would you be in favor of it?

[Jet Nut]

It seems we have Geno haters,Fitzpatrick haters and Flynn haters.

Discuss and vote.

What does any of this have to do with the need to let the guy develop? Why make the same mistake as Rex?

Wasn't this same exact thread started weeks ago? Were you the only one in favor of Petty starting there too?

[nyjunc]

if they don't feel he is ready I don't want him to play at all.  Do not rush him, he needs to be developed. 

[jetsjets]

Start Petty? Did you see the last game?

[jgb]

Yeah let's break him too.

[dbatesman]

Great thread. Compelling and rich.

[JoeC36]

Great thread. Compelling and rich.

 

I know rich and this sir is not rich

[Skeptable]

Absolutely not

[Spoot-Face]

[JoeC36]

this could be the most lopsided poll in JN history that I haven't edited the votes on. 

[Persiussa]

No way, let him develop and don't ruin him. The last time we had a qb that sat on the bench it was Pennington and he came out ready to go. Would be nice to not rush someone on to the field.

[joewilly12]

What does any of this have to do with the need to let the guy develop? Why make the same mistake as Rex?

Wasn't this same exact thread started weeks ago? Were you the only one in favor of Petty starting there too?

I posted for discussion purposes not for arguments sake.  Other teams have thrown rookies into the fire why not the Jets.

[The Crusher]

No. He will sucks worse now than later.  

[Jet Nut]

I posted for discussion purposes not for arguments sake.  Other teams have thrown rookies into the fire why not the Jets.

Did you miss the last two QBs that we threw into the fire?

[joewilly12]

Did you miss the last two QBs that we threw into the fire?

Maybe we get lucky this time 

[sh4dy15]

This would be a terrible decision. Luckily I don't think there is anyway this happens.

[Jet Nut]

Maybe we get lucky this time

Ok, that makes sense then.

[Jetlife33]

Can we at least try and make believe we're going to groom him?

[Larz]

would you be in favor of taking away joewilly's thread starting priviledges for a month ?

 

discuss

[Jet Nut]

I know rich and this sir is not rich

Or compelling

[FloridaJetsFan]

would you be in favor of taking away joewilly's thread starting priviledges for a month ?

 

discuss

I remember when Slats was tougher and would cut him without even blinking, but I think everyone's gotten soft since JI went down,

[Cornfed]

No NFL experience, not a can't miss prospect, and played not so great in only action so far. That would be a no for me.

[Mogglez]

Maybe we get lucky this time

LMFAO. SOLD!

[Charlie Brown]

YEA LETS RUIN ANOTHER QB BY PUTTING HIM IN TO SOON!!!!!

[Jet Blast]

No. Absolutely not.

 

Let him develop over this season and next and we may have a QB. Start him now and he is ruined.

[Bocajetfan]

YEA LETS RUIN ANOTHER QB BY PUTTING HIM IN TO SOON!!!!!

My thoughts exactly. Not saying he is the future just he is not now. Can he develop possibly has the body and arm, but needs to show he ca transition to the NFL game. One training camp does not develop a QB.

[Mike135]

Nope. 

 

I will say though, come December, if we're mathematically eliminated and we know Geno isn't the QB of the future, then I could be for letting Petty play if coaches feel it'd be beneficial.  No sense in having Geno put together another decent December (and ruining a decent draft pick) when Petty could be getting valuable practice/experience.  The problem with that would be conveying the point that it is only for experience/practice, and by starting him in December, that by no means equates to Petty being the starter come 2016.

[Ken Schroy]

Not ready. Why would we want to rush this? Fitz has to get hurt for it to happen.

[bealeb319]

I don't particularly love any of the Quarterbacks that we have on our roster but if I had to choose for this season I would want the one who gives us the best chance to win starting this season and in my opinion that goes Geno, Fitz, Flynn, Petty then Heaps in that order right now (minus Genos broken jaw and all). I think Petty could be a serviceable QB which is really all of us have wanted (I would be happy in the Flacco, Stafford, Ryan teir of QB skill level) but if we want to see him reach his potential we cant rush him. Having Flynn on the roster might be good in developing Petty as Flynn learned from Rodgers who is arguably the best QB in the league currently. The downside to sitting Petty is that if we have a bad season we are likely to draft QB early next year and that QB would likely be given an unfair advantage over any other QBs on our roster during the annual "competition" as he would be Mac and Bowles  guy.

[Jet Nut]

Not ready. Why would we want to rush this? Fitz has to get hurt for it to happen.

Because fans of the Jets suffer from an inability to show patience?

[jgb]

Another positive of Fitz starting, much better mentor than jawbreaker smith.

[joewilly12]

would you be in favor of taking away joewilly's thread starting priviledges for a month ?

 

discuss

Easy Larz its still the off season I know everyone is upset about the situation of the QB position here just talking football no harm no foul.